Book of Heroes

Balancing SWers/WMs · page 2

japster

ModeratorMon Apr 29, 2013 4:07 am
Mcluvin wrote:

Also, it's not true that SWs are the only class that can cycle their two main single target attacks. A Justicar with a 2H axe can alternate Brutal Strike and Wound.

The damage ratios are not equivalent, unlike Toxic Blade and Piercing Strike. But I take your point anyway.
TCG_japster wrote:
Mcluvin wrote:

Also, it's not true that SWs are the only class that can cycle their two main single target attacks. A Justicar with a 2H axe can alternate Brutal Strike and Wound.

The damage ratios are not equivalent, unlike Toxic Blade and Piercing Strike. But I take your point anyway.

Oh, I see what you mean. Yeah it's not really the same thing.

I also forgot to mention the Focus talents versus Dual Wield 3. While Focus talents add some damage to everything a WM or Justicar does (except Justicar Magic damage), Dual Wield 3 only adds damage to a regular melee attack for SW. Now to be fair, DW3 increases the melee attack damage by a much higher percentage than the Focus abilities do, but it only affects that one action. Piercing Strike, Poison Blade, etc are unaffected.
Musketeer wrote: My SW IS getting 2-hit kills frequently against mobs, so there's not a lot of difference in real time speed.

My Mage is frequently getting 1-hit kills against mobs (GK phase 1/2 and VG phase 1) using Flaming Pyre (note: I do not have the Fire enchant). I should point out that my mage is lower might than my SW too. The magic gems are maxed on both. Mage has maybe 100 extra points in magic tokens, but my SW has 3% on nature damage enchant (still ramping it up).

It takes me twice as long to dump my SW (even with 2-hit kills) at the beginning of raids. If the stupid poisoned messages were removed, it might reduce 50% of the difference.
Seriously, the POISONED/RESISTED animations are the worst SW's downside so far. As if server/network lags weren't enough... Just dumping e can be a pain, but what worries me most of all are speed runs...
Not sure if it was suggested already, but they could make 'Poisoned' make the target take 15% more damage from all sources, not just nature, or it could have a Dot attached to it (even if you have to spend talent points for it like 20/40/60% weapon damage over the duration of the debuff. They could have Caltrops do a small amount of damage when first cast, like Poison Cloud but not as strong. or Dual wield could increase not only the offhand damage but give any single target attack an offhand follow up or something (the offhand damage for moves other than normal attack could be like 75% off hand weapon damage). Assassinate should be changed to attack whichever remaining target has the least health, making it more likely to "Assassinate" something, instead of deal damage to something it wont really help with. There are lots of alterations or additions to the mechanics of the SW that could be made to help put them on par with the killing speed of the other two classes. I'm sure Venan and some of you longer time players could figure out the right balance.

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorThu May 2, 2013 10:19 am
If they would have just left the DOT on poison attacks, SWs would of been fine IMHO....but they didn't
Another option I was just thinking about. Remove Smoke Bomb and replace it with a move that would consume the poisoned stacks in exchange for a direct damage move. Or it could consume the dot from poison cloud and use its remaining damage to be dealt as bonus damage to the attack. Something like
Venom Strike
Instant cast, 6 sec cooldown
Deals 25/50/75% weapon damage plus the remaining damage on poison cloud debuff
Pushes enemy action time back .5 sec
Still works to give you more time on your next attack like smoke bomb, and gives sw an extra way to dish out damage faster, as the sw was intended.
Spartanmerc wrote:Another option I was just thinking about. Remove Smoke Bomb and replace it with a move that would consume the poisoned stacks in exchange for a direct damage move. Or it could consume the dot from poison cloud and use its remaining damage to be dealt as bonus damage to the attack. Something like
Venom Strike
Instant cast, 6 sec cooldown
Deals 25/50/75% weapon damage plus the remaining damage on poison cloud debuff
Pushes enemy action time back .5 sec
Still works to give you more time on your next attack like smoke bomb, and gives sw an extra way to dish out damage faster, as the sw was intended.

Well Smoke Bomb is an aoe knockback and refreshes our own abilities by 1s, basically making it one of the best moves in the game for controlling an encounter. Giving that up would not help SW very much.

Urgency, on the other hand, is weak and scales negatively with Dodge. Rather than a haste proc on being hit (which we should try to avoid in the first place), we can add something else that speeds up kill times for both Physical and Nature based SW.

Your suggestion sounds fun but doesn't help physical SW as they don't have a poison DoT.

I would suggest something stealthy. All our abilities are about poison or crits. Where is the stealth. Aren't we SHADOW WALKERS?

Dispatch
6s cooldown
1s cooldown
0.5s cast time
Sneaks up on the target to deal 150/175/200% weapon damage plus all remaining damage over time effects on the target. Any direct damage will interrupt this ability.

Pretty powerful but can only be used once every 6 seconds and easily interruptable and requires set up so that it's not just a faster, weaker Piercing Strike. It's not not very strong if you let your DoTs tick too long before using it. Basically it's a way to get out damage quick but with a tradeoff.
One more option I was thinking about would be a setup ability. Like you use it to gain a buff to guarantee the next ability you use will crit:

Setup / Cold Blood / Ambush
Can not be used within the first 1 sec of combat
Grants 100% crit chance on next ability
.75 sec to cast
6 sec cooldown
Each point into it can lower the cast time and/or the cooldown time slightly.

It would be similar to the old Cold Blood ability for the Rogues of World of Warcraft. Nice long cooldown so it doesnt get explited, initial combat delay so no use from the start for insta clear with Poison Cloud. Or they could replace Urgency with an ability that would grant haste for 3 or 5 seconds at a rate of 5/10/15% with a long cooldown.

Urgency
Cannot be used in the first 1 sec of combat
Grants 5/10/15% haste for 3 seconds
.5 sec cast
6 Sec Cooldown

Just a thought.