Book of Heroes

Guild Loyalty - Suggested System · page 2

Totally agree with Mithrid - some great suggestions there.
I love joining other guilds raids to freshen things up, but I also love chatting with people in my own guild. Currently, once you are made an officer, you are essentially 'trapped' in your guild. If you could merc without leaving I'd be in heaven - and that suggestion that you only get guild perks from the guild where you are a permanent member is genius - there is your guild loyalty right there.
There might need to be some systems put in to avoid more than 60 people in a raid at once. And it would be nice to have another option in the chat to see your own guild's chat or your visited guild's chat.

Please Venan - make this happen!!
Coming from someone who has been on an active loyal guild from the beginning, mercs suck. I'm a part of a very active raiding guild who has been together since Lockbolt raids. Sure we've picked up a few gems a long the way, but we've got a solid raiding core that has done all raids through CK without any merc help. We run 8-10 raids a day depending and we've never, nor would we consider, using mercs.

Mercs ruin the sanctity of guilds. Guilds are and always have been a group of players who stick together, grow together and raid the current content. What's the point in having a guild system if an obvious good amount of players just merc? It's making strong hardcore raiding guilds like mine become obsolete. Guilds are becoming secluded chat rooms for players to pop in, raid, and pop back out. What's he point of the whole "home guild" system if you're going to go mercing and come back to significantly lower than you players. Unless you're all mercing, then is that even a guild?

The point I'm trying to get to is this, I'm a part of rank 34 raiding guild Crypt of Canadians. We're young and growing extremely fast. We recently progressed to KV raids and tried our first attempt in the speed run format for the event. We finished in around 10 minutes and thought we had smoked the competition. Turns out, Party of Fore literally destroyed our time with 4 mins and 1 second!! How?! They tell you how in their guild description, mercs. That's utterly ridiculous that a guild can just recruit mercs out of global chat and then knock off a true guild like that. Sure, maybe we wouldn't have won. But we would have had a hell of a chance at it if it was a true guild loyalty event. I'm not upset that we didn't get the winning time, Im more angry that I feel like mercing ripped off a supposed "guild challenge". We're as loyal a guild as any and we got the shaft because of mercs.

I'm just putting this point out there because this discussion has been very one sided thus far. There are still loyal guilds out there. Some not too far from the top.
Draake wrote:Coming from someone who has been on an active loyal guild from the beginning, mercs suck. I'm a part of a very active raiding guild who has been together since Lockbolt raids. Sure we've picked up a few gems a long the way, but we've got a solid raiding core that has done all raids through CK without any merc help. We run 8-10 raids a day depending and we've never, nor would we consider, using mercs.

Mercs ruin the sanctity of guilds. Guilds are and always have been a group of players who stick together, grow together and raid the current content. What's he point in having a guild system if an obvious good amount of players just merc? It's making strong hardcore raiding guilds like mine become obsolete. Guilds are becoming secluded chat rooms for players to pop in, raid, and pop back out. What's he point I the whole "home guild" system if you're going to go mercing and come back to significantly lower than you players. Unless you're all mercing, then is that even a guild?

The point I'm trying to get to is this, I'm a part of rank 34 raiding guild Crypt of Canadians. We're young and growing extremely fast. We recently progressed o KV raids and tried our first attempt in the speed run format for the event. We finished in around 10 minutes and thought we had smoked the competition. Turns out, Party of Fore literally destroyed our time with 4 mins and 1 second!! How?! They tell you how in their guild description, mercs. That's utterly ridiculous that a guild can just recruit mercs out of global chat and then knock off a true guild like that. Sure, maybe we wouldn't have won. But we would have had a hell of a chance at it if it was a true guild loyalty event. I'm not upset that we didn't get the winning time, Im more angry that I feel like mercing ripped off a suppose "guild challenge". We're as loyal a guild as any and we got the shaft because of mercs.

