Actually I got to agree with DarthPuff and Mike...what's gonna happen when the 2nd-in-command leaves the guild/has to leave the guild/gets inactive?
Since a number of reasons for leaving the guild was due to compulsion of circumstances to help out training guilds/struggling raids/socialize, wouldn't the 2nd-in-command face similar pressures? What do we then need? A 3rd, 4th, 5th? Just so to lower the probability of this occurring? Not too sure if this is really a step in the right direction.
I agree a problem exists, but I disagree with the solution proposed. Probably what DarthPuff just suggested about giving officers the power to promote fellow officers is more feasible, although that might create messy situations for less organized guilds. Once again, a careful balancing of interests is required.
TCG_japster wrote:
I agree a problem exists, but I disagree with the solution proposed. Probably what DarthPuff just suggested about giving officers the power to promote fellow officers is more feasible, although that might create messy situations for less organized guilds. Once again, a careful balancing of interests is required.
I think this is why I originally suggested a new class with higher level of trust and responsibility, not limited to just 1 person, but rather 2-4 seasoned and proven officers. While I wouldn't be concerned with officers in our guild conducting reckless officer promotions, I can definitely see this as being a concern for many other guilds with newer member bases who have not proven their worth as a level-headed officer.
I guess the thing is, Officers already has all the abilities of a GM except they cannot promote new Officers and they cannot disband the guild. Officers can already promote Veterans that can start up new raids.
Now, say we introduce an even higher rank, let's call Commander. They would have the same abilities of a GM except they cannot promote new Commanders. Except now, you will run into the exact same problem as before. Say you have an inactive GM and inactive Commanders.
I'm kind of leaning towards that all this will do is create unnecessary complication of ranks which still does not address the root problem of leadership inactivity. I think this is a problem that needs to be sorted out by the guilds in a guild by guild basis: Make sure the GM is active and responsible, promote enough trusted Officers, etc.
On a side note, as for the promotion/demotion UI issues, it is something on our list of stuff to do. I can't say when it will be done, because there are still a lot of other higher priority issues.
I would propose a system that will offer the GM title to the most senior officer (based on datetime promoted to officer) when the GM has not logged in for XX days.
This offer can be available for a X day period. At the end of said period time, if the offer is not accepted or declined then it moves to the next officer. Then moves to veterans and then members with the same parameters.
Of course this is a system overview and I have not explained all the procedures or completely realized all scenarios that have to accounted for. However its a suggestion.
In our case, it's not an issue of officer inactivity. It's an issue of officer slumber! Doesn't he know that sleeping is for the weak! And like I said, I would like a status that has ALL the powers of the GM EXCEPT promoting to GM and disbanding the guild. That way we don't have the problems currently in place.
I guess part of the reason I want this is because I have been stuck in my guild for as long as I've been here (and it's an awesome guild so that's not all bad). But it would be nice to actually get out in the world and visit different guilds, help friends, experience more of the social aspect of this game, etc. But I only have one character so this is not possible to do, and get my officer status back in my guild if the GM is sleeping/working, etc.
The second in command could be appointed to a max of 3/4 officers -discretion of the GM's of course. If a guild has good officers & team, the probability of the GM & all appointed second in commands disappearing is pretty low.
Leaving this to the guild to sort out will not help solve this issue, rather it will keep the problem stagnant and ongoing. Life happens to the best of us, no one is on BoH 24/7 and it would be unhealthy to do so.
If introducing a second in command is so difficult, then I suggest an option of Venan sending out a mail to the GM's real life mail account, so they can return and relinquish their role until they are ready to come back to the guild.
I have now resorted to communicating with my officers through kik -which has helped me when i'm not on BoH; something like this (a instant chat system like kik) is unlikely to happen on BoH -and not everyone would be comfortable in doing so. This is why I'm offering an alternative mail option from Venan.
So essentially it's second in command vs a Venan mail sent to inactive GM's from the request of the respective guilds officers.
My thoughts have been like Doctor Love's. Let officers create new officers and problem solved.
Bbbb wrote:My thoughts have been like Doctor Love's. Let officers create new officers and problem solved.
I would tentatively say that giving all officers this capability could be hazardous -in that some newly appointed officers and immature officers could quite easily abuse that power. Also some members get power crazy, so when they come into power they become overbearing, for this reason I would not give such powers to all officers -just the selected ones, chosen by the GM.
I agree with doodllz, it could get messy if an officer with the power of officer promotion start to abuse it. You multiply that by a few bad ones and you've go a problem. I don't think a new class of officer needs to be created, just a first officer position, someone trusted by Gm to act in their place should they be absent. They can leave an alt in the guild if first officer wants to leave. the gm and first officer can coordinate when Gm is going to be gone for awhile, so they both don't leave. If it is an unexpected departure of the Gm, at least the other officer can act as Gm until the gm comes back or is replaced by venan. It halves the odds of a no gm situation, while avoiding giving to much power to officer class.
While I see the importance of many guilds to be able to address an issue of a GM disappearing for an extended period of time, that is not the concern for all guilds. In my case, and I'm sure many other guilds, we just want the ability to fluidly manage the guild and the ins and outs of players on a 24/7 basis, then the GM can't possibly be on the whole time. And this is not just in the case of members leaving to merc which we know Venan doesn't like. This also happens when officers pull their toons out of the guild when they go on vacation and don't want to take up space, or even when updates come otu and officers do not have the might to join in raids and do not wanna take up valuable real estate.
Bottom line is there are plenty of reasons why a few trusted officers should have the ability to promote and demote other officers.