Book of Heroes

Update 1.6.1 - May 23, 2013 · page 9

Fizz_Eric wrote: But I agree, for the vast majority of guilds, it's going to remain 20-30 people struggling through a raid, with 2-3 burners if lucky, none if unlucky.

In other words, exactly like it was back in the 1.4 days. God only knows how many Vallus I did with 20-30 struggling with 0-3 burners. BTW, that was in a top 10 guild too.
Hi everybody,

I don´t know if it´s too late, but I want to give my oppinion, make questions and suggestions about next update 1.6.1:
Classes:
- Could you tell us anything (not everything) about the changes in each class? What type of changes?
Guilds:
- I don´t understand why the loyalty will be down only a 50% if you move to another guild, it should be 0 and start again, to demonstrate your loyalty to the new guild. I´d understand it, if you make chained guilds, so if you move from one guild chained to other one, your loyalty is not completely lost, because you are in the same "family". Not losing everything, players may usually be moving, what kind of loyalty is that?
- I think that 10 mercs per raid is a good number. If you are in small guild 10 mercs plus 10 members are 20, enough to do a small or medium raid. If you are in a big guild you may not need mercs to do a medium or big raid and if needed with 5 or 8 mercs should be enough.
Raids:
- I can´t comment on removing some raids, because I didn´t do them yet. What I can say or suggest is that don´t remake raids so long, please, please, please ... it is sometimes boring to be killing the same monster all the time (360 for Kraken uffff ) and as fast as you can because of the time, this is stressful !!! So if you are going to allow 100 persons in the raids (I like this point, the limits we have now aren´t good for the game and the players), DON´T ADD more waves, people may stop participating in raids and consequently in the game.
In our guild while we were riding we talked in the chat and we really had a good time, but after 1.6 we don´t even have time to talk, this isn´t funny at all.

I think I don´t forget anything, oh yes, keep on doing this great job and listening to the players, I really appreciate that and the humility to admit mistakes and solve them quickly as you have demonstrated.

This is a marvellous game, don´t destroy it!!!!



PD: Sorry if my English isn´t very good.

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Fri May 17, 2013 8:11 pm
EJ_Nayec wrote:Hi everybody,

I don´t know if it´s too late, but I want to give my oppinion, make questions and suggestions about next update 1.6.1:
Classes:
- Could you tell us anything (not everything) about the changes in each class? What type of changes?
Guilds:
- I don´t understand why the loyalty will be down only a 50% if you move to another guild, it should be 0 and start again, to demonstrate your loyalty to the new guild. I´d understand it, if you make chained guilds, so if you move from one guild chained to other one, your loyalty is not completely lost, because you are in the same "family". Not losing everything, players may usually be moving, what kind of loyalty is that?
- I think that 10 mercs per raid is a good number. If you are in small guild 10 mercs plus 10 members are 20, enough to do a small or medium raid. If you are in a big guild you may not need mercs to do a medium or big raid and if needed with 5 or 8 mercs should be enough.
Raids:
- I can´t comment on removing some raids, because I didn´t do them yet. What I can say or suggest is that don´t remake raids so long, please, please, please ... it is sometimes boring to be killing the same monster all the time (360 for Kraken uffff ) and as fast as you can because of the time, this is stressful !!! So if you are going to allow 100 persons in the raids (I like this point, the limits we have now aren´t good for the game and the players), DON´T ADD more waves, people may stop participating in raids and consequently in the game.
In our guild while we were riding we talked in the chat and we really had a good time, but after 1.6 we don´t even have time to talk, this isn´t funny at all.

I think I don´t forget anything, oh yes, keep on doing this great job and listening to the players, I really appreciate that and the humility to admit mistakes and solve them quickly as you have demonstrated.

This is a marvellous game, don´t destroy it!!!!



PD: Sorry if my English isn´t very good.

Your English is pretty good, don't worry about it.

May I ask why you don't have time in raids to talk? I can still talk in a raid just fine.
Thanks Hotasfire :)

I don´t know, but since new raids are deployed people don´t talk so much as before, most of us have several toons and we are hitting/killing and changing to another toon all the time, as fast as possible to win the gold (we usually win it, not so usual as before), some of my collegues have even 2 devices and they are using both at the same time, so tell me how to stop to read and write in the chat :lol:

When we start a raid and there are few members conected, we assume that silver is the goal, so we hit/kill more relaxed and then we talk, laugh and comment things about guild, we really have fun.

Regards ;)
JohnJSal wrote:
AoW_McLovin wrote:
Amoron wrote:Little Mike...then return raid lengths to 1.5....Making raids longer is making raids a choir - not more fun

They've raised the effective raid cap by more than 2/3. I think the current raid lengths are fine given that.

Do you honestly think that most guilds will actually take advantage of such a huge raid cap? Or will it still be about 20 to 30 people struggling through long raids.

