JohnJSal wrote:You seem to be working on the assumption that every or most members of a guild will be on during a raid. I'm not trying to "cater" to small guilds, I'm thinking of even a 100 party guild that may only have 20-30 people on for a raid. If the raids are still too long, the 100 person cap won't do any good in these situations.
I'm working under the assumption that since everyone can pop in during the raid and dump e then leave without any penalty, raids will seem much shorter than they do now. You can have up to 100 members in a guild. If you can't get enough of those people to pay attention to push notifications then you can merc. But you probably don't deserve Gold as a guild if you don't have people participating. There isn't much challenge in BoH beyond showing up. If you don't have attendance, you don't have Gold. That's how it's supposed to work.
First of all, who ever said no raid cap? I don't know where you got that from. Even pre-1.6 the cap was effectively 60. Second, no one is asking for "short raids," just SHORTER raids than they currently are, because they've been made so long that no one is having fun anymore. Your exaggerated example of a raid that's over before it barely began isn't helpful, because it's not real, nor will it be even if Venan shortens the raids a little more.
Your point is that if you can't field enough people the raid will be longer. Yes. That's the idea. Working as intended. Your guild will need to recruit more active players in order to finish raids in a more timely manner.
Raids aren't very long once you have a lot of people hitting. And the almost-insta-raid scenario is not impossible and it can easily happen in a very active guild like the kind you see on the top of the rankings every week with 100 people eligible to hit.