Lucky's spawn rate is dreadful. Turned lvl 19 and found him, second spawn, at the tomb of vallus. Now I am almost lvl 21 and he has yet to show up again.
I disagree. This event is beyond stupid and makes me feel like I will start playing Empire online again.
Lucky took about 300+ energy for me to get 10 clovers and then the 50/50 chance netted me 10k silver, an award that couldn't be more of a slap in the face for a level 29 SW being forced to spend 2E in the game ruining Epic areas where monsters can hit for 1.6k every 1.3 seconds. I can't say I got the right side of any coin for this event.
Maybe this is partly my fault for no rerolling classes when I came back to the game. Or maybe epic areas were poorly thought out for a game where raising might rating quickly REQUIRES buying GS. I am at a loss for words with this game after I hit 29, the event was just a nail in the coffin.
I have to respectfully disagree on "good job" as a way to describe this event. At least with TV I knew I would get the feat after some carefully planned grinding. With Lucky, my main was the only one to get the Sham crock. I did NOTHING except raid Ebian, draining all energy multiple times a day and barely got enough clovers for 7 Boxes and yet my alt still did not get the Sham feat.
I said it before and I'll say it again: Luck-based progression is terrible. Especially if you're using a poor choice of probability distribution.
Ok, I have two points on this.
One, I get it from Venans point of view, Its going to be based on luck, since its LUCKY. But i also see how that sucks, since luck based progression always sucks.
It came at a back time for me, since I am on the Vile gate quests, and I am currently on Vile gate II. Doing them at the same time proved stupid and pointless, and I was going crazy, so I had to pick between the two. After my third lame lockbox, I gave up and quit doing either one. I got a sham rock, and that was that.
Ive got a wagon of goldshields, but thats the last of the money ill spend on this game. they are copying the WoW model, but im starting to see how they are getting too many of the bad parts of WoW without learning any of WoWs lessons. I could start an entire thread of critique but I digress. Point is, Lucky was an ok event. I liked Tragic better, but didn't realize how it worked really until it was far too late, as i had just came back into the game at that point. Hell, my character was still using tier 1 legacy gear with stats on it if that tells you anything.
I think the lucky event was a joke I got 12 lockboxs and no sham rock , I understand bad luck but what was the drop rate ? After event and no rock it just seemed like a waste of time
Sadly there is a little insult to injury on this one. Like most adults out there I go to work on Monday morning. I got up checked in BoH and went to work. Late night at the office resulted in me coming home and going to bed. Log in today only to find sham rock raised to 50% drop rate on the last 15 hours of the event?!?!?!?!
Well if that isn't a big freaking pile of **** in my eye!
I appreciate the fact that you guys realize on some level the poor execution of the event, but to only enable the fix with no notice and extremely limited time frame hurts more than no fix. The time for that would have been Sunday morning so your customers would have time to take advantage and sing your praises.
0 sham rocks, way too many Lucky spawns, not nearly enough fun.
I was lucky to have spotted the increased rock drop rate Monday evening (5-ish EDT), so I got to work on my four rockless chars then. 3 of the 4 hit on their first shot... the other took 3 tries (and several energy potions from a previous event).
Perhaps selling a rock in the black market might soothe the feat chasers who missed the updated drop rate.
In future, I might recommend that holiday feats be attainable by spending about 100e per day of event (about the difficulty of the 5 lucky lockbox if you figure 25 lucky kills and 20e spent per lucky giving 500e). Special holiday rewards (like TVal's T6 plate) should be harder, but not added to the feat list... the plate is its own reward, IMO, and is not needed in the feats as well. This would make the holiday feats fun for me, and those that want to chase the big reward may choose to do so.
My 2¢
First of all, I appreciate the effort venan put in to make this and other events happen. I certainly prefer it to a situation where nothing ever happens in the game. Unfortunately, the lucky event has probably done more harm than good. There seem to be quite a few people who burnt themselves out grinding lucky, only to be disappointed with the payoff, and now can't muster the energy to play again. Our guild have struggled with finishing raids all week and pre-lucky we had a decent chance of gold every time. At least val gave gear etc, thanks venan, but maybe something different next year
