Musketeer wrote:
Feats gave Gold Shields, not Hero Tokens, so toons from the legacy era who completed feats are now often weaker than those started later and earned the big HS bonuses.
So since I joined at the end of May 2012, you are saying I joined at the perfect time.

What a load of total BS. Because the people happy with the changes are just as abundant and sick of things been set to weakest level. Is easy to take a poll and have it say what you want when you only listen to results you want.
The raid changes have forced a great number of guilds that were thriving previous to the update to the brink of collapse. This much is evident. The social construct that made mercy-mercing such a joy in 1.5 is also seriously hampered by the these same changes. My particular observations regarding these changes are of course slanted by my personal experiences and by the experiences expressed by those I have had contact with in the guilds I have had the pleasure of raiding with both pre and post changes, as well as the fact that although my own guild's raid achievements have been greatly curtailed, our standing in power and precedence has not been altered, leading one to the conclusion that overall, most guilds are experiencing these same problems, or our own guild's standing would have been displaced.
1.5 had a chaotic start but what the game blossomed into was unique, and attracted a great deal of players through its combination of the social dynamic between guilds/mercing/favours and the fact that raids were not so time consuming that they became a chore.
Some seem to have come to the mistaken conclusion that my comments thus far have been derisive, lightly conceived or that they have been personal attacks. Nothing could be further from the truth. I have watched a game I thoroughly enjoyed go from something that had been a uniquely inclusive participatory game to one whose raid dynamics have changed this inclusive policy into fierce antagonistic derision towards mercs and even their own guild members who through one reason or another have not been able to contribute as fully as others would have them do.
This dissension has changed the entire dynamic of the game. It breeds contempt and enmity instead of friendship and community, and the game is sorrier for it. This is why I chose to post, as BOH; Venan; myself; and the entire community will ultimately lose out if the remedy that is chosen only serves to breed further contention.