Book of Heroes

Armor penetration enchant · page 2

OK, did a spreadsheet and the breakpoint comes at 55/56%.

If your opponent has more than 55.5% armor then AP does more damage.

00 50.00 51.00 52.00 53.00 54.00 55.00 56.00 57.00 58.00 59.00 60.00
01 50.50 49.49 48.48 47.47 46.46 45.45 44.44 43.43 42.42 41.41 40.40 01
02 51.00 49.98 48.96 47.94 46.92 45.90 44.88 43.86 42.84 41.82 40.80 02
03 51.50 50.47 49.44 48.41 47.38 46.35 45.32 44.29 43.26 42.23 41.20 03
04 52.00 50.96 49.92 48.88 47.84 46.80 45.76 44.72 43.68 42.64 41.60 04
05 52.50 51.45 50.40 49.35 48.30 47.25 46.20 45.15 44.10 43.05 42.00 05
06 53.00 51.94 50.88 49.82 48.76 47.70 46.64 45.58 44.52 43.46 42.40 06
07 53.50 52.43 51.36 50.29 49.22 48.15 47.08 46.01 44.94 43.87 42.80 07
08 54.00 52.92 51.84 50.76 49.68 48.60 47.52 46.44 45.36 44.28 43.20 08
09 54.50 53.41 52.32 51.23 50.14 49.05 47.96 46.87 45.78 44.69 43.60 09
10 55.00 53.90 52.80 51.70 50.60 49.50 48.40 47.30 46.20 45.10 44.00 10
11 55.50 54.39 53.28 52.17 51.06 49.95 48.84 47.73 46.62 45.51 44.40 11
12 56.00 54.88 53.76 52.64 51.52 50.40 49.28 48.16 47.04 45.92 44.80 12
13 56.50 55.37 54.24 53.11 51.98 50.85 49.72 48.59 47.46 46.33 45.20 13
14 57.00 55.86 54.72 53.58 52.44 51.30 50.16 49.02 47.88 46.74 45.60 14
15 57.50 56.35 55.20 54.05 52.90 51.75 50.60 49.45 48.30 47.15 46.00 15
16 58.00 56.84 55.68 54.52 53.36 52.20 51.04 49.88 48.72 47.56 46.40 16
17 58.50 57.33 56.16 54.99 53.82 52.65 51.48 50.31 49.14 47.97 46.80 17
18 59.00 57.82 56.64 55.46 54.28 53.10 51.92 50.74 49.56 48.38 47.20 18
WE 50.00 51.00 52.00 53.00 54.00 55.00 56.00 57.00 58.00 59.00 60.00


AP 50.00 51.00 52.00 53.00 54.00 55.00 56.00 57.00 58.00 59.00 60.00
01 50.40 49.41 48.42 47.42 46.43 45.44 44.45 43.46 42.46 41.47 40.48
02 50.80 49.82 48.83 47.85 46.86 45.88 44.90 43.91 42.93 41.94 40.96
03 51.20 50.22 49.25 48.27 47.30 46.32 45.34 44.37 43.39 42.42 41.44
04 51.60 50.63 49.66 48.70 47.73 46.76 45.79 44.82 43.86 42.89 41.92
05 52.00 51.04 50.08 49.12 48.16 47.20 46.24 45.28 44.32 43.36 42.40
06 52.40 51.45 50.50 49.54 48.59 47.64 46.69 45.74 44.78 43.83 42.88
07 52.80 51.86 50.91 49.97 49.02 48.08 47.14 46.19 45.25 44.30 43.36
08 53.20 52.26 51.33 50.39 49.46 48.52 47.58 46.65 45.71 44.78 43.84
09 53.60 52.67 51.74 50.82 49.89 48.96 48.03 47.10 46.18 45.25 44.32
10 54.00 53.08 52.16 51.24 50.32 49.40 48.48 47.56 46.64 45.72 44.80
11 54.40 53.49 52.58 51.66 50.75 49.84 48.93 48.02 47.10 46.19 45.28
12 54.80 53.90 52.99 52.09 51.18 50.28 49.38 48.47 47.57 46.66 45.76
13 55.20 54.30 53.41 52.51 51.62 50.72 49.82 48.93 48.03 47.14 46.24
14 55.60 54.71 53.82 52.94 52.05 51.16 50.27 49.38 48.50 47.61 46.72
15 56.00 55.12 54.24 53.36 52.48 51.60 50.72 49.84 48.96 48.08 47.20
16 56.40 55.53 54.66 53.78 52.91 52.04 51.17 50.30 49.42 48.55 47.68
17 56.80 55.94 55.07 54.21 53.34 52.48 51.62 50.75 49.89 49.02 48.16
18 57.20 56.34 55.49 54.63 53.78 52.92 52.06 51.21 50.35 49.50 48.64
Well, what your spreadsheet tells me is that while AP may be less useful than WE until that 55/56% break even point, AP still is very useful for the most part. We're talking ~10-15% or so difference at low armored enemies (<20% armor), and effectively equal at higher armored enemies (~55%). I suppose what I'd really be interested in now is average armor ratings for level 30 creatures. I'd hope there aren't too many below that 10% armor barrier.

