Book of Heroes

The Player versus Player (PvP) Pipe Dream! · page 2

Mithrid wrote:
RSVA_Veteran_rastafish wrote:Everything is pro-rated based on stats. So 3000 dmg does 300. 10k crit does 1k dmg etc. It would have to be turn-based as well imo.

I think there is more potential for guild war i. e. Challenge another guild to a raid time or challenge.

I would love a guild war type challenge. There are a few games that do that and it's quite entertaining.

It'll be a bit tough logistically however. How would we split up seeds, for example? By tier is a bit too exploitable. Nearly as bad as pvp to make work fairly and consistently.

But if venan can do it properly, I'd love to have guild wars :p
1v1 weekly ladders for valor rewards to start! Everyone starts at 2000 rating every week and its a zero sum every week (winners gain the same amount that losers lose). Match ups and payouts/penalties based on Might of opponents. Could have different Might ranges as tiers. People may even gear up for less to qualify for lower tiers.

Level would pose a challenge though since you can't make up for less ability points.

Guild v Guild sounds awesome but it would be hard to coordinate something like that.

I just hope everyone's ready to be "balanced".

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon May 20, 2013 7:20 am
I think narrow Might brackets would help. So your 5000 Might Justicar doesn't enter a PvP arena and is immediately matched up vs a 20k monster Mage, with the Mage pretty much winning by default. There will sadly be players out there who would think this is ok.

I've played a game that matched players but did not base it on stats, XP or any other factor. It simply connected two players who wanted to fight, which was almost-ok at the start, but it became more and more common to be immediately annihilated by a player who was of a far higher lvl with better weapons. The result was that vs mode simply became a hunting ground of the hardcore players as everyone else just deserted it.

Levels will frequently not match when matching Might, but Might is ultimately the measure of your character's power in comparison to others'. Level may also become a factor, such as a Might bracket that also has a level min.
If PvP is to be brought out BOH needs to be much simpler than it currently is. As it stands there are too many variables that could go into dueling. Gems, enchants, and hero tokens should not be factored in the equation. How could anyone duel without having to a ton of math with these variables? I certainly wouldnt. I say tokens because people have trained in certain areas so they can do well in raids. This game was has been geared for raids and will need some drastic change in order for PvP to work. That being said I was thinking of something like two tabs in the player profile. One for PvE (raids, quests, dgs) and PvP (dueling). Essentially you could have two sets of gear or just one but it would be set up differently in the tabs.
Unknown_Hero wrote:AmI the only one bought 20 health gems to see whats health you can get to? XD

I did too -_-

Did the same thing with resist gems -_-