Book of Heroes

Armor Penetation with Magic? · page 2

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Feb 9, 2013 7:12 am
Romain wrote:
for instance 28% defense mitigation and 34% Nature resist mitigation.
Does that mean that, for a nature attack, I'm going to take 0.72 x 0.66 = 48% of the full damage only?

Overview:
Nature Resist Mitigation will go down from a Poison Stack.
Fire/ Ice Resist Mitigation will usually go down from a Debuff cast on character by a Monster.
Defense Mitigation will go down from Sunder Armor.

Body:
Zeetha had Defense 25% (vs all damage), Physical Resist 10.61% and Magic Resist 10.76%. Instead of doing the calculations and adding Nature Resist, I go to Addition Details where Zeetha's Defense Mitigation (including any Enchants, Buffs and Debuffs) is 25%, Physical Resist Mitigation (including any Enchants, Buffs and Debuffs) is 32.96% or ( 1- [ 0.75 * 0.8939 ]= 0.3296 ). Fire/ Ice/ Nature/ Spirit Resist Mitigation (including any Enchants, Buffs, and Debuffs) is 33.07% or ( 1 - [ 0.75 * 0.8924 ] = 0.3307 ).

As Monsters, or PVP, successfully use Debuffs, Zeetha's Resist Mitigations on the Additional Details page will reflect these changes.
I played with these numbers and I think Rom is wrong. You don't multiply defense mitigation * Nature Resist Mitigation. Nature Resist Mitigation (without any special nature resist enchants) is calculated by defense mitigation*magic resist. Nature Resist Mitigation is the number that comes off the attack.

So if you are hit with a nature attack and you are at 34% Nature Resist Mitigation, you are going to take 66% of the damage.

I played around with the numbers and a maxed out AP on 3 items versus a maxed out 1/2H is only better if the mitigation is above 49.11%.

I even have some Resist gems in my build (a reaction to the amount of dmg I was taking early in 1.5, which I had a redo), which a lot of high might people don't. All T14. Still I'm in the low 30% range.

My current theory is that AP will only be better in PvP versus people who have an insanely high defense build, of which, there is virtually nobody today. Also, it probably would work wonders against Ice Shield.
Bbbb wrote:Nature Resist Mitigation (without any special nature resist enchants) is calculated by defense mitigation*magic resist.
Yes I realized that the other day too. I saw all resist increase when I was enchanting defense.
Note that with defense enchantment, it's really not difficult to reach 50% damage mitigation, so armor penetration will definitely be useful against those players.
TCG_japster wrote:Weapon damage wins. I've ran preliminary calculations and tests before, and right now, no monster (including the Lord of Blades) in the game has sufficient damage mitigation to ever make armor penetration do more damage than weapon enchant. Couple that with the fact that weapon damage increases at 1% per level, while armor penetration is at 0.8%, armor penetration will only get weaker as enchant levels go up.

The power of armor penetration really lies in PvP, much like accuracy.

That agrees with my tests using a +2 enchant of AP and then a +2 enchant of 1-h against the same bosses (Direhorn, Goblin King, and Lord of Blades). The weapon enchant was doing more damage each time.


One difference is that we all get the Armour Penetration enchant at the end of the Vile Gate quest chain, but the 1-h or 2-h enchant you have to go looking for, or buy from the black market for 250 GS. Each player has to decide whether to raid for CV and bring their gems up to scratch, or go slamming the top dungeons in the hopes of enchant recipe drops, or go slamming their pocket to save time and effort.
Bbbb wrote:I even have some Resist gems in my build (a reaction to the amount of dmg I was taking early in 1.5, which I had a redo), which a lot of high might people don't. All T14. Still I'm in the low 30% range.

My current theory is that AP will only be better in PvP versus people who have an insanely high defense build, of which, there is virtually nobody today. Also, it probably would work wonders against Ice Shield.


I have resist gems too; after Venan hinted they'd be more important in 1.5 I loaded up on a couple of each. I have even got a T5 Physical resist gem on my chest armour. My physical Damage Mitigation is 39.6%.

Because you have to split the resist gems between magic and melee, and because they only reduce a portion of the damage that got through normal defences (provided by the character's armor and hero token spending, they are still not very attractive as an option to buy.

I can see the top players having two (or more) sets of gems, as well as two sets of t14 enchanted armor, to tailor their toon for the best results against their chosen PvP opponent - assuming you know what you/re facing before the fight begins. e.g. If you know you're facing a War Mage, then switching out a few excess crit power gems for magic resist makes a lot of sense.


1.5 was supposed to encourage more balanced toons, but the vast majority of experienced players still seem to be going all out offense with hitting hard (2-h weapons where allowed) and high crit proc and damage, and ignoring defense almost entirely beyond what you get from armor and your hero training, and gulping health potions when necessary. Offense is still the best defense.

japster

ModeratorTue Feb 19, 2013 4:16 pm
They did make it harder....the dual behemoth spawns were fun...till they removed it because people complained. LOL.

Honestly, try farming level 4 portals now, it still forces you to gulp lots of health potions. I do have some defensive gems that I use, including dodge, when I farm level 4 portals, to lessen the damage. But otherwise, not really.

Probably the cheapness of health potions is what makes the game easy right now anyway. There has been some discussion about it in another thread though....

Anyway with regard to PvP, I'm pretty sure any decent PvPer will buff their defenses up. Period. Also defensive (power) enchants will see an improvement (this I chatted with Mike previously in private). That I am sure. Possibly the defense and magic stats may scale better too. We'll see...