We've been told that Venan intend to introduce some form of Guild Loyalty System to reduce the prevalance of mercenaries - toons that jump from Guild to Guild to join in whatever raids they choose, for whatever reasons.
I see this as a net negative for the BoH world. Players who merc currently form a network of relationships across the BoH world, and if we are forced, or desire, to stick rigidly to a single Guild, the social aspect of the game drops off dramatically. Players whose lifestyles do not allow them to adhere to the rigid raid schedule of one Guild may see this as the opportune moment to drop the game.
Disregarding the wisdom or necessity of this, I've started this thread for people to make suggestions as to what form of Loyalty system they'd like to see.
Ther are two main roads to take, the stick and the carrot. You can punish people for moving (say, reduce their RPP returns for the first 24 hours in a new Guild), or give them a bonus for staying with the same Guild.
Taking the latter course as preferable to players, my suggestion is a 1% bonus to raid rewards (Valor and Hero Tokens) for each ten consecutive raids completed in the same Guild, maxing out as a 5% bonus after 50 raids.
I definitely like the idea of a bonus rather than a punishment, however, I don't think 1-5% over 50 raids will really stop mercs to any real significance. It's too little of a bonus to give up jumping around (I do 8-10 raids on a given day, only two of which are at my guild... I'd have to drop 8 raids for a 1-5% bonus).
I guess my worry is that it's tough to find that balance. Too high of a bonus and the networking fun of meeting other people/guilds gets lost, and too low of a bonus just provides an ineffective fix. And worst case, if they implement the timer, it only makes things even worse.
Hopefully they're smarter than me though and can think up a solution that benefits everyone.
Oda_tennischamp5 wrote:I definitely like the idea of a bonus rather than a punishment
That is just a difference in semantics. They are the same thing.
I truly fear this change (as well as fearing PvP damaging the culture) and I play both side of the coin. Member/Officer of one guild and merc my alts.
Bbbb wrote:Oda_tennischamp5 wrote:I definitely like the idea of a bonus rather than a punishment
That is just a difference in semantics. They are the same thing.
I truly fear this change (as well as fearing PvP damaging the culture) and I play both side of the coin. Member/Officer of one guild and merc my alts.
Heh... you're right. Didn't even consider that. Well, either way, I'm not super thrilled about it but if it has to happen, I hope it doesn't change mechanics too much. The current system may be a little weird, but it works.
I agree entirely with Musket that the mercs do provide a great social network that allows the whole BoH world to interact...and this as I have spent most of my time merc'n in the BoH world.
Something I have found interesting is when people who are definitely of a specific guild leave to either merc or travel to visit other guilds get asked often..Oh did you leave such and such guild or are you a member of this guild now and so forth...the only factor that ties a member to a guild is that they are present in the guild all the time. Another thing that is silly is that if you get promoted..and you leave even if only to help out another guild, or visit friends...upon your return you are no longer a member of any standing. Also currently apart from Officers/Veterans being able to start stop raids...the other guild status's of member and veteran, they are useless..meaningless.
As such, I think there needs to be a method to allow players to tie themselves to a guild and yet still travel or merc (maintaining the social aspect of BoH), and then return to their home guild in full rank. This method should also provide an easy means for people to recognize which guild anyone belongs to even when merc'n, visiting or traveling. It should also remove the constant question of "which guild are you with?" as no one is certain unless they see you in that guild all the time.
The mechanism should provide a system of benefits as already commented on, and yet give incentive for people to want to be associated with a guild permanently.
I'll throw out this idea:
Every toon gets a two new parameters:
Home Guild: Home Guild is the guild where a guild Master has accepted this toon as a "permanent member"
Current Guild: This is the guild the toon is currently visiting in, residing in, raiding in, merc'n in at the moment, though they may not be a member of the guild.
Both parameters would be displayed on the Toons inspection window.
As for Guild membership:
Give each Guild a limited 60 permanent guild member slots. These are awarded by GuildMasters, maybe officers to toons who apply.
