It seems that Venan really doesn't seem to understand why most users kept coming back to a rpg that for the most part is about as exciting as pressing calculator buttons over and over again on their phones/iPods/Androids. The social community is what has been keeping this game interesting since it came out, and that social community took a major hit when 1.6 was implemented. This hit may cost Venan more than just sales, it may in fact spell the demise of a game that held so much promise because it was different, and all of the changes have each had a part in taking something away from that social community; I will try my best to outline how these changes have hampered rather than helped the current community that has remained so loyal to Venan up to now.
Since the update, I have been polling both in and out of my Guild for user experiences with 1.6. I was unhappy with the changes from the start, but did not post as I have been collecting opinions of players in other guilds and on Global to see what the community reaction would be regarding these changes. Having spoken to (IMO) a wide range of current players in Global, other guilds and my own I have been hearing the same things over and over again from the online community who have been active both before the changes and since.
First and most problematic is the raid caps. Previous to the update all guilds I have spoken to were able to complete their Guilds active raids in time for gold, now every guild I have spoken to is struggling to complete lower raids in silver or bronze if at all. Venan needs to understand: most players find raids that take longer than an hour to finish a complete grind. There is only so much button pressing one can do before it ceases to be fun and becomes a chore. Raid caps need to be changed, if not eliminated. These caps have also effectively put the nail in the coffin for mercy mercing. There is no longer any way for a guild to come to another guild's rescue without seriously hindering them with extra mercs. The 'joy de 'vivre of having your 'superhero' toons swooping in and saving the day has been completely cancelled with the raid caps. The community has suffered greatly.
I have heard a lot of people complaining about low contributing players taking spots in raids, but they need to focus their frustration at the real problem; the raid caps. Every player; no matter how active in the raid; gets a guild one step closer to ending a raid and should not be punished for what little help they can provide. The current raid caps are the problem, not the low contributing players. Writing code to punish players for contributing to a raid will just compound the problem and makes an unhappy situation more problematic. Also, the raid caps take any advantage that the larger guild cap could have improved. As one of my colleagues put it: "It is like giving someone a one hundred dollar bill when the machine only accepts twenties."
Secondly, and I know this might come as an awkward realization to some players; The raid finder automating raid hunting hinders the active community that has built itself up around the game by taking the communication between players out of the equation. It may be easier to find a raid that is suitable to what a single player needs this way, but taking the community interaction out of the equation hinders the greater community in general by reducing active communication between potential mercs and Host Guilds. Global may have been chaotic, but it encouraged people to interact with each other before; during; and after the raid. This social aspect made BOH unique among RPGs, and changing that has taken something that was easy to do previously and made it more difficult to do. Not something conducive to improving in game play.
Thirdly: the loyalty points system is not only too weak as it stands, but also not fair to those who have been in guild previous to the update. For instance, there is no bonus loyalty reward for staying with a raid with your Guild, and the points system for onslaught raids is unfair to those that do the majority of the killing if the loyalty amount is the same for those that make it through 9-12 waves as those that only make it through one. There should be a loyalty bonus to the top half of the contribution ladder in a successful raid, as this is what guild loyalty should mostly be rewarded for.
Fourth; the hero point system was not broken, and did not need to be fixed. As it stands now it stacks things against top guild members for completing daily quests or competing in Guild raids that aren't within 3 levels of their level, and no guild except perhaps HJ is currently completing raid challenges at the top range of their highest players.
Lastly; all of the changes implemented in 1.6 have put what I believe to be the majority of players, for whom this game is not their life, in a position where if they do not become more active they suffer the consequences of less buffs, less hero points for active quests and less fun all the way around. With the changes as they stand, Venan has successfully turned what was a pleasant pass-time into a major chore. Much to the dismay of the current community.
-M
Since the update, I have been polling both in and out of my Guild for user experiences with 1.6. I was unhappy with the changes from the start, but did not post as I have been collecting opinions of players in other guilds and on Global to see what the community reaction would be regarding these changes. Having spoken to (IMO) a wide range of current players in Global, other guilds and my own I have been hearing the same things over and over again from the online community who have been active both before the changes and since.
First and most problematic is the raid caps. Previous to the update all guilds I have spoken to were able to complete their Guilds active raids in time for gold, now every guild I have spoken to is struggling to complete lower raids in silver or bronze if at all. Venan needs to understand: most players find raids that take longer than an hour to finish a complete grind. There is only so much button pressing one can do before it ceases to be fun and becomes a chore. Raid caps need to be changed, if not eliminated. These caps have also effectively put the nail in the coffin for mercy mercing. There is no longer any way for a guild to come to another guild's rescue without seriously hindering them with extra mercs. The 'joy de 'vivre of having your 'superhero' toons swooping in and saving the day has been completely cancelled with the raid caps. The community has suffered greatly.
I have heard a lot of people complaining about low contributing players taking spots in raids, but they need to focus their frustration at the real problem; the raid caps. Every player; no matter how active in the raid; gets a guild one step closer to ending a raid and should not be punished for what little help they can provide. The current raid caps are the problem, not the low contributing players. Writing code to punish players for contributing to a raid will just compound the problem and makes an unhappy situation more problematic. Also, the raid caps take any advantage that the larger guild cap could have improved. As one of my colleagues put it: "It is like giving someone a one hundred dollar bill when the machine only accepts twenties."
Secondly, and I know this might come as an awkward realization to some players; The raid finder automating raid hunting hinders the active community that has built itself up around the game by taking the communication between players out of the equation. It may be easier to find a raid that is suitable to what a single player needs this way, but taking the community interaction out of the equation hinders the greater community in general by reducing active communication between potential mercs and Host Guilds. Global may have been chaotic, but it encouraged people to interact with each other before; during; and after the raid. This social aspect made BOH unique among RPGs, and changing that has taken something that was easy to do previously and made it more difficult to do. Not something conducive to improving in game play.
Thirdly: the loyalty points system is not only too weak as it stands, but also not fair to those who have been in guild previous to the update. For instance, there is no bonus loyalty reward for staying with a raid with your Guild, and the points system for onslaught raids is unfair to those that do the majority of the killing if the loyalty amount is the same for those that make it through 9-12 waves as those that only make it through one. There should be a loyalty bonus to the top half of the contribution ladder in a successful raid, as this is what guild loyalty should mostly be rewarded for.
Fourth; the hero point system was not broken, and did not need to be fixed. As it stands now it stacks things against top guild members for completing daily quests or competing in Guild raids that aren't within 3 levels of their level, and no guild except perhaps HJ is currently completing raid challenges at the top range of their highest players.
Lastly; all of the changes implemented in 1.6 have put what I believe to be the majority of players, for whom this game is not their life, in a position where if they do not become more active they suffer the consequences of less buffs, less hero points for active quests and less fun all the way around. With the changes as they stand, Venan has successfully turned what was a pleasant pass-time into a major chore. Much to the dismay of the current community.
-M