Tiff (IRnaked),
You have a valid point of debate, so lets break it down.
Lets make one simplification: lets not consider regenerated E and just focus on Hero Token/ e spent (HT/e).
I am also going to ignore initial wave RPP values (100-145) and just use 150 RPP per wave.
CoC on average payout 6-7 HT/1k RPP ( don't have very many CoC stats so this is a limited dataset. <20 CoC's)
Thats about roughly 0.0065 HT/RPP
VG: pays-outs on average 31.7 HT/1K RPP or 0.0315 HT/RPP (I have nearly 100 VG raids creating this sat)
Normal Raids are easy to calculate HT/e: 150 RPP/2e = 75 Rpp/e * 0.0315 HT/RPP = 2.3625 HT/e spent
Now COC is different because the RPP/e varies. so rather than fix a number to it, lets look at what amount of RPP/4e is necessary to break even with VG.
VG value CoC function (Xcoc RPP/e for CoC raid..it varies)
2.3625 HT/e = 0.0065 HT/RPP * Xcoc RPP/e solve for X
Xcoc RPP/e = 2.36/(0.0065) = 363.46 RPP/e
For 4e: you need a CoC wave to earn 1453 RPP to be on par with a VG.
At a modified Haste of 60% (all T5 haste gems plus a few extra Haste gems with an elixir of haste- no Haste Pot), a typical maxed War Mage who kills every attack will average between 1300-1600 a wave. (Your 2000-3000 are outlier cases..not averages, unless your burning pots for every CoC you run, and even then...)
So you are right...if a toon average >1450 RPP every wave of a CoC, they can break even with a VG.
Most do not, in fact most fall far short of that average even with maxed toons, and those that do meet the average need to burn a hell of a lot of Haste Pots to do it.
At the end of the day then, CoC is a bad investment for a toon regarding Hero Tokens unless they can keep a very high average RPP/4e...and if they need a lot of Haste Pots to do it...you would have to factor in the time and e/gs spent to earn all the ingredients necessary for the haste post to match that spent in a VG raid.
That being said, under an extreme circumstance, yes CoC can beat a VG for Hero Token payout...but it is not common and does not factor in the additional opportunity cost of say harvesting materials for Haste pots.
Regards,
Coc_n_VGs
You have a valid point of debate, so lets break it down.
Lets make one simplification: lets not consider regenerated E and just focus on Hero Token/ e spent (HT/e).
I am also going to ignore initial wave RPP values (100-145) and just use 150 RPP per wave.
CoC on average payout 6-7 HT/1k RPP ( don't have very many CoC stats so this is a limited dataset. <20 CoC's)
Thats about roughly 0.0065 HT/RPP
VG: pays-outs on average 31.7 HT/1K RPP or 0.0315 HT/RPP (I have nearly 100 VG raids creating this sat)
Normal Raids are easy to calculate HT/e: 150 RPP/2e = 75 Rpp/e * 0.0315 HT/RPP = 2.3625 HT/e spent
Now COC is different because the RPP/e varies. so rather than fix a number to it, lets look at what amount of RPP/4e is necessary to break even with VG.
VG value CoC function (Xcoc RPP/e for CoC raid..it varies)
2.3625 HT/e = 0.0065 HT/RPP * Xcoc RPP/e solve for X
Xcoc RPP/e = 2.36/(0.0065) = 363.46 RPP/e
For 4e: you need a CoC wave to earn 1453 RPP to be on par with a VG.
At a modified Haste of 60% (all T5 haste gems plus a few extra Haste gems with an elixir of haste- no Haste Pot), a typical maxed War Mage who kills every attack will average between 1300-1600 a wave. (Your 2000-3000 are outlier cases..not averages, unless your burning pots for every CoC you run, and even then...)
So you are right...if a toon average >1450 RPP every wave of a CoC, they can break even with a VG.
Most do not, in fact most fall far short of that average even with maxed toons, and those that do meet the average need to burn a hell of a lot of Haste Pots to do it.
At the end of the day then, CoC is a bad investment for a toon regarding Hero Tokens unless they can keep a very high average RPP/4e...and if they need a lot of Haste Pots to do it...you would have to factor in the time and e/gs spent to earn all the ingredients necessary for the haste post to match that spent in a VG raid.
That being said, under an extreme circumstance, yes CoC can beat a VG for Hero Token payout...but it is not common and does not factor in the additional opportunity cost of say harvesting materials for Haste pots.
Regards,
Coc_n_VGs