Book of Heroes

Update 1.6.1 - May 23, 2013 · page 10

JohnJSal wrote:You seem to be working on the assumption that every or most members of a guild will be on during a raid. I'm not trying to "cater" to small guilds, I'm thinking of even a 100 party guild that may only have 20-30 people on for a raid. If the raids are still too long, the 100 person cap won't do any good in these situations.

I'm working under the assumption that since everyone can pop in during the raid and dump e then leave without any penalty, raids will seem much shorter than they do now. You can have up to 100 members in a guild. If you can't get enough of those people to pay attention to push notifications then you can merc. But you probably don't deserve Gold as a guild if you don't have people participating. There isn't much challenge in BoH beyond showing up. If you don't have attendance, you don't have Gold. That's how it's supposed to work.

First of all, who ever said no raid cap? I don't know where you got that from. Even pre-1.6 the cap was effectively 60. Second, no one is asking for "short raids," just SHORTER raids than they currently are, because they've been made so long that no one is having fun anymore. Your exaggerated example of a raid that's over before it barely began isn't helpful, because it's not real, nor will it be even if Venan shortens the raids a little more.

Your point is that if you can't field enough people the raid will be longer. Yes. That's the idea. Working as intended. Your guild will need to recruit more active players in order to finish raids in a more timely manner.

Raids aren't very long once you have a lot of people hitting. And the almost-insta-raid scenario is not impossible and it can easily happen in a very active guild like the kind you see on the top of the rankings every week with 100 people eligible to hit.
I do think that 1.6 has been detrimental to small / new guilds. It's not fair to say, "Well they should just merge with another guild.". There should always be room in the game for a group of friends to make a casual guild together. They should at least be able to do Kraken, which is the entry point to soldier valor. There is no point making Kraken painful for a small guild to do. The most dedicated players will in all likelihood be able to do KV raids. I don't think anyone would complain about a lack of challenge if we shortened Kraken. Let's see what the new patch brings.

The higher tier raids SHOULD be difficult, and should require some coordination to finish. If a casual guild makes it to this point then they need to either recruit to fill the ranks for merge.

At the same time, I don't think anyone wants the raids to be excessively long. I for one would prefer shorter raids with lowered rewards. There's simply more flexibility.

Obviously we'll need to see the actual patch, but I like the changes listed for 1.6.1
Fairy Tail just finished a VG raid at silver with 18 guild members (pitching in 59%) and 20 mercs (pitching in 41%). It was fun, we have a close knit group, and chatting with a variety of visitors is nice. A merc cap of 15 would likely work for our guild, but 10 would be tough.

Perhaps a progressive merc cap:
GG: 5 mercs
Other SqV: 10 mercs
SV: 15 mercs
KV: 20 mercs
CV: 25 mercs

Or a less generous, but still increasing 5/8/10/13/15 set of merc caps.
FT_NikoNarf wrote:Fairy Tail just finished a VG raid at silver with 18 guild members (pitching in 59%) and 20 mercs (pitching in 41%). It was fun, we have a close knit group, and chatting with a variety of visitors is nice. A merc cap of 15 would likely work for our guild, but 10 would be tough.

Perhaps a progressive merc cap:
GG: 5 mercs
Other SqV: 10 mercs
SV: 15 mercs
KV: 20 mercs
CV: 25 mercs

Or a less generous, but still increasing 5/8/10/13/15 set of merc caps.

Agreed. Mercs are vital for a guild's growth. We just did our first VG last night, and it wouldn't have gotten gold without the merc help. The first time a guild runs a raid, it almost always needs some help unless they wait til the entire guild is at that might.
Darkhorse wrote:
Fizz_Eric wrote:Couple comments/questions:
1. So this means raids like CoC/GK will have more waves, correct?
2. Why cap mercenaries at 10? Are we moving towards the end of mercing/ guild-guild interactions for good?
3. What prompted the removal of SC and FS from the game? And what does this mean for the challenge? Will it be disappearing as well? or will it remain as a trophy from the past?
4. Not super pressing, but if Snap Cast is being nerfed so much, why not just remove it and replace it with a different skill?

Outside that, interesting direction.

1. Yes. They should be in line with our new target numbers.
2. We'll be evaluating this number, but initially we want to limit the number of mercenaries to prevent easy exploits of the raid finder system.
3. These were 2 of the 3 most "unpopular" raids in the games based purely based on our metrics and number of raids run. We want to offer a more focused knights valor experience for newer players in that tier. The challenges associated with these two raids will disappear but guilds who have already completed the challenges will keep their prestige earned.
4. We're continuing to evaluate this and will likely make more class changes and tweaks as we get closer to PvP.
AoW_McLovin wrote:I'm working under the assumption that since everyone can pop in during the raid and dump e then leave without any penalty, raids will seem much shorter than they do now.

Frankly, that's an unreal assumption. You can't actually expect EVERY guild member to be available for every raid. Furthermore...
Your point is that if you can't field enough people the raid will be longer. Yes. That's the idea. Working as intended. Your guild will need to recruit more active players in order to finish raids in a more timely manner.

Raids aren't very long once you have a lot of people hitting.

Yes, but this comment doesn't even reflect the reality of the situation as even Venan apparently sees it. That is, they are supposedly designing the raids around a set number of raiders (20, 30, etc.) depending on the particular raid.

Therefore, it should be reasonable to FINISH that particular raid with that number of people. For you to then come here and suggest that a guild doesn't deserve to finish a raid if they don't have 80-100 people participating is ridiculous. It doesn't even seem like how the game's own developers intend for raiding to work. In other words, it's NOT "working as intended."
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Agreed. Mercs are vital for a guild's growth.

I'm pro-merc, but this statement is not true. There were no mercs for the first few months of the guild system and guilds grew just fine.
Here's an idea. Add gem shard conversion, convert tier 3 to tier 4, just like valor conversion
Bbbb wrote:
Swanstar wrote:
I can't force people to show up, raid, or merc. Helion to ck gap is hard to do too.

That gap has always been a hard one for guilds to jump and many guilds die there. That's been true ever since the guild system was introduced. Don't worry, the CK to Vallus and then Vallus to WoF will offer similar challenges.

You just disheartened me beyond belief. But honestly I am ok with building might raids as long as they can completed quickly. Kraken used to be complete in 30-45 min. Now it's not. That's a problem.
Fizz_Eric wrote:
FT_NikoNarf wrote:Fairy Tail just finished a VG raid at silver with 18 guild members (pitching in 59%) and 20 mercs (pitching in 41%). It was fun, we have a close knit group, and chatting with a variety of visitors is nice. A merc cap of 15 would likely work for our guild, but 10 would be tough.

Perhaps a progressive merc cap:
GG: 5 mercs
Other SqV: 10 mercs
SV: 15 mercs
KV: 20 mercs
CV: 25 mercs

Or a less generous, but still increasing 5/8/10/13/15 set of merc caps.

Agreed. Mercs are vital for a guild's growth. We just did our first VG last night, and it wouldn't have gotten gold without the merc help. The first time a guild runs a raid, it almost always needs some help unless they wait til the entire guild is at that might.

Makes perfect sense - so Venan will ignore this common sense suggestion...