Cas,
Your still my favorite bunny!!!
As for the thread...I'm as neutral as can be but I would like to just state a few facts (yes Ill dare say the word facts):
1. CoC is one of the worst Hero Token payouts per RPP/e spent in the game...you don't do CoC for Hero Training otherwise you need to go back and study remedial math.
2. The silver payout is decent per e spent...this makes a lot of sense for lower level characters...but lets be honest, at Lvl30 and above silver is worthless....unless you have a Lockbox gambling addiction. And as far as needing it for enchanting and so forth...I'm sitting on 10's millions of silver that I will never need...you get plenty of silver for any enchanting/crafting needs from regular raiding...hell, from regular farming for materials...you don't need CoC for silver at high levels.
3.Ichor...it is a great source of undead Ichor...which is useful at high levels...if your actually crafting a lot of potions.
4. Hero Score: It pays out, if you are a high level toon with nice stats, on average 2-3x the Hero Score per E spent than any other raid. This is exactly why it is run over and over again by Toons looking to add to their hero score...call it whatever you want, but if you want a high Hero Score for the best investment...this is the only real value in running CoC all the time: is a simple GS/E investment numbers game.
The following are my opinions:
1. I enjoy a CoC every now and then because it does pay out decent Ichor and its a fun run to do as a break from the regular raids...I think that it is a great play for CoC. Nothing wrong with it.
2. You can get to top 5 weekly without having to run CoC's...I have (my last top 5 run, I only did 2 CoC's)...but realize that if you are competing against people running CoC all the time you will spend twice as much in GS to get there, per Hero Score point, as the CoC'er will...the actual tap counts do not vary as much...you all still have to tap the same number of waves...but CoC is the cheapest means of racking up Hero Score..and the fastest considering every wave is generally a one hit kill for high level toons.
(and most top 5 score toons do tend to run CoC's as a majority of their raids..don't bother argueing this point with a few examples contrary...if you go back over the last several months of top5..its obvious what raids are being run all the time by the majortity of the winners).
Incidentally when I did it last, I had over 5-10 daily raids that week with >50k RPP in GK and VG including my personal best of 69k RPP for VG and 74k RPP for GK...its possible to win top5 doing non-CoC raiding, but be prepared to spend more GS than your competition if you do not run CoC the whole time. I'm not complaining, what I am saying is just be aware of the difference and accept it as it is.
3. Hero Score is meaningless as a game stat...it really doesn't say anything about the history of the toon. (OPINION...and I've been around since early 1.3, probably prior if I thought hard about it)
I feel it is appropriate to sign off with my alter ego (this is for you Cas!)
-CoC_n_VGs