But no, I see your point. As things stand, AP definitely is worse (Sigh... so much for the 14 levels I have invested in it.) Guess I'm going to be LoBing for the inevitable future.
14 levels of AP is still going to get you a nice hit bonus as you know, but most long term players have gone for weapon enchant. The Lvl 6 AP enchant that Valentine dropped (after 100 kills) has in many cases been broken down for parts and reused for Weapon Enchanting.

Armor rating for lvl 30 creatures. Well we're guessing, unless someone runs a major test using the alternative enchants to see which gives better damage. My own suspicion is that Bandit Captains (in the Heart of Ebian) and Vile Soldiers (Portals and Vile Gate raid), both of whom carry a shield, may be approaching that 55% break, but WE still gets the job done quickly. The Goblin King is shown carrying a shield, but I tested lvl 2 AP vs lvl 2 WE and found (over a couple of raids) that Weapon Enchant was still giving better damage, though there was quite an overlap in the data range, so it was still close.

If you already have 14 levels enchanted I'd keep your current equipment enchants and buy a new set for the weapon enchant, switching gear as you power up the new set and keeping a record of your blows to see what happens. I was using Brutal Strike as my measure because (at the time using 1-h sword) I got in 2-3 hits per boss fight, making it easy to get more data quickly.
Musketeer wrote:

My own suspicion is that Bandit Captains (in the Heart of Ebian) and Vile Soldiers (Portals and Vile Gate raid), both of whom carry a shield, may be approaching that 55% break,.

You may be right about the bandit captains, but I have not noticed vile soldiers taking that much less than my tooltip damage. I wish I had thought of this before spending all that time in the Ebian for Lucky.

One other point to mention is Direhorn's Defensive Stance and Lord of Blades' Vile Ward. Does the pure damage from an armor penetration enchant still hit defensive buffs like that? Sure it doesn't much matter at high might when you can oneshot them before they cast it, but for lower level players it's a consideration.
GC_Myainsel wrote:
Musketeer wrote:

My own suspicion is that Bandit Captains (in the Heart of Ebian) and Vile Soldiers (Portals and Vile Gate raid), both of whom carry a shield, may be approaching that 55% break,.

You may be right about the bandit captains, but I have not noticed vile soldiers taking that much less than my tooltip damage. I wish I had thought of this before spending all that time in the Ebian for Lucky.

One other point to mention is Direhorn's Defensive Stance and Lord of Blades' Vile Ward. Does the pure damage from an armor penetration enchant still hit defensive buffs like that? Sure it doesn't much matter at high might when you can oneshot them before they cast it, but for lower level players it's a consideration.

You're right, I included Vile Soldiers for completeness, but they don't seem to have particularly noticeable defences.


From the wording of the buff '20% off all damage', I read this as meaning after armor has been taken into account, so WP vs AP makes no difference.

With Direhorn it's pretty easy to knock off the buff, either with a rune or with Radiant Light if you're a Justicar.

Vile Ward is much harder to remove once it's up, so I try not to let LoB cats it in the first place.