Mithrid wrote:
I don't even mind the long raid times, as it works better for casual gaming..
If I remember right, you weren't playing during the 6 hour raid era. Venan had the same theory (even stated it) and it was discredited and they shortened the raids. The longer the raid the more people who would take it even more casually (i.e. my 3000RPP won't make much of a difference in such a long raid and they don't try). The reality of what would happen is that a handful of people would get stuck on a raid the whole time and it sucked hard.
I got an email last night from a friend about the BoH update. First thing he mentioned was an infamous almost 6 hour overseer raid. The sad thing was that I already had made the same comparison myself. There was no mercs in those days (which is the raider cap) and virtually nobody in my mid-tier guild was a burner. Pure torture.
I am strongly against not all members being allowed to join. I think it's bad game design to lock out guild members. Cap on mercs is fine. I can stretch as far as considering members of guild level 0 as mercs.
What you could do is let those starting a raid decide. If your concern is about large guilds you can have cap 40 people X waves for gold, cap 60 Y waves for gold.
But as was Said earlier, reward levels isn't really the problem. It's not being able to complete the raid at all that's the real gamebreaker pushing the casual player away.
Bbbb wrote:Mithrid wrote:
I don't even mind the long raid times, as it works better for casual gaming..
If I remember right, you weren't playing during the 6 hour raid era. Venan had the same theory (even stated it) and it was discredited and they shortened the raids. The longer the raid the more people who would take it even more casually (i.e. my 3000RPP won't make much of a difference in such a long raid and they don't try). The reality of what would happen is that a handful of people would get stuck on a raid the whole time and it sucked hard.
I got an email last night from a friend about the BoH update. First thing he mentioned was an infamous almost 6 hour overseer raid. The sad thing was that I already had made the same comparison myself. There was no mercs in those days (which is the raider cap) and virtually nobody in my mid-tier guild was a burner. Pure torture.
Bbbb,
You have a point...I watched when raids first came out but was not actively involved in them at the time, so I never worked through a long 4-6hr raid. From what you described right here I could see that being an issue.
-Mith
I want to explain why I have taken my sabbatical from the game.
It is not because "raids are now too hard". Raids are now harder than they used to be (in some cases much harder), but I can live with that. I heard in a chat that during 1.5, 97% of raids were gold. This was a testament to the community optimizing how to get gold, since gold raids award the highest payout per effort. I have no problem with Venan altering the game to make gold success harder to achieve.
it is not because "Venan is trying to get more money". I don't believe this to be the case. I get every impression that Venan cares about the quality of this game, and has shown on several instances a willingness to listen to players on suggested features and to solve individual problems. Venan simply wanted to make the game more challenging, something many of its customers had been asking for a while.
The reason I have left the game (not the forums, obviously) is that the way I play this game is now harmful to my guild, whereas before the way I played the game was helpful to my guild.
Like many players, I have a job, a wife (though no kids), and other outside responsibilities. I have built up five characters with between 18k and 21k might on my main account. My two styles of play are:
(1) during the day, I may find myself with a few scattered minutes of free time. And I might check in with my guild to see if a raid was in progress, and if so, dump 1k to 3k RPP in a raid. This would usually be all I could give.
(2) during the evening (5 or so times a week), our primary 9:30PM EDT VG raid, I could devote 1.5 hours non-stop to empty each of my five characters into the raid. Totalling anywhere from 20k to 30k RPP combined among the five characters. It was a challenge for me to see if I could empty all five (including regenerated energy) before the raid ended. This was fun for me, helped my guild, and would lead to consistent valor rewards.
Both of these styles are now detrimental to my guild. Taking up a valuable slot in a mid-day raid to only dump 1k to 3k RPP is now a liability. Taking up five slots in a large raid limits the participation of my guildmates, adding to their frustration.
I see one potential alternative: I could retreat to my old guild, Fairy Tail, which is currently not running raids. Solo a few GG's a day (with 5 42-e chars, this is 15 to 20 minutes) to build loyalty to get my favors back, play through the new content, and occasionally merc raids for valor (though I hear mercing now costs GS, and mercing with a realistic probability of failure beyond my control is stressful = not fun).
If raid limits were removed (or doubled), then my style of play would no longer be a penalty to my guild, and I would happily take up my swords and staves to fight with my guild again. But as long as I am a liability to my guild, I have no true home, and the community of my guildies is one big reason I continued to play.
I hope this gets sorted out in the coming weeks, but as long as raid limits remain tight, I don't see fitting this game in my life, which makes me sad. I am a low-spending player, having probably spent about $50 on shields over the last year, and occasionally download GS offers.
I can see why that play style will suffer but you can literally dump energy on the toilet and keep on going with your day then dump energy while you're waiting in line at the store or watching tv or waiting for a bus or at lunch or... No one is busy every minute of the day. I don't think it's worth leaving. Just see what happens.

Niko +1
I think Niko describe on of the new problems very well. I can see during periods of casual gaming in my life (which happens with RL) that i would be a detriment to my guild and unable to help much in raid (by which I mean dumping 42e + whatever in a single visit).
Niko +1
You said It Perfectly.
Venan: No One Wants To Be A Drag On Their Guild.
I also agree with Niko. I don't mind that Venan wants to redefine Silver as the new standard, and Gold only when people are committed to burning pots.
But the raid cap really does not make any sense. Why limit a raid to 30 or 40 players when there can be 100 people in the guild? Like Niko, I used to jump in a raid and dump my energy. Every bit helps afterall. But now, I have to think about whether I can stick around for the entire raid. It's unfair to the rest of the people in the raid if I cannot. Raids being longer now, the time commitment is significant. How do decisions like this make the game more enjoyable?
The changes are definitely much worse on lower level characters, which will have big impacts on the number of players that actually stick around.
Also did you forget about the new guilds and players?!? They can't complete the raids. And when they call for help on the global most people make fun of them for asking for help. Come on guys, help them. This game needs new players. If there aren't new players coming aboard a game will die, so you can't make a game not fun to get started in. Also belittling new players wrong on so many levels they look up to the players with the crazy amount of might, so give them a helping hand and not call them stupid for needing help. You where all new to the game at one time so don't forget.