Book of Heroes

Balancing SWers/WMs

There seems to be a nearly universal consensus that SWers are currently underwhelming and WMs are overwhelming at higher mights.

I figured maybe we can start a discussion on some potential solutions.

I can't say I'm super well-versed on warmages (seeing as mine sucks), so someone else will have to help bring up those points.

Shadow Warrior:
1) Somewhat underwhelming attacks compared to wms/justicars. We have speed, a lot of it, but not much else. But then again, maybe that's just the focus on the class - low attack power, low defense, at the benefit of high speed?
2) The incessant animations really slow down e dumping. Then again, taking away the animations wouldn't necessarily fix the balance issues, would it?

War Mage:
[will update as discussion continues]

What do you guys think?
I spent a long time as a Mage when they were the weakest class and SWs the strongest. It flips a little with every update; I wish people who have only played the game a couple of months could have the same perspective as the longer term players.

The SW can't carry a 2-h weapon, but does get benefit to all damage from the off-hand weapon. Apart from that I don't see a lot of difference, and I've been running toons of every class for over a year. All my toons are lvl 30 and 21k+ might. Some people focus on trying to get one hit kills. The SW can't do that with foes of the same level, but then the Justi and Mage don't get them every round either, only with crits. My SW IS getting 2-hit kills frequently against mobs, so there's not a lot of difference in real time speed.

The Mage has a great advantage that every ice attack slows, stuns or knocks back the enemy's timer. Add Deep Freeze and every ice attack is a potential stun. Also their stun is faster than other classes at higher levels, where as the other class stuns are useless to take more than 1 level in, and stll does damage. The fire attacks are the only attacks that are pure damage, and you can add burning for DoT if you like. I've eliminated DoT on my Mage because it breaks all those lovely stuns at inopportune moments.

I don't see a need to balance or nerf anything. If you build your toon and use it right they all work fine.
I have a char of each class around 20k might. SWs are not underpowered with respect to kills per damage taken. In fact, my WM will usually take the most damage per wave when chugging through the mob waves of CV raids. This is because the mage only has an interrupt, rather than a push-back attack. For bosses, my WM is rarely touched.

In real time, the SW is slow since the individual attacks are weaker (and faster in game time). Real time kill speed will affect raid RPP (for those who can buy energy) and tedium (SW may require twice the button pushes to kill). All the "poisoned" animations slow down the SW in real time as well, but that is a different thread.
Push your mage further up the might chain. You can one hit kill CV mobs. Worst case, attack, interrupt, attack. Mob dead - no damage taken.

japster

ModeratorSat Apr 27, 2013 5:45 am
Bbbb wrote:Push your mage further up the might chain. You can one hit kill CV mobs. Worst case, attack, interrupt, attack. Mob dead - no damage taken.

A SW can achieve the worst case scenario you mentioned with attack, ensnare, attack.

The real problem with SW, if it even exists, is that they are stuck with a one-hander. To achieve 1 hit KO with a one-hander would mean their skills really have to scale excessively. And if so, then the speed factor on their 1hander should be nerfed. WM and Justicars are NOT doing 1hit KO moves with 1handers, but 2handers.

Bottomline is the developers wanted SW to be special with the 1h+offhand combo. I don't think asking for a damage buff to achieve a 1hit KO is the most elegant way to solve the problem. That would just return SW to their crazy imbalanced state pre 1.5 where Vanish would easily grant 100% crit and 300% crit power. Then SW would be one hitting everything again with fast attack speed.

I'm quite inclined to think that if they fixed the animation speeds, SW would be on very equal footing with the other classes in terms of real-time kill speed. But like many have said, this isn't a real balance issue but a UI issue.
TCG_japster wrote:
I'm quite inclined to think that if they fixed the animation speeds, SW would be on very equal footing with the other classes in terms of real-time kill speed. But like many have said, this isn't a real balance issue but a UI issue.

The thing is that 100% of the players I have talked to agrees with the animation issue. One of the Venan people somewhere said they wouldn't solve this issue because they don't want to be viewed as a "Do It" RPG. Just make it optional and maybe require a certain level before the option works.

Still I don't think the SW would be on equal footing, but the margin of difference would be less.

japster

ModeratorSun Apr 28, 2013 4:23 am
Bbbb wrote:
The thing is that 100% of the players I have talked to agrees with the animation issue. One of the Venan people somewhere said they wouldn't solve this issue because they don't want to be viewed as a "Do It" RPG. Just make it optional and maybe require a certain level before the option works.

Still I don't think the SW would be on equal footing, but the margin of difference would be less.

Maybe we should think of ways the SW could be balanced without buffing their damage directly, besides fixing animation. Boosting their damage to achieve 1 hit KO with a 1hander just makes SW ridiculously overpowered when compared to WM and Justicar (unless WM and Justicars can 1hit KO things with a 1hander too, then I think it'll be a fair change).

