Book of Heroes

A post in favor of the goal of raid limits

Simply put, the goal of the new raid limits, raid restructuring, and adjusted times, is that a Gold raid should be the reward for burning a fairly large amount of extra energy, and Silver should be the new norm for a full-commitment but not necessarily free-burning raid (IE, lots of raiders at the start, sticking around for the whole raid, on natural energy regen).

To me, this seems fair. We got spoiled with easy Gold, and it became the new expectation. It's fair for Venan to redefine it in this way. It's their game, after all.

What I'm not happy about is the raid limits. Why can my guild of 100 people only send 40 into a given raid? I'm not sure what the better solution is, as raid limits seem to be needed to define how many people can be actively spending energy, and therefore how much energy is needed for a given level, but it still seems unfair that because I'm the 41st person to join the raid IN MY GUILD, I can't, because there's a hard cap. If we can only put 40 in at a time, then why do we even have 100 spots?
Just a theory here, but I know in my guild we never had all 60 members in any raid at one time. The increase to 100 gives guilds a larger pool of potential raiders to fill out a raid. Do I think the inability to remove a player who may just be taking up a spot due to RL sucks....oh yeah. This theory makes sense why the increase makes sense. The caps on some raids are too low I believe though. The low cap on Gobs makes perfect sense to limit the amount of poaching 1st for the top 3 feat. Just my 2¢
If the goal is to force a guild to spend real life money in order to complete a raid, then I want no part of this game anymore. And yes, some raids *cannot* be completed without burning.
The cap on raids also means that casual players can't raid.

For VG, silver reward means 40 people use all their energy for Three hours. If that happens, you can get silver without burning.

As we know, in practice, some can't full the full Three hours.

So, for any casual player joining, those committed Will have to burn just to finish VG.

This means I cannot dump 42 e and go to work any longer.

So if your goal with this patch is to get rid of any casual player and just keep hardcore burners, or those willing to commit to all raids they enter, well, if that's the goal you've nailed it Venan.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu May 9, 2013 10:01 am
It's really looking like people will stop playing this game in their droves. All those casual players? The raid cap ensures you can't just drop in and dump energy anymore. You can't even help YOUR OWN GUILD out in a raid, because you didn't join within one minute of the raid announcement.

Make raids more difficult, that's fine. Everyone was getting gold. I like almost everything else about this patch. But capping the number of raid players is going to drive people away well before they find out what it's like with all the loyalty bonuses.

I hope you take note of all these angry people, Venan, because your current silence is conspicuous.
So gold is basically now designed for burners and that's okay? No, that's not okay.

Gold is supposed to be for a dedicated group and burning is supposed to be for either additional rewards or helping a group that is falling behind, which many if not most groups do as it was. If they are redefining it as a burner's reward then, honestly, I don't see myself playing this anymore. And I was so excited to play this patch that I was going to buy a whole wagon of shields too.

I'm fine with the limits but they are very strict. This game is ON A PHONE for goodness sake. While it's not a lot to ask for players to come back later on in the raid and spend more energy, it is too much to ask for ALL 40 people to be there the very second the raid pops open, and make sure every single point of energy is spent from that moments onward. If I wanted that sort of gameplay I would be playing World of Warcraft because it's much more fun and only $15 per month gets you the best rewards if you put the time in.

Guild limits were put in place, obviously, BECAUSE they expanded the guilds to 100. The previous "raid cap" was 60. And I was kicked out of the OP's guild multiple times to make room for new raiders. Now we don't have to boot people to make room. Makes sense. With the raid caps, the new issue would be unlimited raiders. So yes, I am fine with some sort of cap, at least on mercs.

Honestly, just reduce the wave counts in a raid and this patch will be fine. Venan dropped the amount of participants and increased wave sizes and they expected that we would be THAT DUMB to just smile and take it. Joke's on them.
AoW_McLovin wrote:Honestly, just reduce the wave counts in a raid and this patch will be fine. Venan dropped the amount of participants and increased wave sizes and they expected that we would be THAT DUMB to just smile and take it. Joke's on them.

I think I agree with this. While I'm not as experienced enough as many other players to truly know if the raid cap is a real problem, it seems to me that most raids I participated in never really had more than 15-20 people, unless I just wasn't paying attention.

The real problem seems to be that raids have been made so much longer by dramatically increasing the waves. If the wave count went back to pre-1.6, then I wonder if the raid cap would really matter anymore (although increasing it somewhat, or maybe getting rid of it altogether, would still probably be a good idea anyway, for all the various reasons people have said).
I think on some raids, the wave count should be increased, but have no cap to members joining. Mercs should always be capped.

In other raids, there should be a member cap. But I think the number of waves should be decreased.

Then you can organize a daily raid that requires like 60-70 active members to complete. Or you can stick to smaller, easier raids that require less people.

That's my two cents. Although balance is needed, I think the new patch will be great in the long run.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu May 9, 2013 12:26 pm
I agree with JaXtm in principle.

Gold should not be the standard...yet it was. And LimboDog, every raid can be completed without burning...just not Gold..which seems right to me.
I don't even mind the long raid times, as it works better for casual gaming...however...the casual gamers should be able to finish Bronze at least and that is where the problem lies.

Silver/bronze still require a very well coordinated full complement of toons working most of the raid to dump e. I think Venan should leave the gold standard where it is (and yes, gold should require some burining) and just relax the ability for Guilds to finish silver or bronze...bronze should be enough so that full toons can finish with casual gaming effort.

I do think part of the new 1.6 effort is to reduce the number of guilds...and I agree with that as well...There is no need to have 10000 guilds with 2-8 regular players each.