Book of Heroes

The Player versus Player (PvP) Pipe Dream!

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Mar 7, 2013 1:19 pm
I have listened to and read about many many discussions in both forums and in-game chat regarding player versus player and the speculation about how it will work, what it will/won't allow, how it will be/won't be different, etc etc.. This post is nothing against Venan, as I am certain they are working hard to find a means of making it work.

Mostly this is a post to the gamers, to help them truly realize the daunting task of making PvP work within BoH, under the current game mechanics. I truly believe that most BoH gamers have no clue how difficult it will be to make PvP work in BoH.

NOTE: Everything here is My own ****ing opinion and I am by no means an authority, so take it with a grain of salt.

The current mechanics were designed and geared towards a single player quests based adventure. This allowed the Dev's the freedom of creating separate classes, attack systems that catered to individual players, without compromise on how those individual classes worked compared to each other.

That changed when raiding was released. Raiding created a system in which players (and consequently their classes) could compete against each other in a single arena. This arena however is limited to one method of win...whomever kills the most waves the fastest wins...they get the MVP slot, they get the RPP.

The problem here is that to win, there is only one strategy..and certain classes were better at that strategy then others which saw a huge series of revisions (aka nerfings) to balance the classes out, with the one goal of making raids a fair challenge for each of the classes. Unfortunately, when everyone competes in a raid using the same strategy, as you tweak the classes they all start to behave the same using the same type of attacks, etc...you simply rename things across classes...this has had the effect of limiting the unique style of the classes...but to be fair it is all you can do when raid strategies are singular. Now I am digressing...what does this have to do with PvP...

The point is that the game mechanics were not designed for raids originally, and needed a lot of tweaking to balance out the individuality of the classes when they started competing in raids using the same strategy to win.

So consider now how much more challenging and how many more changes will need to be made to PvP.

Damn this is going to be long... lets just start with the basic game mechanics:

Toons versus Enemy is how its built. Enemy defined as in game monsters, not other toons.
Here is a table of typical stats for high level game play (lvl 30 toons against GK/VG raids and portals)

Toon (High level)
1 individual
Health: 4k-6k
Instant Heal (>50%)with potions
Average damage per attach:
>3000 >10k-15k crits are common
Status options: Many stunning/kockback
all fast, designed to beat opponent
Instant attacks such as runes or snapcast
(note Little Mike has commented
Runes are likely out in PvP)

Opponents
Typically groups as individuals are too easy
Health: lower opponents >5000 Mid tier: >8k-10k High level >15k
No instant heal, some have a slow regeneration easy to interrupt that only regenerates on average <20%
Average Damage per attack:
<800 strongest opponents may do slightly more than 1000
Status options: a few stunning and knockbacks, but these are slow and few.
No instant attacks

I want you as a gamer to consider these points:
Most toons are designed to attack opponents with massive amounts of health (compared to the toon them-self) and with slow attacks giving the toon options for strategy using their attacks (that is part of the fun of the game).

Also, the toons are able to withstand multiple attacks, as most opponents at best can only knock down the toons health by 20% in one attack; and then instantly and easily regenerate most of their health with a potion (though potion reuse time is delayed).
None of the current opponents of a toon can do this.

Toons have many options for very fast status affect type attacks such as stun, knockback, etc... most of their opponents do not and when they do, the attacks are typically slow and easy to counter...again part of the strategy designed for the toon to enjoy.

Now, migrate these stats to a toon versus toon battle (as in a PvP):

First major hurdle:
Every toon can easily do 1-2x as much and even 3x as much damage as the opposing toon has in total health (even with health gems which nobody currently uses as they do not help in raids) with one attack (especially if its a crit). Generally this translate into whomever hits first wins. No drawn out battle or even strategy..just land the first punch.
Even a super high defense or overloading health gems can not counter this...and if you do max out Defense or health, it means you have sacrificed other offensive stats..in this case you just allowed yourself to survive one or two hits but have no capability to counter, you have made your toon a sturdy target....one strategy then is successful in PvP..all offense, fastest offense, first offense)

Other challenges, everyone has very fast status attacks such as Icy Grasp from the Mage. Though these may not do the max health damage, they are sufficient to knock down the opposing toons health to 50%-70% at the least and they buy the aggressor enough time for the very first powerful attack which ends it.

So essentially there is only one way to win...in a PvP battle using current game mechanics...first hit...be it a status or typical attack...the toon who hits first will always win...there is no strategy and it becomes obvious which classes have better advantages against the others. To gear your toon to survive the first hit, you have to sacrifice their ability to counter...which leaves them a target.

There are several other major hurdles that I wont elaborate on at this time...these are just the obvious one.
Key point, current game mechanics can not support a PvP system that will be anything close to satisfying or challenging...

Any PvP system that comes out will have one of two effects...it will nerf all the classes so they pretty much behave exactly the same and with much weaker stats or it will be a system completely different from what we are used to in Raids or Quests.

So for the gamers, realize, PvP will be nothing like what you are used to...there is no point in trying to figure if AP will be better for PvP, or if shields or 1H versus 2H will work better...your considering these options in light of the current mechanics...

I don't think we have a clue yet how PvP will actually work...and I would venture a bet that the ideas Venan currently has on the table to make it work are scary to them because it will require major game changes. (Nothing against you Venan, for my part you have designed a great game, but I think making PvP work in the current system is a very daunting task.)

