Book of Heroes

Focusing Frustration in the Right Direction

It seems that Venan really doesn't seem to understand why most users kept coming back to a rpg that for the most part is about as exciting as pressing calculator buttons over and over again on their phones/iPods/Androids. The social community is what has been keeping this game interesting since it came out, and that social community took a major hit when 1.6 was implemented. This hit may cost Venan more than just sales, it may in fact spell the demise of a game that held so much promise because it was different, and all of the changes have each had a part in taking something away from that social community; I will try my best to outline how these changes have hampered rather than helped the current community that has remained so loyal to Venan up to now.

Since the update, I have been polling both in and out of my Guild for user experiences with 1.6. I was unhappy with the changes from the start, but did not post as I have been collecting opinions of players in other guilds and on Global to see what the community reaction would be regarding these changes. Having spoken to (IMO) a wide range of current players in Global, other guilds and my own I have been hearing the same things over and over again from the online community who have been active both before the changes and since.

First and most problematic is the raid caps. Previous to the update all guilds I have spoken to were able to complete their Guilds active raids in time for gold, now every guild I have spoken to is struggling to complete lower raids in silver or bronze if at all. Venan needs to understand: most players find raids that take longer than an hour to finish a complete grind. There is only so much button pressing one can do before it ceases to be fun and becomes a chore. Raid caps need to be changed, if not eliminated. These caps have also effectively put the nail in the coffin for mercy mercing. There is no longer any way for a guild to come to another guild's rescue without seriously hindering them with extra mercs. The 'joy de 'vivre of having your 'superhero' toons swooping in and saving the day has been completely cancelled with the raid caps. The community has suffered greatly.

I have heard a lot of people complaining about low contributing players taking spots in raids, but they need to focus their frustration at the real problem; the raid caps. Every player; no matter how active in the raid; gets a guild one step closer to ending a raid and should not be punished for what little help they can provide. The current raid caps are the problem, not the low contributing players. Writing code to punish players for contributing to a raid will just compound the problem and makes an unhappy situation more problematic. Also, the raid caps take any advantage that the larger guild cap could have improved. As one of my colleagues put it: "It is like giving someone a one hundred dollar bill when the machine only accepts twenties."

Secondly, and I know this might come as an awkward realization to some players; The raid finder automating raid hunting hinders the active community that has built itself up around the game by taking the communication between players out of the equation. It may be easier to find a raid that is suitable to what a single player needs this way, but taking the community interaction out of the equation hinders the greater community in general by reducing active communication between potential mercs and Host Guilds. Global may have been chaotic, but it encouraged people to interact with each other before; during; and after the raid. This social aspect made BOH unique among RPGs, and changing that has taken something that was easy to do previously and made it more difficult to do. Not something conducive to improving in game play.

Thirdly: the loyalty points system is not only too weak as it stands, but also not fair to those who have been in guild previous to the update. For instance, there is no bonus loyalty reward for staying with a raid with your Guild, and the points system for onslaught raids is unfair to those that do the majority of the killing if the loyalty amount is the same for those that make it through 9-12 waves as those that only make it through one. There should be a loyalty bonus to the top half of the contribution ladder in a successful raid, as this is what guild loyalty should mostly be rewarded for.

Fourth; the hero point system was not broken, and did not need to be fixed. As it stands now it stacks things against top guild members for completing daily quests or competing in Guild raids that aren't within 3 levels of their level, and no guild except perhaps HJ is currently completing raid challenges at the top range of their highest players.

Lastly; all of the changes implemented in 1.6 have put what I believe to be the majority of players, for whom this game is not their life, in a position where if they do not become more active they suffer the consequences of less buffs, less hero points for active quests and less fun all the way around. With the changes as they stand, Venan has successfully turned what was a pleasant pass-time into a major chore. Much to the dismay of the current community.

-M
I dissagree although everything you say is valid all changes that where made where to accomidate larger numbers of players and that rebalance will take time and putting passwords on raids allows you to manage bad mercs and keeping the community chirping bottom line give it time try to make it work insted of working againts it. Imo
I respect your opinion and I ask that you respect mine as well, as you seem to have come to the conclusion that there is a universal consensus on the changes made in 1.6.

First and foremost, lets be clear, the community makes the game fun and more fulfilling, but some of us really do enjoy playing the actual game. We are fans of this genre and we enjoy seeing our characters grow in strength and fight progressively more difficult foes with greater and greater ease. I don't feel like I'm pushing calculator buttons at all.

