Book of Heroes

Luck-Based Progress :(

First let me say that I've tried to be very favorable towards BoH and even 1.5; defending it against others who have jumped to judge. After all, payment is voluntary and the game up to this point has been phenomenal. That being said:

I'm sure everyone has an opinion on this and many may disagree, but I wanted to hear what other people have to say about game progression beyond level 25 being mostly based on luck, even with day-in-day-out grinding.

I get it that Alchemist Lockboxes rarely (if ever) give GS now. That's built as a gambling device. That being said I just spent nearly 1MIL silver and didn't get a single GS. If Venan wants to make gold almost exclusive to money purchases, the decision is completely mine to spend money or not.

What I don't agree with is seemingly impossible quest lines now dictated by what would appear to be a sadistic monkey hell-bent on flinging mounds and mounds of excrement at you before you even get a glimmer of a nod (a.k.a Flux). Even after the "fix", my two characters had to spend hundreds more energy and multiple days just to finish the initial Fluxing quest requiring (5,5,5) of each type. Add to that the sketchy nature of portals in general, and you get a working man with a family that rarely has a chance to be on at exactly the right moment to succeed with the quest.

Add to this dilemma the fact that you can't unlock the new area until said Fluxing quest is Fluxing completed. This means that people like me now can't help our guilds in raids and every body gets fluxed.

This new grind, while endurable to a point, has sucked a lot of the fun from the game. Maybe drop rates, sequestered world events, or high rare item requirements alone would be bearable, but the combination of them is nearing the end of my threshold for pain. Right now it's just good for me that I have some fantabulous guild mates and a memory of a more enjoyable game. (see Marney, now you have to agree with me because I called you fantabulous :p)
I think we'll find that overall people are still pretty antsy about 1.5. Yes there are players that will probably leave because of the changes, but this happens in every facet of life that there is change. I will stand up with the bulk of players and say that Luck Based Questing is unnecessary. It kind of frustrates people, and only the lucky players will proceed at an enjoyable pace.

First of all I will say, I have completed the entire quest line for 1.5 and did thoroughly enjoy myself. Flux grinding is very possible in just a few sessions (especially now with the increased rate) and the time it took to complete (a week for me) was pretty nice. I don't want to blow through all of the game's content in a few hours.

As nice as all of the new content is though, the luck based quests... Quests, in my opinion, should take some time. You want players to be fully immersed in the story, giving a grind, but giving hope to work for. Luck based questing takes away this hope.

If I could recommend anything for 1.5, would be a coding similar to the quest line pre-25. Have us kill a particular number of monsters, let's say 10, to get a drop. This way it still takes a while to quest, costing 20 energy per drop, but still gives players an idea of what to plan for.

Even if this doesn't change though, players need to realise that being hand-fed drops can speed the game up enough that the devs wouldn't be able to churn out another update in time for players to reach the 'so-called' cap of progression of the current update. Many of the casual players will finish the flux quest and realise later on down the road that all the essence they racked up is going to be Immensely useful when they start high-end enchanting.

I implore everyone, just stick with it! It does get better ^~^!

With BoH Love~~

~~Katt
Rabid_Old_Lady wrote:Right now it's just good for me that I have some fantabulous guild mates and a memory of a more enjoyable game. (see Marney, now you have to agree with me because I called you fantabulous :p)
See, if you hasn't clarified I would have assumed you meant Katie, since she's prettier. ;)

But as I said in the guild chat, you do have valid points. The combination of a time limit, a set schedule, and rare drops will always make the portal quest a major bottleneck unless some kind of mechanic is implemented that makes it increasingly likely to get a needed drop as consecutive battles are won. That kind of thing could even reset to zero if the player left to heal or something, thus adding to the difficulty as well as making it more satisfying. I'm just relieved that my three characters are finally past it.

(edited for spelling)
I hate the luck based progress. The holiday goblin was an example of that. When he showed up, I might find him once or seven times (using about 60e) - no way to know. The Flux and VG quests are the same.

I know the complaints about Fellmarsh, but you always felt like you were making progress. On these, you don't know if you are going to spend 42e and make zero progress. It happens and it does suck the life out of you....
The holiday goblin wasn't required for a questline, though. The flux and elite grinds annoy people so much because they block them off from content. Flux is the worst offender, but hunting elites is silly too. The challenge should be in the fight itself, not in hoping that a random number generator will let you stumble across the right critter to kill.

Buff up the monsters, especially the elites. Make them able to easily kill an unprepared character, then let us find them and suffer for it.

But make us suffer because the quest is a challenge, not because it's a chore.
Marney wrote:The holiday goblin wasn't required for a questline, though. The flux and elite grinds annoy people so much because they block them off from content. Flux is the worst offender, but hunting elites is silly too. The challenge should be in the fight itself, not in hoping that a random number generator will let you stumble across the right critter to kill.

Buff up the monsters, especially the elites. Make them able to easily kill an unprepared character, then let us find them and suffer for it.

But make us suffer because the quest is a challenge, not because it's a chore.

+1 :) I'd take a challenging mob that really took me down a peg over 100 meager mobs any day!

P.S. I knew you would see so I had to mention you. Katie, Beeks, Katy and the rest of the gang are of course fabulous as well. As an update I finally got my (5,5,5) Fluxes and FINALLY managed to open the new zone; just in time to miss the raid :p. But I promise I'll be there next time!
It isn't just the 3x5 Flux Portal-based Quest that is a problem.

I've been on one of the later Quests for many days now, the one where you have to kill 30 randomly encountered Elites in 3 different areas. I just spent 46 Energy in a zone, 23 encounters, and did not get a SINGLE Black Wyvern. That's annoying. In a sense worse than Portals, because at least with a Portal, you can influence the probabilities, by levelling it up to 3. Here, it is purely RNG-dependent.
Good point; there is that one minor point in favor of the portals. Of course there are several cons which more than balance it out, but both are bad.

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Mon Jan 7, 2013 12:37 am
Marney wrote:Good point; there is that one minor point in favor of the portals. Of course there are several cons which more than balance it out, but both are bad.


The update has fixed portals slightly. I got 2 indigo flux from about 50 or so energy, and 1 emerald flux. The rates have increased a lot and can be found in level 1 now :)
Oh, it has improved tremendously; there's no doubt about that. Still, the structural problems (time limit, schedule, rare, three types of rare) which make it difficult for people like Rabid to advance do remain. And the elite grinding badly needs revision too.