I think Giorgio has a good point. A guild doesn’t have to die if it raids less. We just think so because the main ways to judge a guild success rely on how many raids they can complete:
- Power is how many raids you can complete in 4 weeks (short term);
- Prestige factors in members’ might and basic challenges, but apart from that it’s still basically how many raids you’ve completed so far (long term).
From that it’s entirely up to your guild to decide whether your definition of success is the same as Venan’s.
If your aim is to be first on the leaderboards, you’ll have no choice but to raid non-stop, leaving no time to personal growth and either renewing your members base regularly or relying on mercs, like most of top 10 guilds now.
If your aim is to grow a group of people together, you don’t need to be raiding 4, 5, 6 times a day. You can have a more relaxed schedule, as long as you accept a lower ranking in the leaderboards.
Rather than bringing everything (e.g. essence and fluxes) to raids, maybe Venan could give us more non-raiding activities and give them more consideration. We could have more challenges and achievements, a guild-wise daily bounty, different weekly leaderboards (e.g. which guilds are the best Glenfort protectors, killing the most viles in portals), etc., all of which could be factored in the guild’s prestige or power.
All those things would give more interest to guilds as a group and would probably also keep top players longer (honestly, who really cares about level 5 gems when you have level 4?). It wouldn’t penalize mercing in any way as I’m sure a number of guilds would still prefer to raid as much as possible.
Don’t get me wrong, I think raiding should remain the main guild activity and I like all the social interactions it brought, but ideally not the only one.