Your selection of people in global is limited. Most players who are content in their guild and raids don't visit global all that often anymore with the streamlined form of participating in raids as a mercenary. Before 1.5 global was basically 1/3 advertisements for mercs, 1/3 people trolling and complaining, and 1/3 people asking how to become a moderator. Without the merc advertisements there's not much else. The happy players are silently celebrating their victories in their own guilds and planning new ways to adapt to this patch.

Raid caps are necessary to make raids not trivial. In the current patch, you no longer leave your own raid to raid with other guilds. Therefore there needs to be a cap of some sort to every raid or else the cap is equal to basically everyone who feels like joining in. Remember, some of us do like playing the actual game, and as such, do enjoy beating the odds even though there's always a risk of failure. While the actual cap amounts may or may not be too harsh, I am in agreements that caps should exist. Otherwise it just becomes a messy pile of people who don't even talk to each other that rush in. To take 2 hits and then go rush into another group for another 2 hits. This does nothing to promote teamwork or guild cohesion and it certainly doesn't help making the game any more exciting. What's the fun in something when there's no risk of failure. How many people would be playing Candy Crush if you could just receive unlimited moves from strangers whenever you're stuck?

As for mercs who don't contribute enough, and team is as strong as its weakest link. That's how it's always worked in any competitive group based activity and it should work here to some extent as well too.

I personally have been far more social now that I am in just one guild that I'm never booted from than I've ever been before 1.6. I feel like I have a team and a home and people I'm actually getting to talk to more than once every week or two. Global is still there if I want to see what's happening in other parts of BoH.

Your point about loyalty I haven't really considered but the system could use some tweaking I suppose. I suspect it will be tweaked in some way. This is just the first iteration of the design.

And your 4th point is just insulting. The game gives you push notifications if there's a raid. Join if you feel like it. Don't if you don't. Get on to chat when you want. Solo when you want. This game couldn't possibly be any more casual. It's in your pocket. I have a life and from what I can tell so does everyone who raids often in my guild.

You can still mercy merc by the way. Go check who needs help by visiting the trouble raids like Helion and Kraken. Swoop in and save the day. They'll love you.
Magdalene wrote: most players find raids that take longer than an hour to finish a complete grind. There is only so much button pressing one can do before it ceases to be fun and becomes a chore.

I agree completely. The 2:11 I spent on the Karnak raid seemed like 6.

Secondly, and I know this might come as an awkward realization to some players; The raid finder automating raid hunting hinders the active community that has built itself up around the game by taking the communication between players out of the equation.

Good point. I feel very isolated now. There is no reason to read global anymore and i am losing touch with a lot of people.

I disagree 100% with your onslaught and hero score thoughts. The hero score system was totally and completely broken before. The fixes made it maybe only half broken. The current problem was that the fix was too lazy - you shouldn't get zero, but a reduced amount. Also, the scores on each monster make absolutely no sense.

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon May 13, 2013 8:35 pm
Bbbb wrote:

Good point. I feel very isolated now. There is no reason to read global anymore and i am losing touch with a lot of people..

I feel isolated too, but for me, the majority of my pre 1.6 socializing was not done in global, but done by visiting other guilds as a merc...in 1.6, I love the merc finder, but now the only time I can visit friends in other guilds, I have to catch them just as they open up a merc slot...and even then if timing isn't right, those slots fill up too fast or they are at times I am unable to join...I miss the opportunity.

I need a more casual method of visiting other guilds, maybe not as a merc but as a visitor-tourist, when its convienent for me.

Regarding Hero Score, I like the fixes, and they were very much needed. I think its fair not to get points for slaughtering armies of creatures that are no threat at all to you...but I do like Bbbb's suggestion of reduced hero score award so you get something to show your active.

As for the raid caps...
I love that gold has been made a real challenge and requires solid guild organization (or massive burning)...however, I do think it is very sad to have lost mercy mercing...I liked that about this thread as that hasn't been pointed out much with 1.6.
Mercy mercing is dead. :(

I also agree that even silver and broze raids are becoming tedious...
I have wished often for the ability to go in an help save a raid knowing I didnt need anything from it other then the satisfaction of helping. With raid caps thats not possible.
However, I do support the theory of raid caps and am uncertain how you can implement mercy mercing now...

