Book of Heroes

PvP *NOT* what customers want or need · page 2

Bimbo_sama wrote:
I happen to know a lot of people who want PvP. And for those who don't want to, it's simple. Just don't do it!


Same thoughts here. While I personally have next to no interest in PvP I know a lot of players who do want it, and it'll just be a sideshow for those who like that sort of thing.

I see it as an Arena or Colosseum in or near Glenfort where toons enter themselves as available for challenge, or challenge someone already there. Both players would need to be online to initiate and run the fight, and actions need to be chosen quickly, say 5 to 10 seconds maximum or an action is chosen automatically (defend or basic attack). You can't challenge your own toons. It requires some energy to have a PvP fight, maybe 10, and you put in a stake of your own choosing, betting on yourself to win. If you win you get a reward (probably just in silver) at odds calculated via might ratings.

We already know that no potions or elixirs can be used, but enchants definitely do work.

The one advantage of PvP is that it's a perpetual entertainment. Once it's running right, it''ll keep the top players entertained while they wait for more storyline quests or new raids to be introduced.

The Daily bounty was originally introduced to give some sort of daily involvement for players who had done all the quests (it started before Guilds were introduced), but alas has not been kept up to date and is now an irrelevence to most top players.

Darkhorse

Site AdminTue Apr 9, 2013 2:19 pm
Appreciate the feedback. At the end of the day I think there are some people who don't want PvP or at least some people who would not want to participate in PvP. However, there are many people that DO want PvP and would definitely enjoy that feature. I know this is true because I interact with these people in game on a daily basis.

Now take this with a grain of salt, because it's something that is not final and we are currently working on. That being said, the previous posts are correct, the way that we are designing this feature is that it will not be forced upon players in any way. There won't be any "ganking" or anything like that. Participation will be voluntary in a more "arena" based style that other popular MMOs use. For those that wish to keep only doing PVE content, they will be able to continue to do so happily. For those that wish to participate in PvP, they will be able to as well.

As soon as I'm allowed to share more information about these features, I will do so :).
I'm all for a PvP option. Agree that it should not play a significant role in character development. Bragging rights, medals, a new stat, but nothing more. Any way to have a vote so that we are not relying on anecdotal mass preferences as being posted?

Darkhorse

Site AdminTue Apr 9, 2013 2:41 pm
XRCIST wrote:I'm all for a PvP option. Agree that it should not play a significant role in character development. Bragging rights, medals, a new stat, but nothing more. Any way to have a vote so that we are not relying on anecdotal mass preferences as being posted?

In the future we'll be running more polls or "poll like" posts on our Facebook page, so make sure you like BoH on Facebook!

http://www.facebook.com/bookofheroes

FreyaYuledottir

ModeratorTue Apr 9, 2013 3:56 pm
I don't understand the concern of the post, pvp is coming because it's been one of the most requested features. You definitely don't speak for whole community as alot of people wait it very eagerly, me included. And as it's completely optional, I see no problem to implement it whether it gets popularity or not.

Therefore the whole headline of thos thread is total false statement:

On contrary, PVP *IS* what customers want.
Darkhorse wrote:
XRCIST wrote:I'm all for a PvP option. Agree that it should not play a significant role in character development. Bragging rights, medals, a new stat, but nothing more. Any way to have a vote so that we are not relying on anecdotal mass preferences as being posted?

In the future we'll be running more polls or "poll like" posts on our Facebook page, so make sure you like BoH on Facebook!

http://www.facebook.com/bookofheroes
Well this is more than I or anyone I have spoken to has said about it in a long time. It is good to hear from Venan that it will not be integral. Most of the people I speak to that aren't looking forward to it are worried it will take away from the community spirit, and that was the emphasis of the original post.

As to my suggestions, contrary to the folks who may not have understood what I meant, I was merely suggesting some of many things the game could use that would please people from the small and relatively easy albeit cosmetic, to bigger more productive changes that I have heard bandied about.

And, as for speaking for *all* users, I never made such a claim, I merely voiced the opinions I have heard in my daily wanderings, which I thought I had stated clearly enough to be understood by everyone reading. I apologize to those who may have missed my reference to this in their haste to post their own opinions.

Thank you for the clarification Venan, I am certain it puts many people's mind at ease about the update.

-M
FreyaOlafsdottir wrote:I don't understand the concern of the post, pvp is coming because it's been one of the most requested features. You definitely don't speak for whole community as alot of people wait it very eagerly, me included. And as it's completely optional, I see no problem to implement it whether it gets popularity or not.

Therefore the whole headline of thos thread is total false statement:

On contrary, PVP *IS* what customers want.

There is a huge group of players that think that PvP is just going to lead to trash talking morons taking over and ruining the game we have and enjoy. Plus many of us have zero interest and have stated so for months - we wish the limited development cycles were spent on PvE.
Bbbb wrote:
FreyaOlafsdottir wrote:I don't understand the concern of the post, pvp is coming because it's been one of the most requested features. You definitely don't speak for whole community as alot of people wait it very eagerly, me included. And as it's completely optional, I see no problem to implement it whether it gets popularity or not.

Therefore the whole headline of thos thread is total false statement:

On contrary, PVP *IS* what customers want.

There is a huge group of players that think that PvP is just going to lead to trash talking morons taking over and ruining the game we have and enjoy. Plus many of us have zero interest and have stated so for months - we wish the limited development cycles were spent on PvE.

I definitely agree with bbbb and magdalene. While if pvp is implemented, I'll definitely try it out... if it has no benefit other than to be a mini-game, I don't know how long it'll keep my attention. And honestly, I don't see the real need to conform to what other mmos do. Venan has done an amazing job thus far holding my attention far longer than any other mmo i've played on the iphone because what they do is different.

Although, I understand it is often suggested, so I understand the appeal, but I just hope there's more to the update than pvp.
I just hope PvP doesn't lean heavily on rewards that matter to character progression and growth. If its aesthetic stuff and boasts I'm all for it. Should be a fun mini-game from time to time, but in all honesty I would rather see the development time spent somewhere else.

FWIW

japster

ModeratorTue Apr 9, 2013 11:29 pm
I want to do PvP and am excited about it.

However I see the fears of having a PvP environment ruining BoH as we know it, even if PvP is optional. Depending on how the mechanics work, there is likely going to be a real impact on player's choices. We are limited in the game by time and energy. PvP might detract players from raiding and cause PvE players to suffer more in raids.

In addition, PvP ranking and competitiveness in PvP may also translate to rivalries that cause people not to help guilds with raids etc to avoid helping a "rival in that guild beef up".

These are just very loose scenarios but things along these lines can easily occur even if the PvP feature is optional. It's going to be really hard for Venan to balance these things out.

One possible option is to ensure that resources spent in PvE and PvP are kept separate, i.e. PvP does not use energy but another regenerating resource, such as a PvP energy bar. That would lessen the impact it has on player's choices between PvP and PvE, but certainly won't solve the issue of unhealthy competition (if it arises).