Book of Heroes

Armor Penetation with Magic?

Hi all,

Just wondering does armor penetration work if im casting magic? Does it still reduce mitigated damage?

Also, does the 2 handed enchant increase magic damage or only physical?

Thanks!

japster

ModeratorSun Jan 20, 2013 2:28 pm
Armor penetration reduces defense rating, which affects both magic and melee damage taken.

The weapon damage enchant (both 2h and 1h) literally increase weapon damage, and thus both magic and melee damage are also improved. This is because skills, whether they are magic or melee are based off a % of weapon damage. There is a slightly more complex formula involved but I shall not go into details since that isn't necessary to answer your question.
I'm having a hard time choosing between these two enchantments. Seems to me 1h/2h damage is slightly more beneficial, but I can't explain why for the love of my life :D

japster

ModeratorMon Jan 21, 2013 12:17 pm
DarthPaff wrote:I'm having a hard time choosing between these two enchantments. Seems to me 1h/2h damage is slightly more beneficial, but I can't explain why for the love of my life :D

Armor penetration is more useful when the enemy has a high defense rating. Because weapon damage scales based on your weapon (which is fixed at t14 right now), while armor penetration's effectiveness varies depending on the enemy, there really isn't a "best" option. But for general purposes, damage is probably better.

In PvP, armor penetration and accuracy will definitely be the best options.
TCG_japster wrote:In PvP, armor penetration and accuracy will definitely be the best options.

Yes, I kind of feared something like that since I went for the 1h damage enchantments. When PvP is released I might need a second set of enchanted armour. Probably something many players will do.
TCG_japster wrote:Armor penetration reduces defense rating, which affects both magic and melee damage taken.

The weapon damage enchant (both 2h and 1h) literally increase weapon damage, and thus both magic and melee damage are also improved. This is because skills, whether they are magic or melee are based off a % of weapon damage. There is a slightly more complex formula involved but I shall not go into details since that isn't necessary to answer your question.

Thank you for this great answer! Exactly what I needed to know.
TCG_japster wrote: There is a slightly more complex formula involved but I shall not go into details since that isn't necessary to answer your question.
Could you please elaborate? Looking at your spreadsheet, it seem bonus damage applies to the total attack damage (e.g. 3% weapon damage enchantment translates to 3% more damage), so that's pretty straightforward.

How does the armor penetration work, could you please share the formula?

Thanks,
Romain

japster

ModeratorFri Feb 8, 2013 11:34 pm
Romain wrote:
TCG_japster wrote: There is a slightly more complex formula involved but I shall not go into details since that isn't necessary to answer your question.
Could you please elaborate? Looking at your spreadsheet, it seem bonus damage applies to the total attack damage (e.g. 3% weapon damage enchantment translates to 3% more damage), so that's pretty straightforward.

How does the armor penetration work, could you please share the formula?

Thanks,
Romain

Actually I am convinced calculations for weapon enchant changed in v1.5.3 from v1.5.1. However I clarified with the developers and they do not corroborate my findings. Regardless, my current spreadsheet is correct, and weapon damage enchant is now a simple multiplier that affects both weapon damage AND magic bonus. In the previous version I was pretty sure it ONLY affected weapon damage.

As for armor penetration, this is how it works. I did intend to put in armor penetration into my spreadsheet, but because of the lack of monster data and that PvP isn't out yet, it seemed pre-mature. Basically armor penetration is worthless in v1.5.3.

Scenario A
Your skill does 1000 damage and you have 10% armor penetration. The enemy has a defense rating that reduces damage by 20% and the relevant magic/elemental resist that reduces damage further by 10%.

10% of 1000 damage will go through unmitigated, i.e. 100, while the remaining 1000 - 100 = 900 damage is subject to damage mitigation. So you will deal (900*0.8*0.9) + 100 = 648 + 100 = 748

Scenario B
Your skill does 1000 damage and you have 10% weapon damage enchant. The enemy has a defense rating that reduces damage by 20% and the relevant magic/elemental resist that reduces damage further by 10%.

You deal 1000*1.1*0.8*0.9 = 792

Weapon damage wins. I've ran preliminary calculations and tests before, and right now, no monster (including the Lord of Blades) in the game has sufficient damage mitigation to ever make armor penetration do more damage than weapon enchant. Couple that with the fact that weapon damage increases at 1% per level, while armor penetration is at 0.8%, armor penetration will only get weaker as enchant levels go up.

The power of armor penetration really lies in PvP, much like accuracy.
Thanks a lot Japster. I see for instance 28% defense mitigation and 34% Nature resist mitigation.
Does that mean that, for a nature attack, I'm going to take 0.72 x 0.66 = 48% of the full damage only? Sorry if the question is stupid, I've never bothered about defense stats before.

japster

ModeratorSat Feb 9, 2013 12:36 am
Romain wrote:Thanks a lot Japster. I see for instance 28% defense mitigation and 34% Nature resist mitigation.
Does that mean that, for a nature attack, I'm going to take 0.72 x 0.66 = 48% of the full damage only? Sorry if the question is stupid, I've never bothered about defense stats before.

That is correct. I base it off the v1.5 patch notes which state,

"Physical/Magic Resist and Armor Defense are no longer additive. They are now multiplied to determine the final amount of damage received. For example, if you have 20% mitigation (80% damage taken) due to Defense and 30% mitigation (70% damage taken) due to Physical Resist, you will take 70% x 80% = 56% damage taken."