I've sort of said this before, but let me stress this and hopefully be more eloquent. The latest updates are for the most part great, but they introduce a significant problem. It used to be that when you had a quick break from rl you could dump your e into a guild, socialize for a min or two and go. Now, quick breaks are no good for raiding. If you don't get in at the beginning you can't get in. If you can't reasonably expect to stay on for 2+ hours (which is asking a lot for many) then joining a raid makes you dead weight filling up a spot. Basically the current setup is incompatible with real life. Separate but related issues: 1) if you do join a raid early to help it out, you end up feeling guilty when it fills up and people can't get in. A game shouldn't make you feel guilty for playing it. 2) if John doe enters the raid and only hits once, there's no way to get rid of him. Or for that matter prevent him from doing that every raid. Locking down an entire guild that you want open is not a reasonable solution for one bad apple raider.
Unfortunately these are hard problems to solve. I have some ideas about how they could be solved. Not great ideas. Perhaps you can do better. Here they are:
1) to solve all problems: get rid of raid caps or make them rediculously high. This is an easy out of course and i respect the reason for having them.
2) to solve problem of only being on shortly to dump e, provide a mechanism where a toon can voluntarily leave a raid. To avoid people using this to dump e for several toons (in effect raising the toon limit), put a time limit on spot becoming available after they leave. Possibly in this scenario they can still get rewards too.
3) to deal with annoying hit once guy problem, I see two possible solutions:
3a) ability to blacklist players from entering guild. Either as members or Mercs. This would also be handy for people that are very annoying. Like myself
3b) ability to kick from raid toons that have had their e maxed out for some length of time. To avoid bad feelings, they could maybe even get to keep rewards. Just gives up their spot. This also partially satisfies first issue. To make life simple, you could auto boot toons with maxed e after let's say 10 min. Just thought of that. Actually that's quite good. Do 3a+ 3b auto boot and all problems solved.
Unfortunately these are hard problems to solve. I have some ideas about how they could be solved. Not great ideas. Perhaps you can do better. Here they are:
1) to solve all problems: get rid of raid caps or make them rediculously high. This is an easy out of course and i respect the reason for having them.
2) to solve problem of only being on shortly to dump e, provide a mechanism where a toon can voluntarily leave a raid. To avoid people using this to dump e for several toons (in effect raising the toon limit), put a time limit on spot becoming available after they leave. Possibly in this scenario they can still get rewards too.
3) to deal with annoying hit once guy problem, I see two possible solutions:
3a) ability to blacklist players from entering guild. Either as members or Mercs. This would also be handy for people that are very annoying. Like myself
3b) ability to kick from raid toons that have had their e maxed out for some length of time. To avoid bad feelings, they could maybe even get to keep rewards. Just gives up their spot. This also partially satisfies first issue. To make life simple, you could auto boot toons with maxed e after let's say 10 min. Just thought of that. Actually that's quite good. Do 3a+ 3b auto boot and all problems solved.