Do not touch the current "active guild member" limit of 60 people.
(edit: this is the same as the current limit for raiding with the guild)
Each guild then has two lists to track from a programming stand point: permanent members and current raiding members/mercs/visitors). both list are limited to 60 slots.
When your a permanent member of the guild, it shows up as your home guild status along with your rank. Even when visiting other guilds, everyone will know who who associate yourself with. When you return to your home guild, you automatically have full member/officer status due you...no one needs to re-promote you.
Now if a home guild has filled up with mercs, say to the 60 limit max when a permanent member wants to rejoin, then they either have to wait, or have an officer currently residing in the home guild boot someone to make room...this effect doesn't mess up the current game mechanics on guild limits. You will not have more than 60 active raiders at a time. Even permanent members than would have to wait for a spot to open up when they return.
It would also be up to the guild masters to manage their record of old or non-active permanent members. They could determine how to award memberships and ranks to players with multiple toons, this would even give guilds a reason to actively recruit. This would create uniqueness in management style of each guild that currently can't exist.
As for loyalty benefits: Guild bonuses should not affect recruits or visitors. If your guild has earned a bunch of bonuss, those bonuses affect only permanent members. And the affects should be based on status: members get all bonuses at default level: veterans and above whould get a 5% bonus (or something) on top of the default level.
When a permanent member travels, they take their home guild bonuses with them, local guild bonuses do not apply as already mentioned. Again, so visitors of a new guild, including mercs or members of other guilds, DO NOT get to benefit the local guild bonuses. Only permanent members get guild bonuses..and they carry those when they visit other guilds. This will encourage everyone at some point to join a guild and help build it up, while at the same time it will not punish people who want to be completely independent mercs, other than they dont get to sponge off the guild bonuses other people strove to work for.
However, this doesn't punish merc'n or visiting other guilds. It also in fact allows toons to establish strong ties with a home guild and then merc using home guild bonuses. It also creates a more cooperative environment where guilds can help each other.
This also encourages and rewards guild members who work together to achieve guild goals, and allows a guildmaster to reward those people with permanent membership...while mercs will not get to take advantage of the bonuses, but why should they, they are mercs and just visiting. But if they are merging from a home guild, they get the benefits of their home guild themselves, so they are not really punished at all, but rather encourage to eventually create a home.
This way, there is incentive to have a home guild, but it wont limit socializing in the game. It will allow for membership status to be meaningful, create a stronger association for guild membership and yet not hamper the playing of mercs or one guild visiting another to help out in a raid.
It could even allow for a whole new feature of guild alliances as well as guild rivalries which I have been thinking about for quite sometime. I'll save those thoughts later.
My though for the day.
-Mithrid
Wow.... mithrid... I fully support that solution. That's an excellent idea.
+1
+1
+1 again.
Oda_tennischamp5 wrote:Wow.... mithrid... I fully support that solution. That's an excellent idea.
+1
+1
+1 again.
Thanks Tennis.
I did forget a PS: Hey Venan...this should be a "piece of cake to code" into the current system and should NOT affect current game/guild raiding mechanics at all.

Yeah, that's the part I liked best.
Earlier, Venan expressed issues that it'd be tough to code that in because there servers would have to keep track of 1000s of ex-players w/ranks. But by keeping those limits, and having two parameters for current/home guilds, it makes it easy to code and sensible to implement.
Very well thought out

There is only one way to be 100% fair. And that's if everyone is screwed,a guild cooldown u quit and ur screwed for 48 hrs and/or a daily reward that multiplies of eachday u stay in a guild. I don't really care either way I like the game the way it or just come up with a random raid generator that anyone can que for and each person brings the buffs that they have from their guild but to que for raids u would have to have full energy or whatever and if u don't spend a set amount of energy u get nothing also... There's prolly hundreds of ways of fixing the problem... If u see it as a problem.. There's always Gona be problems with fairness unless everyone is screwed then they all come together for help