Perhaps we could emphasize the speed factor of SW as their niche. So instead of having crazy 1 hit KO moves, they move so quickly that they can avoid most damage when killing enemies, such as killing an enemy before his attack animation occurs = real time speed improvement too. The tricky part is how to balance this out without turning the SW into a perma-stun character that Venan sought to eliminate with v 1.3 and 1.4.

One thing I do like about SW right now is that they are the only class that can rotate between their two main damage (by skill %) skills (Toxic Blade and Piercing Strike) without cooldown issues (unless riposte occurs...). None of the other classes can do that effectively.

They could try to work on those 2 skills, and Riposte to improve kill speeds somehow. Perhaps making those 2 skills cast even faster, or include some sort of minor knockback or chance to interrupt (miss garotte?), might help SW avoid damage even more. Maybe for every stack of poison on the enemy, toxic blade/piercing strike will knockback the timer by 0.1? Something along those lines.

Poison Cloud and Acid Spray are pretty fine IMO and shouldn't be touched too much lest all SWs become poison mages once more.

Assassinate should work on DoTs. Period. I don't know why this wasn't coded for.

Caltrops could be made to to last for 5 seconds instead of 3 seconds, so that the slow duration sticks longer. The damage should be scaled up to reflect the increased duration but stay the same dps wise.

Lastly, urgency proc rate should be raised much higher, so if the SW does get hit, he is guaranteed to go on overdrive. To even it out, maybe Urgency could make SW lose their defense or take more damage when they get hit under this mode. So in exchange for their high proc-rate speed steroid, they trade survivability?
I like the Urgency proc rate idea. However, those people who went the dodge/riposte route won't benefit.

Another idea is to up crit/crit power a little bit more though not to insane Vanish levels. Or let Crit Eye work work with poison too.

Or slightly buff the damage percentages on TB, PS and RS slightly. Maybe by 10%.

Another angle is that SW is the only class without an interrupt/stun/knockback that does damage. Maybe tack a little damage onto smoke bomb.

BTW, I have gone completely over to a Poison Mage build. If it wasn't for doing onslaught on occasion, I would drop Piercing Strike. When I was hybrid, I completely agree with the PS/TB rotation. However, in 1.5, I decided I had to go completely melee or magic to up my damage and you can only enchant for one or the other. Once you go all magic, Acid Spray does about the same damage as PS but fires quicker.

As far as Poison versus Hybrid build, the Poison build works much better on mobs. It is about a wash against bosses though.
I completely agree with Musketeer. I think if you play SW to the character strengths, you have a quick and deadly character. Thanks Musketeer for your perspective.
Musketeer wrote:I spent a long time as a Mage when they were the weakest class and SWs the strongest. It flips a little with every update; I wish people who have only played the game a couple of months could have the same perspective as the longer term players.

The SW can't carry a 2-h weapon, but does get benefit to all damage from the off-hand weapon. Apart from that I don't see a lot of difference, and I've been running toons of every class for over a year. All my toons are lvl 30 and 21k+ might. Some people focus on trying to get one hit kills. The SW can't do that with foes of the same level, but then the Justi and Mage don't get them every round either, only with crits. My SW IS getting 2-hit kills frequently against mobs, so there's not a lot of difference in real time speed.

The Mage has a great advantage that every ice attack slows, stuns or knocks back the enemy's timer. Add Deep Freeze and every ice attack is a potential stun. Also their stun is faster than other classes at higher levels, where as the other class stuns are useless to take more than 1 level in, and stll does damage. The fire attacks are the only attacks that are pure damage, and you can add burning for DoT if you like. I've eliminated DoT on my Mage because it breaks all those lovely stuns at inopportune moments.

I don't see a need to balance or nerf anything. If you build your toon and use it right they all work fine.
I think people are underestimating the damage of a SW. Even with a 1-hander, as the only class that uses an offhand weapon, their weapon damage is very close to that of other classes before ability multipliers come into play. The difference isn't that much once you add in Melee damage from stats. You can do the math yourself with T14 weapons. Sure, 2H comes out on top, but Dual Wielding is considerably faster and very close behind. SWs can hit very hard and very fast.

The main difference is the high crit damage of 2H Justicars/2H Fire War Mages and the base percentage of their abilities being a bit higher as well. In return Shadow Walkers just crit a lot more.

Purely physical SWs in particular have no direct AOE. Just a DoT. And those don't even scale with Haste. Poison SWs have more options in terms of taking down groups but they get lots of messages popping up left and right that make energy dumping a huge chore.

Also, it's not true that SWs are the only class that can cycle their two main single target attacks. A Justicar with a 2H axe can alternate Brutal Strike and Wound.