Well, its nice to hear from someone from the other side for once with actual valid points. Ideally, yes, if every guild had a core group of 50+ players that could be online all at the same time, then sure, the case for keeping guild lines hard makes sense. But three points I want to make. First is, for many guilds, we have players in all time zones. Realistically asking everyone to be online at the same time just isn't feasible. Secondly, not trying to diminish your achievement, but up through CK, its a lot easier to cohesively work well with a guild. But by VG and GK, we're talking about 3-5 hour raids that require a minimum of 30+ people on through (if no one spends shields) to hit gold. I'm not saying it's impossible. It's just the we hit the grey area of real life stepping in and to get that number of people to show up for raids throughout the day when you're on different zones is tough. This game has always been billed as a casual mmo, not so much a hardcore one.
And thirdly, social aspect is lost I feel if those guild lines become hard. Majority of the friends I've met in BoH have been outside of my guild. My guild is great, don't get me wrong, but it's fun switching it up and raiding with others once in a while.

However, the point of the home guild system is exactly that. To have a guild you call home, that you and others identify you with, and where you primarily raid. I average 8 raids a day, 2-3 of which are at my home guild. We're a CV guild, and I'm still in need of some KV items so I find myself mercing out to help out with KV raids elsewhere.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Mar 14, 2013 10:34 am
Draake wrote:
The point I'm trying to get to is this, I'm a part of rank 34 raiding guild Crypt of Canadians. We're young and growing extremely fast. We recently progressed to KV raids and tried our first attempt in the speed run format for the event. We finished in around 10 minutes and thought we had smoked the competition. Turns out, Party of Fore literally destroyed our time with 4 mins and 1 second!! How?! They tell you how in their guild description, mercs. That's utterly ridiculous that a guild can just recruit mercs out of global chat and then knock off a true guild like that. Sure, maybe we wouldn't have won. But we would have had a hell of a chance at it if it was a true guild loyalty event. I'm not upset that we didn't get the winning time, Im more angry that I feel like mercing ripped off a supposed "guild challenge". We're as loyal a guild as any and we got the shaft because of mercs.

I'm just putting this point out there because this discussion has been very one sided thus far. There are still loyal guilds out there. Some not too far from the top.

Draake,
I think your actual complaint is not the idea of Mercs or how they affect the game; what is really irking you at the moment is how the speed contest was skewed to top players diving to lower guilds to burn up times, and yes this had the effect of jerrying the speed competition. But lets be clear, your anger is not directed at mercs rather the result of your guild not having a fair competition with similarly ranked guilds/toons. That would be one beauty of the "Home guild" system. It would not discourage merc'ing as it currently stands, as mercs are a very valuable to the BoH community, however future competitions could be held requiring home guild members only...and to limit bringing in ringers, you simply have a time delay on how fast a toon can actually change home guilds (this would still allow mercing in the current raid system but can easily create a segmentation of guild to guild competition and normal raids).
Example permanent membership takes 24hrs to be accepted. And for special raids, such as a competition raid, the guildmaster or officers would set a raid condition to "Permanent members only" where visitors and recruits get booted or cant participate. There are a myriad of ways to fix the competition, but lets be specific about your complaint...its not about mercs, its about the competition wasn't geared towards a true loyal guild...but that is simply because as the game currently stands, there is no such thing as a true home guild.
-Mith
[/quote]

Well, its nice to hear from someone from the other side for once with actual valid points. Ideally, yes, if every guild had a core group of 50+ players that could be online all at the same time, then sure, the case for keeping guild lines hard makes sense. But three points I want to make. First is, for many guilds, we have players in all time zones. Realistically asking everyone to be online at the same time just isn't feasible. Secondly, not trying to diminish your achievement, but up through CK, its a lot easier to cohesively work well with a guild. But by VG and GK, we're talking about 3-5 hour raids that require a minimum of 30+ people on through (if no one spends shields) to hit gold. I'm not saying it's impossible. It's just the we hit the grey area of real life stepping in and to get that number of people to show up for raids throughout the day when you're on different zones is tough. This game has always been billed as a casual mmo, not so much a hardcore one.
And thirdly, social aspect is lost I feel if those guild lines become hard. Majority of the friends I've met in BoH have been outside of my guild. My guild is great, don't get me wrong, but it's fun switching it up and raiding with others once in a while.

