Book of Heroes

Venan and Lucky: Good Jobs guys

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun Mar 17, 2013 12:02 pm
HI Venan,
Just thought I would post and say thank you...I think the Lucky event and achievements were a good implementation and a fun event.
Did he disrupt raids? Yes...was the randomness a bit of a pain..yes (but then that was also fun).

I've been able to enjoy the event without burning too many epots/gs...achieve the achievements without feeling overwhelmed...it was a good balance here...I liked it much better than Tragic Valentine who, though it was a great event concept and character design (Still laugh at "Extra Whispy")....the E needed to get that final achievement of 100 TVals...that was just gross and frustrating...more so because I rarely had enough E when he appeared, especially if I was trying to support guild raids in any way shape or form...as such I was reduced to using GS/Epots most of the time I needed to hunt TVal.
....timing was critical...at least with Lucky I had more options to hunt him when I wasn't raiding, and not always forced to burn epots/gs.

My kids even took turns with my toons hunting in the Ebian to see who would get lucky first! LOL

It was a well designed/implemented event. Thanks Guys
In theory it's not a bad thought. Personally I've disliked the event a lot. I'm really over the randomness. Just irritating. But I like that venan are mixing it up, just for me this one missed the mark a little.
Mith may be my friend but I am the polar opposite of my opinion on this event. It is too random. I know of two people who got 2 500gs prizes without even trying. Meanwhile my SW has been running the event full time for three days and doesn't even have the sham rock to finish the feat.

I will state my point yet again that I have made before: rarely occurring random based events (finding lucky and the lockbox payout) is a bad game play design. This is the WTF, Essence 1 & 2 quests but with a deadline where you end up in a situation where you can't finish because you had bad luck.

Note: I did get a 10 e pot prize so it hasn't been like I have been totally screwed on the prize end and am bitter over that. I do like the fact the event did not require rushing during short periods of time though.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun Mar 17, 2013 8:42 pm
In response to Bbbb, I can understand his polar opposite position...I only opened 6 lockboxes, and from them I got 2 sham rocks, 1 epot, 1 luck elixir and 2x 10k silver (...whoopee...).

Being as I was able to just fore-go portal diving and achieve the achievements without burning too much gs...that would explain why I found the event enjoyable...that and I had no intention of working toward the 500 GS bonus.

It would appear then that the difference of opinions lies entirely in the randomness of the rewards...I imagine if I was at Lockbox #9 or #10 and still trying to win a sham rock to check off the achievement...I wouldn't be nearly as content with the Lucky event.

-Mith
[quote="Mithrid"
Being as I was able to just fore-go portal diving and achieve the achievements without burning too much gs..[/quote]

I refuse to burn for this event, but I know someone who went thru 350gs to get the sham rock. But they did all of that on Thursday night.

Mith, I have been down a toon due to the event and why you haven't seen me much. Probably see you on a raid Tuesday. :)
Mithrid wrote:

It would appear then that the difference of opinions lies entirely in the randomness of the rewards...I imagine if I was at Lockbox #9 or That's#10 and still trying to win a sham rock to check off the achievement...I wouldn't be nearly as content with the Lucky event.

-Mith

And here is the position I find myself in. I am not going for any particular loot either. I just go for feats of achievement. With Valentine I had 5 toons that all got the 100 kills achievement. it was a bit of a grind. I set my alarm clock and got up at weird hours to make it happen. BUT because I put in the work, I was guaranteed the success on every character.

Fast forward to this event. While I will agree that the free hunting structure is better, none of those same 5 toons has had the fortune to loot a Sham Rock. That is seriously infuriating. I'm not on box 9 or 10. I'm on box 47ish with no useless piece of loot that does nothing but finish an achievement.

This game is fun, but many people like me play with a goal of finishing achievements. To have one stare you in the face as incomplete when you did everything possible to get it and just didn't have luck on your side feels like an abuse of good will from Venan. Achievements are a very big deal to some, including me. I could be wrong, but I don't think there is a single other achievement that is purely luck based.

Luck based achievements are the wrong direction. I think it would be a killer move on Venan's part if for those who did not loot a Sham Rock, but did loot 5 of Lucky's lock boxes, that they would send a Sham Rock in the mail after the event closes. This way, the clovers are useless and there is no unfair advantage, but the achievement is still made for those that putinthe work.

Think about it please.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Mar 18, 2013 8:25 am
I would say this event has been terrible and the guild chatter I have heard backs this up. Lucky just doesn't appear regularly enough for it to be worth it. Personally I've spent too much energy and too much silver on energy potions for the return of one Elixir of Luck. The areas he spawns in seem to be pitched at too high a difficulty for it to be worth farming the location continually as you end up using too many potions and the rewards from his box just don't sound worth it in the long run unless you get extremely lucky and get GS.

A big misstep in my opinion as I've heard 95% negative feedback on this event. More thought required for future ones please.
Ilyana wrote: The areas he spawns in seem to be pitched at too high a difficulty for it to be worth farming the location continually as you end up using too many potions

It varies depending on your level. A baby toon was doing Urgesh Peak and was fine, but then it leveled and I had to go to Isle of Nithus, which is really beyond this toon's ability. That was rather annoying. At least, it was a baby that I don't really care much about, but if I was a newish player, I would have been very irritated about it.
Frustration for me. I had a toon level beyond one location, then had to spend time tracking down all the quests to unlock a completely different level. (Fellmarsh)

I think the event would have been better if Lucky appeared randomly throughout the game. That way players could continue questing, and still have the chance to get "lucky." Even if the odds of finding him was slightly reduced, it wouldn't seem like such a grind to hit the same spot over and over with nothing to show for it.

Just me, though.

CodeMonkey

Site AdminMon Mar 18, 2013 2:21 pm
Blurker wrote:Frustration for me. I had a toon level beyond one location, then had to spend time tracking down all the quests to unlock a completely different level. (Fellmarsh)

I think the event would have been better if Lucky appeared randomly throughout the game. That way players could continue questing, and still have the chance to get "lucky." Even if the odds of finding him was slightly reduced, it wouldn't seem like such a grind to hit the same spot over and over with nothing to show for it.

Just me, though.

Right now we don't have the ability to make monsters spawn at all locations. This is something we're considering adding for future events, but we can't do it without a client update.