Book of Heroes

Inactive/Absent GM's

I'd like to suggest an additional role to the veterans & officers.

Second in command to the GM. This role would be approved by the GM and would have the options to promote/demote officers in the GM's absence -and would also be regarded as a likely candidate for the GM's replacement should the GM be away for a long duration as Venan states in their policy about GM's being absent for 30 days or more.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Thu Jan 31, 2013 2:12 am
I emphatically second this. The GM cannot possibly be around all the time and promoting officers, or even demoting officers can often be needed when the GM is absent. Having a second in comand with the same powers as the GM with the sole exception of making himself GM is a very important feature we should have.

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu Jan 31, 2013 10:31 am
Not that this is a bad suggestion, but what happens when both the GM and #1 are inactive? Then we are just back to the same problem that we have now.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Thu Jan 31, 2013 2:48 pm
Yes, that's true. But the chances of this happening would be half what they are now. Either this, or give all officers the ability to promote and demote other officers. This is my biggest concern on the issue here. But since I don't think you want that power to go to everyone, the second in command is the best idea.

beekeo

Site AdminThu Jan 31, 2013 2:56 pm
I'm curious about how frequently you need to promote officers; is this related to officers leaving to merc and wanting to resume their former seniority when they return?

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Fri Feb 1, 2013 5:11 am
The times I have seen the need are when officers leave to bail out a struggling raid, whether in a training guild or just a guild where their alts reside and such. It is rare that our officers will leave, but it does happen once or twice per week I would say. Also, when officers go inactive for an extended period of time, we will keep them in until we decide it's time to let someone else in to contribute to the guild. This decision is not always made when the GM is around. But we cannot remove them from the guild. Only the GM has that power. And when they come back, we cannot re-promote to officer status either. Another situation is when an officer desires to swap their officer toons, like demote one and promote the other. All of these things are dependent on the GM being around all the time which just isn't realistic.

In our guild, I would say there may be 2-4 people who would be great as "second in command" and have all powers of the GM save for making themselves GM. I would like to see a new class between officer and GM but have this be limited to between 2-4 people so it doesn't just become the new officer status.
Doctor_Love wrote:In our guild, I would say there may be 2-4 people who would be great as "second in command" and have all powers of the GM save for making themselves GM. I would like to see a new class between officer and GM but have this be limited to between 2-4 people so it doesn't just become the new officer status.

Wouldn't it make more sense to make these people that are great as ''second in command'' Officers, and all that are not - Veterans. Then all the rest as Members. And the newcomers are Recruits, as usual. I see no reason for another vanity title. Just use the structure we already have on our hands meaningful.

As you described above, the new ''Second in Command'' may just as well be tempted to leave the guild on an occasion for whatever reason. Then we shall face a situation no different then the one we have with Officers already. Only the GM would be able to restore their status.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Fri Feb 1, 2013 6:02 am
I propose that the Second in Command would have all powers of a GM EXCEPT for promoting to GM (or disbanding the guild). Thus, they could promote others to Second in Command as well. And if we demote most of the current officers to vets, they they can't accept members, change ticker and might requirements, etc. And then you would have to give officers all powers of the GM. And people getting "demoted" to veteran will get all butt hurt as well. The new class would be the best solution I can think of here. It is not at all about the vanity title, but rather, giving more people the power to more effectively manage the guild if they have proven they know what they are doing. Our guild has multiple people who could competently serve as GM, so why not let them help even more, as officers should.
In that case, if Officers received the ''power'' to promote others to Officers, that might be enough to solve the problem. This is the only ''skill'' that Officers lack compared to the GM, other than promoting somebody to a GM.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Fri Feb 1, 2013 6:08 am
Well sure, I suppose you could make it that simple! :)

(And while we're on this topic, here is another plea to Venan to PLEASE fix the interface relating to the promotion/demotion/booting of players in the member list. This is SOOO cumbersome to navigate and make changes to right now. It NEEDS to improve drastically. Pretty please??)