Book of Heroes

Significance of CoC- Be Civil, No Swearing · page 4

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Mar 20, 2013 1:39 am
Tiff (IRnaked),
You have a valid point of debate, so lets break it down.

Lets make one simplification: lets not consider regenerated E and just focus on Hero Token/ e spent (HT/e).
I am also going to ignore initial wave RPP values (100-145) and just use 150 RPP per wave.

CoC on average payout 6-7 HT/1k RPP ( don't have very many CoC stats so this is a limited dataset. <20 CoC's)
Thats about roughly 0.0065 HT/RPP

VG: pays-outs on average 31.7 HT/1K RPP or 0.0315 HT/RPP (I have nearly 100 VG raids creating this sat)

Normal Raids are easy to calculate HT/e: 150 RPP/2e = 75 Rpp/e * 0.0315 HT/RPP = 2.3625 HT/e spent

Now COC is different because the RPP/e varies. so rather than fix a number to it, lets look at what amount of RPP/4e is necessary to break even with VG.
VG value CoC function (Xcoc RPP/e for CoC raid..it varies)
2.3625 HT/e = 0.0065 HT/RPP * Xcoc RPP/e solve for X

Xcoc RPP/e = 2.36/(0.0065) = 363.46 RPP/e

For 4e: you need a CoC wave to earn 1453 RPP to be on par with a VG.

At a modified Haste of 60% (all T5 haste gems plus a few extra Haste gems with an elixir of haste- no Haste Pot), a typical maxed War Mage who kills every attack will average between 1300-1600 a wave. (Your 2000-3000 are outlier cases..not averages, unless your burning pots for every CoC you run, and even then...)

So you are right...if a toon average >1450 RPP every wave of a CoC, they can break even with a VG.

Most do not, in fact most fall far short of that average even with maxed toons, and those that do meet the average need to burn a hell of a lot of Haste Pots to do it.

At the end of the day then, CoC is a bad investment for a toon regarding Hero Tokens unless they can keep a very high average RPP/4e...and if they need a lot of Haste Pots to do it...you would have to factor in the time and e/gs spent to earn all the ingredients necessary for the haste post to match that spent in a VG raid.

That being said, under an extreme circumstance, yes CoC can beat a VG for Hero Token payout...but it is not common and does not factor in the additional opportunity cost of say harvesting materials for Haste pots.

Regards,
Coc_n_VGs
Mith, I've done coc for the past two weeks constantly. I'm 13.7k might, nowhere near max. I'm a SW, with mainly T10/12 equip and gem tier averaging 3.8 :/

Trust me, without pots, solely w/ speed elixir at 53% haste, i'm easily able to do 1800 rpp a round. With luck/pots, that number hits 2250-2400.

Nowhere near maxed... check the post right before yours.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Mar 20, 2013 1:50 am
Tennis,
When you consider RPP and Hero token payouts, you have to also consider Gold/Silver/Bronze as well as MVP status.
All of those have a significant influence on final payouts.

Also, # of participants in a raid affects dramatically (on a comparative scale) payout as well since if you have 50 players, the number of early waves where e was spent making only 100-145 RPP per wave is vastly different than a raid with 3 people where a significantly smaller group of people burned e on low RPP waves.

To accommodate for all this, you either take huge averages to create generalities, or you cherry pick individual data points to tell the story you want...in statistics, you can make them say anything you want if you know how to manipulate the data. Just listen to politicians... ;)
Mithrid wrote:Tennis,
When you consider RPP and Hero token payouts, you have to also consider Gold/Silver/Bronze as well as MVP status.
All of those have a significant influence on final payouts.

Also, # of participants in a raid affects dramatically (on a comparative scale) payout as well since if you have 50 players, the number of early waves where e was spent making only 100-145 RPP per wave is vastly different than a raid with 3 people where a significantly smaller group of people burned e on low RPP waves.