However, the point of the home guild system is exactly that. To have a guild you call home, that you and others identify you with, and where you primarily raid. I average 8 raids a day, 2-3 of which are at my home guild. We're a CV guild, and I'm still in need of some KV items so I find myself mercing out to help out with KV raids elsewhere.[/quote]

Thanks oda!!!

See the thing is we're called Crypts of Canadians, and just as the name suggests the majority of us are North American or Canadian. So we're pretty lucky in that aspect :) But we do run 8-10 raids a day. Minimum 3 CK, 2-3 Kraken for quick SV and Zuur at 4pm est everyday. That way everyone gets a chance! We've all come to be good friends and have developed a great rapport. So we don't face that problem. The name draws that time zone generally (we do have one Swedish guy who spices it up lol) We also have an array of officers and players who are always burning for the RPP. So we never have a problem.
I like the idea as a "carrot" solution:)
though guild benefits doesn't really matter for my 17-20k toons (maybe only for onslaught), it could be nice to associate myself with a guild without loosing merc freedom (waves to fero Amy and wookie)
and if venan adds some % bonus on valor / hero tokens while raiding with home guild it gives me even more motivation.
the bonus of course shouldntt be accumulating
btw before speaking of guild loyalIty, new content should be added to guilds. guild challenges r nice but one day u finish it :)
and guild benefits as I said rnt too much meaningful as i see it.
but if first x places in power leaderboard will give rewards to toon which had this guild as home guild during full week it gives more straight forward motivation to all guild members to develop their guild and by this develop their toon. rewards could be valor ht essence or even gs;) maybe enchanting transfer plate to most active guild members. in-guild activity board could be also nice to check how much each toon contributing compared to others.
Great idea Mithrid, I am extremely active player and have progressed ahead of starting guild. Mercing is only way I can remain loyal to starting guild and progress character.
With recent pooled speed run based on guilds highest valor level a lot of guilds migrated to much lower guilds and it concerns me they have forced Venans hand and may disrupt mercing completely. With this system venan can place a maximum substitutes limit during events and resolve issue without stopping general mercing.
Draake wrote:
Thanks oda!!!

See the thing is we're called Crypts of Canadians, and just as the name suggests the majority of us are North American or Canadian. So we're pretty lucky in that aspect :) But we do run 8-10 raids a day. Minimum 3 CK, 2-3 Kraken for quick SV and Zuur at 4pm est everyday. That way everyone gets a chance! We've all come to be good friends and have developed a great rapport. So we don't face that problem. The name draws that time zone generally (we do have one Swedish guy who spices it up lol) We also have an array of officers and players who are always burning for the RPP. So we never have a problem.


You won't be running 8-10 raids a day when you hit CV raids - it'll be 4-5 maximum, purely because of the long cooldown periods. I've settled in one Guild now because the raiding times suit me, but even then one of our five daily raids starts at 5am for me on the West Coast of the USA, while another starts at 11pm for my East Coast Guildmates. You'll have exactly the same problem before too long. Right now you, and your Guild, are still relatively new to the game. I've been playing since before Guilds existed, and have seen Guilds rise and fall in the charts, because it's nearly impossible to get 60 players who are happy to (or even can) share a raid schedule equally. Some burn energy potions or GS and get the lion's share of the rewards, then move out because they are above their Guildmates. Others drop out becasue they can't keep up, or get dropped because they are not active enough.

I like being in a multicultural Guild, with players from around the world. If Guilds have to become a monoculture just to complete a raid, the game will become less interestin.

I'm sure Venan are acutely aware of the minefield they will be stepping into. They need to make staying on one Guild more attractive, while still allowing people to move freely if they so wish.
Draake wrote: Sure we've picked up a few gems a long the way, but we've got a solid raiding core that has done all raids through CK without any merc help.

In other words, you have done the easy part. Most of us older players have run our original guild to Vallus or FS. The stretch to grow from CK to WoF is the guild killer and will probably completely change your point of view. As far as I know, there are no guild that runs Vallus or higher without frequently using mercs.