Book of Heroes

The Death of Guilds at Endgame (once more?)

japster

ModeratorSat Feb 2, 2013 11:01 pm
With the latest update, enchants have had their levels raised, requiring 9350 essences (assuming my other sources are correct, because I personally do not have access to high level enchants) and goodness knows how many fluxes just to get one piece of gear from lvl 1-6. For 9 slots of gear, that would mean 84150 essences. And it is likely people will want more than just 9 enchantments, but 18 or even 27, to achieve different objectives. Even if I am wrong, the exact value cannot be too far off.

This would take a LOT of farming. I fear that once everybody has finished their t14 and filled all their gem slots with t5, focus on raiding would come to a halt for these players. Of course this represents a minority of gamers who are at "end-game", but still this also affects a good number of players from top guilds.

It seems almost inevitable that there will be a direct clash between raiding and farming for enchant mats at the end of the day, especially when raids no longer give any benefit. Since farming mats is a largely solitary endeavor, this also makes the tension become a dichotomy of guild vs solo. Soloing obviously benefits mercenary behavior as well.

Given Venan has stated they do not support mercing and are looking to encourage more guild play, I hope that you realize how the new, arduous requirements for enchanting mats are actually going to demolish high level guilds once their characters collect all the necessary gems. Sure, they might not quit the guild, but one of the most defining characteristics of a guild - raiding - would almost certainly die. It would require heavy mercing to support the dwindling numbers, once again relying on a phenomenon Venan has stated they want to discourage.

This may not have been a huge problem in the past, when portals were less frequent and could be anticipated. Thus raiders may have missed a few raids but not all. But with portals spawning every hour now (to meet the new costs of enchanting), and the high costs of enchanting, it is inevitable that all high-might raiders with full t5 gems will be compelled to farm portals instead of raid.

Perhaps Venan could rectify this by allowing conversion of Captains Valor to Flux/Essences, and/or allow Flux/Essences to drop from Vile Gate raid (I did not support this suggestion previously Flux & Essence in Vile Gate raid., but with the new changes, I certainly do!).

Of course other more creative solutions could occur, and I look forward to Venan amazing us with the good work they have done thus far. But please, do realize that the new updates have created an "impending doom" timer on top guilds.
Couldn't all this be avoided simply by creating a new raid that awarded essence for RPP (instead of valor) and had flux as random drops?

japster

ModeratorSat Feb 2, 2013 11:29 pm
Marney wrote:Couldn't all this be avoided simply by creating a new raid that awarded essence for RPP (instead of valor) and had flux as random drops?

Also another possible solution. =)

Little_Mike

Site AdminSat Feb 2, 2013 11:50 pm
First off, we love all the theorycrafting you guys put into the game. It brings a tear to our eye, haha.

Okay now back on topic.. I just wanted to bring up one thing. If a player maxes out their gear and gems from raiding and the enchantment system didn't exist, what would those players normally do? Some might quit the game, others might just start raiding on a different toon. With enchanting, those same players may still quit, or work on enchantments, or raid on a different toon. It's actually quite hard to say exactly what players will do when that time comes. The way I see it, everything must come to an end at some point right?

But that's what new content is supposed to address in order to keep the player's interest in the game. It isn't to the game's benefit to only cater to one style of playing. That's why we want to introduce different core game play features like PvP. So that there are multiple different ways to enjoy the game. In that way, guilds won't necessarily die simply because there aren't able to raid as often as before. Some guilds may become just a social group of PvPers, others may do both, some could just be with casual friends, and some may still just focus on raids.

Now, this is all assuming that level 30 and Captain's Valor is the end of the game. Oh, no no... we are not nearly done yet.
A very valid observation and concern made by Japster here.
Marney wrote:Couldn't all this be avoided simply by creating a new raid that awarded essence for RPP (instead of valor) and had flux as random drops?

Perhaps adding random flux and essence drops to the CV raids (as opposed to the singleplayer dungeon) would have been a good solution.

Adding these to singleplayer dungeons is yet another (tempting) distraction to raiding in a guild.

japster

ModeratorSat Feb 2, 2013 11:54 pm
Little_Mike wrote:

Now, this is all assuming that level 30 and Captain's Valor is the end of the game. Oh, no no... we are not nearly done yet.

Oh you're such a tease...but please try to make it happen quick this time? :P Thanks for the reply. At least we now know that Venan is acutely aware of possible issues!

I guess for us players, there isn't much more we can do but wait and see...and hope for the best for now.

Little_Mike

Site AdminSat Feb 2, 2013 11:59 pm
I forgot to mention that raiding is still the best way of gaining Hero Tokens, so even if people are maxed out in gear and gems, if they really want to min-max their characters, they will still need to raid.

japster

ModeratorSun Feb 3, 2013 12:01 am
Little_Mike wrote:I forgot to mention that raiding is still the best way of gaining Hero Tokens, so even if people are maxed out in gear and gems, if they really want to min-max their characters, they will still need to raid.

I am unsure if what I was informed was correct, but according to Hai, solo farming CoC (or a joint endeavor with massive gs) gives best hero token returns? Probably has to do with max haste on all slots and using 1 hit aoe kills or something to rack up massive rpp...or as a SW to use their 2-hit normal attack...

If that is indeed true...then it's not exactly raiding high-end content lol
Oops, it took me too long to write that last post so it actually was written before reading Little Mike's response, for which I am thankful as well. :)

Edit:

PS: These forums are definitely too fast for my humble phone.
Mike, it is my opinion that you all do not "get" the guilds as they are today. Black Lotus doesn't help - it is different than every other guild in the game. The high end guilds are mostly dead as guilds even now and are "raid rooms" for the most part. I think your ideas of guilds surviving without raids are wishful thinking.

Hero tokens give so little benefit to high end players they aren't an incentive except the massively obsessed players (of which there are just a handful and possibly just Hai and Mich).

Solo farming for enchantment is a boring thing to do. As a part time thing, it is okay. I don't think many people will do it for long if it is the only thing. Without the raid social interaction with a guild/mercing, I will move on. I would have been gone in mid-summer without raids. I'm fine with either of the proposed solutions earlier in the thread.

The problem with 1.4 was that people were reaching the end game before the new content came out. As long as you can keep the new content in front of that, then you don't have a problem. However, it is moving shockingly fast now. I know one person who started 2 weeks ago and is VG might....