To accommodate for all this, you either take huge averages to create generalities, or you cherry pick individual data points to tell the story you want...in statistics, you can make them say anything you want if you know how to manipulate the data. Just listen to politicians... ;)

Well then disregard my data. But it doesn't change the fact that 1450 RPP isn't anywhere near difficult for most toons to do. I can't speak for WMs or Justicars, but I can guarantee that a SW can hit 1450 every round at my might (with the right build and experience) except for the occasional bad luck in phase 2, where nothing goes my way... and I end up with 1350. :/

As much as I'd like to think I'm crazy, I think my math holds true. I make a point of trying to do the best payout I can and GK nor VG has kept up for me.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Mar 20, 2013 1:55 am
Tennis,
Regarding your comment on average RPP...you may have a point...I have hardly run any CoC's myself...less than probably 30 my entire Boh career....I focus mostly on building speed in a normal raids.

Ill take sometime to tweak my toon for CoC's and see if I can get the averages you guys are suggesting. I may have to eat my words.

The math still holds, I would need to average >1450 RPP per 4e though to break even without needed extra effort else where for pots and so forth.
Well, give it a shot, and see what happens ;)

You may find you like it... and if we win over enough converts, maybe instead of CoC, we can start doing more SCs and maybe that'll lead to a CV onslaught.

Goal is to remove the stigma around onslaught. Too many players had bad experiences with it at low mights and are terrified to ever try it again.

Best of luck! Thank you for the vg/coc rates though. I didn't know 1450 was the break even point... gives me a very good frame of reference to work off of.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Mar 20, 2013 2:04 am
Oh I like CoC's occasionally, and as I stated, Im neutral on the whole debate, I think they can be very fun...I just enjoy raiding a lot though.

That being said, your not off the hook Tennis, I may need to come pick your brain about how you tweak and work your build for the CoC waves. ;)
Mithrid wrote:That being said, your not off the hook Tennis, I may need to come pick your brain about how you tweak and work your build for the CoC waves. ;)

Feel free to whisper ;) Always glad to help. Tiffy and hop might be better advise-givers, but I'll gladly do what I can ;) In tiffy's immortal words... sharing is caring (I think that was her).

I just find it fun to see how far I can go in onslaught with as low might as possible. Unfortunately, I'm kinda straddling the line here. Feel like anything below like 12.5k won't be able to keep to the same results.
Good point mith I didn't know others are hitting 1450 RPP. Myself never under 1800 RPP. Mostly 2100-2400 RPP per wave and that's without haste pot, i don't use any pot in raid coz I'm that lazy. I only used pot in speed run. I have been playing BoH for a month so far and all my hero training are already at 500 hero tokens now. Im trying to max them out before 1.6 so hehehehe, Thanks to CoC. Allowing me to burn my 42 energy fast and not having to sit in a CV raid for hours hitting monster losing health drinking health pot using break runes etc. I never get hit in CoC once have to drink some cleansing pot once in a while tho. I'm a SW, poor me. I don't kill as fast as other class in Cv raid. So go for CoC and it's turning out great for me so far.

CoC is easy and u can solo it urself while Cv raid u need lots of people to raid tgt. And if u want to finish a CV raid fast. U need lots of solid people willing to burn gs with u to finish it fast. I hate sitting there 2-3hrs hitting vile non stop while most other players sit there and wait for energy regen. (sorry if I offended anyone here)

When I raid. I like big RPP. I burn lots of gs if I'm in CV raid. And I got most CV I needed so far. So I'm doing CoC to save my GS. If I want. I can do 45k RPP in VG daily too. But that's gonna be 100+ gs daily. And i don't want to see my gs being spent that fast :cry: :cry: and I need lots of concentration if I'm doing VG (try not to get killed) but when I do CoC. Coz I know my rotation well enough I don't have to worry as much. coC makes me love my SW .

Cascadia_LoveBunny

Wed Mar 20, 2013 2:18 am
Mithrid wrote:Cas,
Your still my favorite bunny!!! :)

I feel it is appropriate to sign off with my alter ego (this is for you Cas!)

-CoC_n_VGs

Mith! I am so glad that I am your favorite bunny. Especially since the other Bunny is a guy and I don't think you would enjoy doing CoC with him.
I am happy to Spoon a CoC n VG along side or from below (RPP wise of course) with you anytime. As you know a good CoC never grows old. But if it did, well, there's elixirs for that. And a quick, well run VG is always a treat too.
See you Spoon, my friend.
Cascadia Bunny