...except as I pointed out in this thread: Remove raid cap.
dynamically adjusting the raid caps for gold-silver-bronze...I do not see how mercy mercing should be allowed for a gold raid (its a cheesy award of guild gold if you need someone else to earn it for you),...but silver or bronze can definitely benefit from a mercy mercenary. So Venan, implement dynamic raid caps...keep the raids and gold challenge where it is, but then lift caps for silver and further for bronze, this would make gold something of value, but still allow a guild to pile in players shortly after they miss the gold deadline and end the raid quickly so people arent raiding for hours with their toons locked up to avoid a failed raid. :D
Some thoughts on soldiers tier from a 'new' guild which also finds current raids a bit too long.

The old system of graduated increases in raid members worked well imho, newbies would start with Goblins and gradually work themselves up. Kraken the introductory raid to Soldier's tier was simple enough that it allowed a new guild to merc some raiders and get in a kill once a good number of their members were ready.

Things felt more varied then. A guild deep into soldiers tier could do Helion at peak hours when most of their members were around for the best valor/RPP ratio and do shorter raids off peak hours. Kraken was great for getting newer members up to speed in soldiers tier and could be run with fewer raiders online, 15-17 raiders or so would cruise to gold if everyone put in decent RPP. Zuur was a nice quick filler if you had around 20 punctual ppl while waiting for the longer Kraken and Helion cooldowns to reset. CoC was a good challenge to see how many waves you could do and to tweak your abilities/stats to do better.

These days in 1.6, all non onslaught Soldier tier raids are 30 member monsters which take waaay too long and all feel the same. Kraken has gone from 493 waves to a 884 wave abomination. If my guild was still doing soldiers tier in 1.6, I think we likely would have felt crushed just looking at the required numbers. Currently there are no short raids anymore which require less members online. Everything is long and demanding in terms of attendance and numbers and mercs are unreliable. In 1.5, if a merc came in, never put up even 1 hit in an hour, and you were full in terms of guild capacity, you could kick and replace. Now you are stuck with dead space. Strangely enough back then in 1.5, I found less of these 100RPP mercs. When you have the ease of raid finder letting all and sundry queue up for anything they like in 1.6, I guess that's what you should expect. /shrug

My guild has moved on to CK since then, which after rebalancing, doesn't seem to be too awkward. But I feel sorry for our members who have not yet breached 5300 might. Yes I know they are free to merc raids on their own but it doesnt feel quite the same. I enjoy doing guild runs with the whole guild and to be able to provide runs to all our members.



I like the idea of dynamic raid caps. There should be some effort to make casual play viable again. Making gold times tight is fine, but please allow participation from casuals and shorten raid lengths.

LUNABELLA

ModeratorTue May 14, 2013 3:11 pm
I think in 1.5 you found less of those 100 RPP hitters because the reason they appeared/is completely different. In 1.5 a merc looking for a raid could join a guild check how the raid is going & if the raid is not going particularly well they would just leave without hitting to look for another raid. Some would of course do mercy merc'ing, but that's friends of the guild. IMO most of 100 RPP Mercs in 1.5 were people that just busy with something else that came up RL. I never had to kick anyone from a raid.
In 1.6 Mercs can join a raid only by already taking a slot in & some of them if realize that basically the raid is now very slow or wasn't as advanced as they thought (the raid finders shows you total time left to completion but some people don't calculate time left to gold) then they can just join another raid and don't need to drop anymore hits in your raid while that slot is busy till the end of the raid.
LUNABELLA wrote:...they can just join another raid and don't need to drop anymore hits in your raid while that slot is busy till the end of the raid.

I fully agree that what you have stated here is probably what happens in a good majority of these cases. Suggest to give the guild rights to remove mercs that are doing below a certain threshold (say 500RPP). The raid would lose all the hits done by that player once he/she is kicked but the slot would be free. Some have brought up additional criteria like not being able to kick within say 30 mins of joining, etc. That sounds fine too.
Having a Vote to kick, or a guild officer be able to lock a player (guilded or not) out of a raid would be nice, would also be nice if, like some others said, a person didnt realize till after they paid the 2e to join the raid that it was the wrong one or not as far along, they could remove themselves from the raid cap on their own. That might help a bit too.
Magdalene wrote:The social community is what has been keeping this game interesting since it came out, and that social community took a major hit when 1.6 was implemented.

Just for the record, there was no social network until Guilds were introduced in version 1.4 on 23rd May 2012. Prior to that there were leaderboards you could look at at the Mucky Duck, but that was it for player interaction.

Once you had completed the main Questline, originally much shorter than it is now, the only reason to continue playing was the Daily Bounty, which did not give Hero Tokens as they did not exist until the version 1.4 major.

Feats gave Gold Shields, not Hero Tokens, so toons from the legacy era who completed feats are now often weaker than those started later and earned the big HS bonuses.