Book of Heroes

The Death of Guilds at Endgame (once more?) · page 2

Little_Mike

Site AdminSun Feb 3, 2013 1:00 am
Bbbb, we are aware that things are far from perfect. We have plans for future improvements to the guild system which we hope will address some of the problems you are having. Don't get me wrong, raids are a HUGE part of the game and I honestly think the game could not survive without them. So even though we have been talking about PvP a lot recently, improving guilds and raids is still a high priority for us.
Bbbb wrote:Black Lotus doesn't help - it is different than every other guild in the game.
That's a pity. :)
Ok so here are my thoughts regarding this issue and some of the other issues that have been pointed out in this thread.

Firstly I think this game has done a great job so far catering to all different types of players allowing progression by either solo, merc or guild based play.

It's difficult to design a game that will make everyone happy because everyone is different. We've seen many guilds go under because some of their members have quit for all kinds of reasons. This can happen to any guild.

The success of a guild depends on the mix of players in it and the general dedication of the players to helping each other out. In 'black lotus' we have enough patience and camaraderie to not be dependent on mercs yet we allow them in if they want and the option to be a part of the team of they so choose. I guess it's up to the individuals and what they feel is important. If progressing as fast as possible is their prerogative then solo farming and mercing is the way to go, if they want a more relaxed environment then they can join an appropriate guild.

That being said I have seen the pattern of guilds becoming 'raid rooms' but if that's the way ppl want to play then that's great but its not necessarily for everyone.

Personally I think a good mix of raiding and farming is the fastest way to gain might and wether the raids are in a single guild or multiple are up to the individual.

Mercing has the big advantage of being able to raid almost whenever you are able and not restricted by time constraints etc and so it seems to be more appealing to individuals but if there were bonuses for staying in a guild eg. guild loyalty rewards then there would be a greater incentive to stay in a single guild.

At the end of the day, individuals will find the best method of play that suits them and wether it be in a guild or out of one that will be their choice.

If raids start failing because ppl are farming in the guild then it's not a problem with the game as much as it is with the individuals. They shouldn't be there if that is happening. Or raid schedules will need to be adjusted etc.

I like how the game allows us the freedom to play how we want and if a certain guild isn't the right fit then I'm sure there are others that would.
Im pure merc have full t14 gear and 1-2 t5 gems. it gives
me enough might to enter all existing raids and some 3-4k might above highest raid. naturally my next purpose should be getting all t5 gems and maxing hero tomes. but here enters e regen enchanting which I also want to max of course. maxing gems or maxing e enchant will take some months each. but if i first finish e enchanting - getting ~100k cv to max gems becomes some faster.
getting all this essence and fluxes isn't easy so I want also luck enchant on other set of gear. maybe not max it.
anyway until all this enchanting is finished I effectively stay out of raids. this probably doesn't influence the boh much :)
but if other players adopt the idea guilds, especially top ones will have hard time. low ones already have hard time due to energy efficient bosses farming and "low mighters friendly" lockbox.
so I think raid combining flux essence valor ht even in lesser proportion should be good idea.
or at least raid with pure essence flux drop. like portal but with ht and rpp based
btw I suppose venan shouldnt want guilds death as it's one of more cool and unique features of boh, attracting new players which want collective community activities.
btw2. player racing other players and competing for rpp will probably burn more gs than player farming portal alone.
for example people talk about records of 60k rpp in vg, but no one talks about record of max gs burned in portal...
I think Giorgio has a good point. A guild doesn’t have to die if it raids less. We just think so because the main ways to judge a guild success rely on how many raids they can complete:
  • Power is how many raids you can complete in 4 weeks (short term);
  • Prestige factors in members’ might and basic challenges, but apart from that it’s still basically how many raids you’ve completed so far (long term).
From that it’s entirely up to your guild to decide whether your definition of success is the same as Venan’s.
If your aim is to be first on the leaderboards, you’ll have no choice but to raid non-stop, leaving no time to personal growth and either renewing your members base regularly or relying on mercs, like most of top 10 guilds now.
If your aim is to grow a group of people together, you don’t need to be raiding 4, 5, 6 times a day. You can have a more relaxed schedule, as long as you accept a lower ranking in the leaderboards.

Rather than bringing everything (e.g. essence and fluxes) to raids, maybe Venan could give us more non-raiding activities and give them more consideration. We could have more challenges and achievements, a guild-wise daily bounty, different weekly leaderboards (e.g. which guilds are the best Glenfort protectors, killing the most viles in portals), etc., all of which could be factored in the guild’s prestige or power.
All those things would give more interest to guilds as a group and would probably also keep top players longer (honestly, who really cares about level 5 gems when you have level 4?). It wouldn’t penalize mercing in any way as I’m sure a number of guilds would still prefer to raid as much as possible.

Don’t get me wrong, I think raiding should remain the main guild activity and I like all the social interactions it brought, but ideally not the only one.