Book of Heroes

PvP *NOT* what customers want or need · page 3

Darkhorse

Site AdminTue Apr 9, 2013 11:36 pm
TCG_japster wrote:I want to do PvP and am excited about it.

However I see the fears of having a PvP environment ruining BoH as we know it, even if PvP is optional. Depending on how the mechanics work, there is likely going to be a real impact on player's choices. We are limited in the game by time and energy. PvP might detract players from raiding and cause PvE players to suffer more in raids.

In addition, PvP ranking and competitiveness in PvP may also translate to rivalries that cause people not to help guilds with raids etc to avoid helping a "rival in that guild beef up".

These are just very loose scenarios but things along these lines can easily occur even if the PvP feature is optional. It's going to be really hard for Venan to balance these things out.

One possible option is to ensure that resources spent in PvE and PvP are kept separate, i.e. PvP does not use energy but another regenerating resource, such as a PvP energy bar. That would lessen the impact it has on player's choices between PvP and PvE, but certainly won't solve the issue of unhealthy competition (if it arises).

This is one of our concerns as well :). All I can say right now is we are definitely thinking about these sorts of things.
I would have quit quite a while ago if I didn't know PvP was coming. .. its the light at the end if the tunnel of all that stupid portal grinding
Rivalries that deter merc'ing are irrelevant because merc'ing was never intended. The fact that you are free to roam from guild to guild reaping rewards is already stupid. There is no incentive for loyalty when you can just rejoin at any time and instantly regain your guild's favor bonuses, continuing to raid like you'd never left. If rivalries discourage this, it's for the better.

japster

ModeratorWed Apr 10, 2013 2:07 am
Bimbo_sama wrote:I highly doubt 1.6 will just be about PvP. There's been much talk about the nerfing of mercs as well as other features. I know many of the high mights want more cv raids, preferably with an onslaught phase. A dev said info would be coming out in "a few days" so lets all just be patient and see what's on the horizon. I also don't really care much about PvP but I want to try it out at least. Might provide a nice break between the mind-numbingly boredom of collecting tens of thousands of essence and hundreds of flux. And darkhorse...you and me bro!! Bring it on!!

I am not sure about another onslaught raid. Onslaught is almost impossible to balance between classes and making it a high-tier raid will cause a lot of people to grouse and yell and complain once more (remember The Shadow Comes when it first came out?). Some class is always going to have a crazy huge advantage over the other, "stealing" all the RPP away.

Anyway I recall talking to Mike previously and he had said new onslaught raids will probably not be added any time soon due to the complex balancing issues.
As much as pvp sounds an interesting diversion. There are only 3 classes, 30 levels and the game is extended in end with ridiculous amount of grinding. Surely the focus should be on addressing these issues before adding a diversionary component. How many people have tossed app at the who gives a flux quest or once they start grinding enchants or even at fellmarsh where it's more repetitive than shopping for pregnancy cravings? As a paying customer I would rather see devs time focused elsewhere than pvp.
MegMasters wrote:Rivalries that deter merc'ing are irrelevant because merc'ing was never intended. The fact that you are free to roam from guild to guild reaping rewards is already stupid. There is no incentive for loyalty when you can just rejoin at any time and instantly regain your guild's favor bonuses, continuing to raid like you'd never left. If rivalries discourage this, it's for the better.

Except the guild system fundamentally flawed in that raids are based on player might not guild might so as players inevitably sprawl in might value due to different amounts of free time and cash investment it becomes impossible to cater to all guild members without mercs and guilds helping each other. You talk about loyalty but without mercs players will be forced to constantly move to avoid might spread so guilds able to run raid totally in house.
PVE/PVP in a nutshell-

Awesome! I have finally ground out all of my T15(?) pieces, enchants and gems to maximize raid kills!!

Now I get to do a whole second set of gear, gems and enchants for PVP!!! Oh wait, D'oh!!

I'm still gonna do it mind you. I just remember having to arena cap every week to grind out that second gear set in wow!!
Honestly, this game is great. I don't feel that PvP will ruin anything. The veterans will still have their over strength guilds that are impossible to touch and the people that pay into this game will be stronger. That alone is what will topple the game if anything.

In PvP those that pay for higher tier gear will have the upper hand just like they do in PvE. So eventually people will either become bored or enough people will play that you don't get destroyed every other time.

In either situation game development can not keep up with players....it's just not possible. Those who talk about lvl caps overlook the fact that the daily bounties and raids allow you to earn currency to boost stats. Patience with a game you enjoy is the only option. Updates will come soon enough. As for the aesthetics of hair and faces...I would care more about an increase in gear or enchantment options.
Sinphil wrote:

Except the guild system fundamentally flawed in that raids are based on player might not guild might so as players inevitably sprawl in might value due to different amounts of free time and cash investment it becomes impossible to cater to all guild members without mercs and guilds helping each other. You talk about loyalty but without mercs players will be forced to constantly move to avoid might spread so guilds able to run raid totally in house.

First of all, not only did you misuse words, but you omitted key ones that would have made your post less headache-inducing. Secondly, I'm not the reason the guild system is faulty, so what is your point? Venan has admitted it's not working like they want it to and will be addressing the issue, which means merc'ing is a player-crafted bandaid. So, uh, great point there.