The raids are progressively balanced around higher numbers of raiders. Smaller guilds are usually in the lower tiers and with mercs there's no reason they won't at least get silver if people participate. Should we continue to cater to these small guilds of 10-15 people? At a certain point those guilds have to realize that they are a small guild and they aren't going to be able to tackle the strongest challenges in the game without growing and making new friends and teammates.

Making raids shorter would just make the upper tiers flat out stupid. No raid cap, short raid, lol? The raid will be over before I notice my push notification, much less accumulate enough RPP for it to matter that I even attended. What's the casual raider going to do when every raid is over before they get a chance to know it's even going on?
AoW_McLovin wrote:The raids are progressively balanced around higher numbers of raiders. Smaller guilds are usually in the lower tiers and with mercs there's no reason they won't at least get silver if people participate. Should we continue to cater to these small guilds of 10-15 people? At a certain point those guilds have to realize that they are a small guild and they aren't going to be able to tackle the strongest challenges in the game without growing and making new friends and teammates.

You seem to be working on the assumption that every or most members of a guild will be on during a raid. I'm not trying to "cater" to small guilds, I'm thinking of even a 100 party guild that may only have 20-30 people on for a raid. If the raids are still too long, the 100 person cap won't do any good in these situations.
Making raids shorter would just make the upper tiers flat out stupid. No raid cap, short raid, lol? The raid will be over before I notice my push notification, much less accumulate enough RPP for it to matter that I even attended. What's the casual raider going to do when every raid is over before they get a chance to know it's even going on?

First of all, who ever said no raid cap? I don't know where you got that from. Even pre-1.6 the cap was effectively 60. Second, no one is asking for "short raids," just SHORTER raids than they currently are, because they've been made so long that no one is having fun anymore. Your exaggerated example of a raid that's over before it barely began isn't helpful, because it's not real, nor will it be even if Venan shortens the raids a little more.
Sinphil wrote:So gold becomes standard, raids become longer and mercs are screwed over because some couldn't adapt. You never bothered checking with players just listened to whiners. Of course the people happy aren't going to post on forums you need find them.
If you don't speak, don't expect to be listened... Nothing prevents happy people from posting appreciation on the forums so Venan knows they're going in a direction that people appreciate. Venan please take note - I find the 1.6.1 changes great. Easy.
AoW_McLovin wrote:The raids are progressively balanced around higher numbers of raiders. Smaller guilds are usually in the lower tiers and with mercs there's no reason they won't at least get silver if people participate. Should we continue to cater to these small guilds of 10-15 people? At a certain point those guilds have to realize that they are a small guild and they aren't going to be able to tackle the strongest challenges in the game without growing and making new friends and teammates.
I fully agree. Venan give you 100 slots, use them. If your guild only has 20 regular raiders it can only progress as a merc room anyway. You'll need to recruit or merge with another guild. Most successful guilds are the results for merges and regular recruiting.

Then on the raid length subject I'm not sure... they do seem a bit long for the moment. With the 30 minutes cool down, I wouldn't really mind seeing shorter raids completed quickly but often. Less pressure to come back.
Snipped from Fizz_Eric and Mikedr:
Mikedr wrote:
Fizz_Eric wrote:Couple comments/questions:
1. So this means raids like CoC/GK will have more waves, correct?
2. Why cap mercenaries at 10? Are we moving towards the end of mercing?
Ok but I'm worried on this not all guild have 100 members and much fewer that can raid in All raids how is this going to help smaller guilds finish raids not looking for gold every time but it would be nice to be able to finish


What good purpose does it serve Venan to so misuse it's current user base?

Why must raid waves be increased thus? This proposed change is as good a solution (which is to say that it is no solution at all) as the original raid caps were to the game in the first place.

I might be tempted to insert certain Joni Mitchell quotes regarding "paradise" and "a parking lot" here did these proposals not leave me so aggrieved as they seem bent much to the detriment of smaller guilds and more casual players.

Does Venan so misunderstand their target market that they cannot see that a significant portion of this market may not have the luxury of being able to commit more than an hour of gameplay per raid? Do they believe they will sell more GS by taking this "uniquely inclusive community based MMORPG that fits in your pocket so it is handy to have to cheer those 'idle moments'" and turning into "just another cheap clone of UO, UT or WoW that takes as just as much of your time but has no real animation and a horribly crappy keyboard to boot."

Or perhaps there is an option I have inadvertently set that blocks the thousands of players who have been complaining vociferously each day that they "would love the game so much more; if only their current guild raids weren't so gosh darn short!"

That must be it.
-M
CrzyHopper wrote:I'm bummed about SC going away. Doesn't leave much for onslaught fans.

I feel the same way hop, I feel the same.

We were running daily SCs... now.... :(