Book of Heroes

Merc Black List- Characters/ Players · page 3

I've had only one time where I merced into the wrong raid and bailed temporarily. I only attacked maybe 2 rounds, realized it was the wrong valor raid (yea still learning which ones are which) and went to the correct one, but I came back after finishing the right one and helped the raid I mistakenly joined, using an epot to allow myself to catch up and contribute enough (we finished in bronze cuz we didnt have a lot of people anyway). If you are really worried about mercs poping in and ruining your raids, set a password and form an alliance or two, tell them what your raids pw will be and just let trusted mercs join your raids. Dont leave 15 slots open to mercs and leave no PW and let them pop in and spend 4 energy and bail. No need for a blacklist, just make friends, sister guilds, etc. Then just PW protect your raids for your guild and the trusted mercs, which would be a good idea for a list instead of blackballing, make a Quality Merc list of people that contribute pleanty and never bail, or use epots, or call their friends, etc...
The reason that many guilds are leaving so many slots wide open is that they were not strong enough to begin with for certain raids and were succeeding based on merc support. Nothing was wrong with that because that was the reality from August to now. But the world was changed with 1.6 and that strategy doesn't work.

Note: I have the GM duties of a guild dumped on me in Sept and we were in the same boat. Mercs were harder to get in those days than during the 1.5 era and I ended up merging. I think there are a lot of guilds out there that need to merge to deal with the new reality. Unfortunately, the guild loyalty system inhibits mergers.
I wouldnt say it inhibits them exactly, since the loyalty just started, its not hard to go from being lvl 1 or two or even 3 loyalty to joining a new guild. And with the merc PW option, you can make sister guilds with someone and have them be the only ones with your guilds PW to join you for raids. Thus effectivly conjoining the guilds without having to lose anyones loyalty bonuses, and you gain a bunch of new raiders to assist your guild when needed. Personally, I have no problem merging guilds as long as I dont get bumped down to "lower than dirt"-recruit status. Being an officer in my guild means I have the task of setting up the progression raids and keeping new members in line with our behavior expectations, I prefer to have the control over certain things like that, been doing that sorta stuff for years now from WoW.
Player named Kristall joined our WoF raid. Did one hit. Then says in chat "one set of sweet 100 rpp donated. Have fun with WoF.". Then leaves. I don't care what anyone says. No one is going to convince me that this guy's kid broke a tooth or that his internet went out. There needs to be a way to remove people from raids, period.
Thad wrote:Player named Kristall joined our WoF raid. Did one hit. Then says in chat "one set of sweet 100 rpp donated. Have fun with WoF.". Then leaves. I don't care what anyone says. No one is going to convince me that this guy's kid broke a tooth or that his internet went out. There needs to be a way to remove people from raids, period.

Kristall from Black Lotus? wow... I've never seen that kinda behavior from her.
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Thad wrote:Player named Kristall joined our WoF raid. Did one hit. Then says in chat "one set of sweet 100 rpp donated. Have fun with WoF.". Then leaves. I don't care what anyone says. No one is going to convince me that this guy's kid broke a tooth or that his internet went out. There needs to be a way to remove people from raids, period.

Kristall from Black Lotus? wow... I've never seen that kinda behavior from her.

That was written some time in p2 of the raid. Shedid eeventually come back and burn e in the onslaught phase of the raid
Thad wrote:
That was written some time in p2 of the raid. Shedid eeventually come back and burn e in the onslaught phase of the raid

Oh, WoF onslaught vulturing (I am using that term in the fantasy football sense). It is the most effective way to earn KV in the game IMHO. Disclaimer: I used to do this back in 1.4 though I would always dump e along the way before P4 and burn GS through P4.

Before posting people as troublemakers, please let the current raid play out.
Why not set a limit of rpp that must be done in order to gain credit for participating in a raid? The majority of the people tagging raids are doing so to gain the achievement and if 100 rpp gets them credit for the raid then they will continue to drop 2e on 20 different raids per e dump in order to complete this achievement!

However it's not a huge issue to me as I merc and host guild raids all day long. The mercs that join and help get a message of thanks from me as well as our guilds PW for gold runs. It's just a personal system set up to weed out the achievement hunters!
Oda_Sadaar wrote:At this point, you may want to look at adding a GUILD black list.

Unfortunately some guilds are running Guild Loyalty farming raids, with open merc slots. Why open a raid to mercs when you have no real intention on finishing the raid, much less aim for a gold finish. Many mercs have been burned this weekend joining a raid, burining pots, then discovering that the guild was only loyalty farming.

If you want to loyalty farm, SET THE MERCS TO ZERO. Please!

I don't know of any guild that has all the challenges done yet. So those guilds that are farming gl are not guilds to raid with then.
I think adding a "Note" section to the raid display in the raid finder would be an easy way to let mercs know of any RPP caps the guild wants to enforce or what their goal is regarding times / loyalty farming, etc.