Book of Heroes

Armor penetration enchant

Does this enchant really helps out a warmage? I mean does armor affect spelldamage at all?
Yes, it does affect warmage damage. BoH armor resists both magical and physical damage.

That said, popular opinion considers 1-h Damage or 2-h Damage to be the best Skill enchantment choice.

japster

ModeratorTue Apr 2, 2013 11:10 am
It's not popular opinion that makes weapon damage enchant more favorable than armor penetration enchant right now. It's maths.
EDIT: Turns out I'm wrong about the mechanics.
TCG_japster wrote:It's not popular opinion that makes weapon damage enchant more favorable than armor penetration enchant right now. It's maths.
Challenge accepted.

Take your listed tooltip damage to be "Base Damage"

Against a foe with n% armor reduction, you deal Base Damage * (100-n) damage.

With one level of weapon damage enchant, you deal Base Damage * 1.01 * (100-n) damage.
With one level of armor pen instead, you deal Base Damage * (100 - (n-.8)) damage.
So for what value of n does the first equal the second? Simple algebra gives us a break even at n=20.
So if your enemy has more than 20% armor, one level of armor pen is better than one level of weapon damage.

Now let's assume you've already got one piece enchanted for 3% weapon damage, because that next rank is kind of a doozy. You're ready to enchant a second piece of gear. Should you still go for weapon damage? The formulae now look like
Four levels of weapon damage: Base Damage * 1.04 * (100-n)
Three weapon, one armor pen: Base Damage * 1.03 * (100-n+.8)
The first is greater than the second for n<5. This means we need a foe with only 5% armor to make Armor pen a better choice than damage.

Now let's look at some endgame cases. With level 6 enchants, because each item can carry only one enchantment, you have four choices. 18 levels of weapon damage (18/0), 12 levels of weapon damage and 6 of armor pen (12/6), 6 levels of weapon damage and 12 armor pen(6/12) , or a full 18 levels of armor pen (0/18).

To compare them, I'm going to use 18 weapon damage as a base, and find how much armor a foe needs to make the other three options deal the same amount of damage.

(18/0) vs (12/6) means a foe needs 6.66666... armor reduction
(18/0) vs (6/12) means a foe needs 13.3333.. armor reduction
(18/0) vs (0/18) means a foe needs 20 armor reduction

I'm not sure how much armor most mobs have, but since my skills usually seem to deal tooltip damage, its clearly not much. However, armor pen does seem like a clear winner for pvp, if and when it gets here.
That's not how Armor Penetration works unfortunately, but nice maths.

With 1 level of weapon enchant you are doing 101% base damage before armor.
With 1 level of AP you are doing 0.8% damage directly (not affected by armor), and 99.2% is still affected by armor.

So with 20% armor, base damage for Enchant is 101% x .8 = 80.8%
For AP it is (99.2% x 0.8) (the portion affected by armor) +.08% (the unblocked portion) = 79.44%


At lvl 3 weapon enchant per item (9 total) it's 109% x .8 = 87.2%
With 9 levels of AP it's (92.8% x 0.8) + 7.2% = 81.44%

So it doesn't matter what level of enchantment you have, if one is better at level 1, it's even better at level 3 or 9 or 18. Thus you should not mix your enchantments.

Let's assume the foe has 50% armor.

Weapon Enchant lvl 1 = 101% x .5 = 50.5% damage
AP level 1 = (99.2% *.5) + 0.8% = 50.4% damage
Weapon Enchant lvl 9 = 100% x .5 = 54.5% damage
AP level 1 = (92.8.% *.5) + 7.2% = 53.45% damage



51% armor :
WE - 101% *0.49 = 49.49% damage
AP (99.2*0.49) + 0.8 = 49.408% damage

52% armor:
WE - 101%*0.48= 48.48%
AP - (99.2*0.48) + 0.8 = 48.416%

52% armor @ lvl 9 enchant:
WE 109 * 0.48 = 52.32%
AP (92.8*0.48) + 7.2 = 51.744%

60% armor :
WE 101*0.4 = 40.4%
AP (99.2*0.4) + 0.8 = 40.48%

60% @ level 9 enchant:
WE 109 * 0.4 = 43.6%
AP (92.8*0.4) + 7.2 = 44.32%

So somewhere between 52% and 60% armor the AP pays off. I could do the math to work out the exact figure but right now my son needs attention. There is no foe currently in the game with >52% armor.
Wow. That's not how armor penetration has worked in more or less any game ever. No wonder it's so worthless.
GC_Myainsel wrote:Wow. That's not how armor penetration has worked in more or less any game ever. No wonder it's so worthless.

Venan do like to be trend setters.
If they'd made Armor Penetration 1% instead of 0.8% per level it'd be the better enchant all the time, but then you get it free as a Quest reward: weapon enchant you have to raid the LoB dungeon for, or if desperate buy at the Black Market, so it makes sense that AP is the lesser enchant.

Of course as the game grows we may get higher and higher defence bosses (and PvP) so that AP comes into its own again, but for now it just doesn't quite cut it. It's still a lot better than no enchant at all.