Book of Heroes

Merc Black List- Characters/ Players · page 2

mage12345 wrote:I am starting to wonder if the people shooting this down are the same people doing the sitting in the raids and whose names belong on here any way.

Mage, what is your guild because with an attitude like this I certainly wouldn't join a raid of your guild. Maybe we should make a blacklist of guilds.
I smell trolls. The idea behind this list is to inform players of other players that are CONSISTANTLY logging into raids and just sitting there. If this is not a concern to you prrsonally then you don't need to bother reading this post. If someone is going to shoot down this topic then it seems they would be worried about their name showing up. Instead of just calling it a bad idea why not post a solution to the issue.
Sweeping issues under the rug does not make them go away. It just gives you something to trip over a few steps down later.
Oda_Galen2 wrote:This isn't the way to do it. It would need to be an in game guild feature. Also if ever added, GM's would be fools to use it for single offenses. Sooner or later their guild would be empty. Everyone has a problem sometimes


What other options do we have, and we are talking about merc's not guild members, if a guildy does this the GM should give a warning, etc. But for a merc, we really don't have any means to deal with it, what is so wrong with holding people accountable. If you can't finish a a raid don't fill a spot, period. If somebody comes up with a better idea, great, I am all ears.

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri May 10, 2013 1:42 pm
Mage,
I understand your position...however I would just like to point out that if you knew the players pushing back on this thread, namely Romeo, Bbbb, Niko and Galen, you would know that none of them are remotely capable of sandbagging a raid by merc skunking...they are all some of the best and most upstanding players in the game today. Their position is more along the lines of what Niko stated, a thread like this represents a possible culture change in the game that many of us old timers just don't want to see occur.
-Mith

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri May 10, 2013 3:33 pm
Mithrid wrote:
the players pushing back on this thread, namely Romeo, Bbbb, Niko and Galen, you would know that none of them are remotely capable of sandbagging a raid by merc skunking...they are all some of the best and most upstanding players in the game today.

Venan is aware of this issue:
Little_Mike wrote:
There are also some common complaints such as the skunk merc issue. We will implement something in the next client update to mitigate this issue. We recommend only opening up merc slots when absolutely necessary since mercs generally have a lower efficiency. You can also password protect your raid so only people you want can join your raid.

reasons for the raid changes
Oda_Galen2 wrote:This isn't the way to do it. It would need to be an in game guild feature. Also if ever added, GM's would be fools to use it for single offenses. Sooner or later their guild would be empty. Everyone has a problem sometimes

Of course this is the way to do it. As somebody said, this allows us to see trends. Not only that, but a blacklisted player can defend himself here. Not sure what you're afraid of.
Thank you MIth. I had meant to come back to this topic and post a reply but you already did for me :)
Mithrid wrote:Mage,
I understand your position...however I would just like to point out that if you knew the players pushing back on this thread, namely Romeo, Bbbb, Niko and Galen, you would know that none of them are remotely capable of sandbagging a raid by merc skunking...they are all some of the best and most upstanding players in the game today. Their position is more along the lines of what Niko stated, a thread like this represents a possible culture change in the game that many of us old timers just don't want to see occur.
-Mith

I do admit there are people capable of skunking. In the early guild days, there were a-holes who would cancel raids when you were almost done. They thought since no info was publicly logged that they were in the clear. Changes have been made to solve this.

I have no problem w a per guild blacklist of who they don't let merc or attempt to join as a member. There are reasons for this beyond sandbagging.
At this point, you may want to look at adding a GUILD black list.

Unfortunately some guilds are running Guild Loyalty farming raids, with open merc slots. Why open a raid to mercs when you have no real intention on finishing the raid, much less aim for a gold finish. Many mercs have been burned this weekend joining a raid, burining pots, then discovering that the guild was only loyalty farming.

If you want to loyalty farm, SET THE MERCS TO ZERO. Please!