My two-cents, just felt like venting today. :)
what if only for pvp area toons initial health multiplied by 10 for example? it should solve some issues about first hit win and give more time for strategy even if got first strike. initiative status resist and knockback resist enchants r probably addressing these issues. btw raising percentage of these enchants or for example lowering in arena dmg could easily make each toon arena tank and each duel some minutes.

but somehow I'm not really concerned about pvp as is. whats I'm really curious about it's duel win reward. venan always succeed in giving us some meaningful reward that powers up the toon. so I hope arena win reward will be some new currency that will buy new kind of things. like enchants that were introduced after valor-gear-gem.
I will be really dissapointed if reward will be silver or just numbers in some leaderboard table.
Why not make pvp gear that boosts resistances for pvp similar to WoW that is earned in pvp to address damage concerns.
Venan mentioned that pvp will be optional, which to me would mean that there would not be a reward in pvp more powerful than anything available by raiding or farming.

Getting rewards that could not be used in pvp from pvp would be odd, so runes and potions would be out. Perhaps transfer plates for rewards would make the most sense for some kind of tournament win.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Mar 7, 2013 11:30 pm
John12345,
You are correct in that there needs to be a significant adjustment in PvP that eliminates the first hit kill problem, as well as the amount of damage per hit proportional to health...though potent attacks should still be allowed that do massive damage, but require a strategic advantage to implement them. That aside, a multiplier in health or a limiter in damage only addresses the more obvious issues..others include the multiple techniques/methods in which a toon can keep another toon from ever landing a blow, by use of status skills, as long as they get first hit...a counter would be status resist, but what fun is it if every toon "has" to have status resist enchant in order to stand a chance in the match; But yes, a large change to health or damage would have to be present from the current mechanics.

Siushaga,
That would be a good idea, but then it will require an expanded backpack beyond the 50 limit as well as an entirely different set of gear/equipment for PvP. In reality, you would end up building an entirely separate toon for PvP compared to what you now have. Its one option, but again it doesnt address the limitation of the current mechanics, it would only give the Dev freedom from the constraints they have to deal with from the current gear/enchantment options.
I thought about this too. The damage thing may or may not be an issues. Reason being is that the big damage moves have a longer execution time and any opponent can stun/interrupt you before you get a chance to pull it off.

The main problem is going to be stun locks. Without addressing that PVP will be a pointless stun-fest.

Damage will be a concern too, but consider the fact that we have higher armor than most enemies in the game (many enemies seem to have none or very low amounts), we have the option of investing far more into defense than we currently do (most people NEVER slot any defensive stats), you can use defensive enchants as well...

A fully defensive toon can get:
-About 4k more health by slotting all red gems as health (and honestly not lose THAT much damage).
-Easily squeak out 20%+ Dodge and far more than that for SW.
-Somewhere around 15% I think phys/mag resistance.
-Power enchants depending on your needs (lower chance to be crit, smaller knockbacks, less damage taken).
-Using a shield will probably be a popular option since that's like straight up like 20% more defense, a chance to block damage (especially for Justicars with heavy shields), preventing a crit and reducing damage of a regular hit at the same time.
-Missing your enemies will happen a lot without investment into the Accuracy enchant, which will lower damage because it would be replacing the more popular damage enchant.

So while getting Crit by a mage's strongest fire spell may hurt, it's unlikely that they'd be able to crit you because you'd have to be open long enough, they would then have to bypass defense, resistance, block chance, actually HIT YOU, and hit you for more than your max health of over 8k. So it would definitely be a luck thing. So maybe for consistency if we have enough defensive options, people will opt for defense rather than trying to luck out. I think the resistance gems should be stronger than they are. If they change that alone, we should have plenty of defensive options to stave off getting annihilated by a single spell.

It's interesting to see what will happen. But if we all go into PVP with our current builds then yeah, it'll be a bit much. It may be necessary to lower our damage output and rebalance the game for lower numbers or increase the value of defensive gems like health and resistance.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun May 19, 2013 12:14 pm
You're right Mclovin, the status attacks are an issue. I know I gave them a passing mention in my first post, but to highlight the problem you're emphasizing, it still comes down to first hit wins.

Example: As a WM, I just need to land an Icy Grasp, which can be made insanely fast, and once stunned then I have all the time in the world for that 1-hit kill. (In reality even an Icy Grasp can still do 20-50% damage on most high end toons in the game)
SW and Justi have similar stuns, so it really comes down to who lands the first punch...unless as many of you have said, something dramatic changes in the health/damage scenario.

And yes, there may be need of investing heavily in certain enchants such as status resist and stats such as Dodge to avoid the first punch...and maybe that is what everyone will do...but then it takes away the strategy and makes winning a match entirely a game of chance and random number generator as you hope your attack lands/sticks first.

I guess what I would like to see is a possibility for PvP battles to have a bit of strategy, opportunity to recover from a bad roll, less dependence on statistics and lucky rolls...but that is going to be super difficult and always is.

...on the opposite end, most mobile apps do battles as nothing more than a match-up of stats and a little random number variation (think Mafia Wars, Crime City, Modern war, Sorority Life, Fantasy Hero,High School Hero ....). All such games as those just mentioned have PvP that merely compare stats and better stats wins...its what is used everywhere else simply because its easy...but never really satisfying.

RSVA_Veteran_rastafish

Sun May 19, 2013 6:45 pm
Everything is pro-rated based on stats. So 3000 dmg does 300. 10k crit does 1k dmg etc. It would have to be turn-based as well imo.

I think there is more potential for guild war i. e. Challenge another guild to a raid time or challenge.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun May 19, 2013 10:08 pm
RSVA_Veteran_rastafish wrote:Everything is pro-rated based on stats. So 3000 dmg does 300. 10k crit does 1k dmg etc. It would have to be turn-based as well imo.

I think there is more potential for guild war i. e. Challenge another guild to a raid time or challenge.

I would love a guild war type challenge. There are a few games that do that and it's quite entertaining.