Spartanmerc wrote:RH_Alanna wrote:A 1000 rrp doesn't look bad on goblins, but does on Krakken. On a toon with 18 energy (common in my guild) 1 bar of energy puts you to 1080.
The difference is in Goblins, by the time you reach 1,000ish RPP, the raid is nearly over, making it harder to get much higher, and everyone knows this so its no big deal for someone to pull that score as it is a much higher % of contribution to the raid than it is in Kraken. And 1,000ish RPP for Kraken, with it being so long, means the person just emptied energy once and stopped raiding, which isnt going to get the raid done, people need to be coming back after a brief recharge time. So if you finish Goblins with 1,000 RPP, then you got a decent amount of the work done, if you raid Kraken and from start to finish only put in 1,000 RPP, you didnt help your raid enough. I wouldn't mind having a function in the Host Guild's Officers power to boot someone that has been inactive for 30min or more at the end of a phase or something. Something like...
Risen From the Depths
1. Guildmate A 3450 RPP [ ]
2. Guildmate B 3300 RPP [ ]
etc...
15. RandomMerc C 205 RPP [X]
Remove selected inactive players at the end of current raid phase (11 minutes 32 seconds)
And it would remove selected players if they have been inactive for 30 minutes by the time the phase ends, allowing for a new player to take their place and contribute.
The issue that you dont account for is when they join the raid. If you come into kraken on a small character (high enough might, but just there) it takes longer to hit then someone who is much higher. One of my characters takes 1 hit to kill kraken, the lowest takes significantly more. The high character can blow 40 energy in the same amount of time my smaller character takes to burn around 18.
on the other hand, small toons can often handle phase 1 and 2 much more easily than they can handle phase 3. Particularly in coc, I have had the issue of just simply not being able to make a kill in phase 3 of coc. the lack of rpp then is not lack of trying.
finally, I have people in my guild that have a decent might, but very low energy (18 e, level 30 character) over the course of a raid, even a long one, there is only a finite amount that they will contribute. The more energy you have coming into it, the higher the possible rpp (ignoring gs and pots). Several of the sigils require a hefty amount of gs. No one should be required to payout GS to be able to enjoy the game and participate in raids.
I suppose you will say that if I can't hold my own I shouldn't be in the raid... Well first, if you have the required might, the fight should be appropriate. Second, you can't get the valor, etc, necessary to move up if you don't join the raid. lastly, while I wouldn't as a merc purposely hurt a raid, I think there should be no "punishment" within the guild for joining in and doing as much as possible, which is now possible with the newest patch.