My major gripes with the 1.6.1:
1)Removal of FS and SC:
Raid content, however unpopular, should be maintained. Perhaps some adjustments could be made to length or payoffs to make them a tad more attractive. But taking away 2 raids outright just seems a waste of time and effort on the devs part and new raiders would miss out on potential content. So please keep SC and FS. You can tweak them later on if still not satisfied but for now let new raiders experience them as they were before please.
2)Cooldown reduction/removal:
The old system of cooldowns worked pretty well with different raids having different cooldowns. It added an extra dimension to planning raid schedules and which raid to attempt. No idea why the cooldowns need to be reduced to 30 mins.
Other changes which I feel could be tweaked but are not major issues for me:
3)Capped mercs
Agreed that mercs should be capped but I would suggest that it be a function of expected raiders instead of a fixed number. Tight cap: max of 20% mercs of targeted balance number, Loose cap: max of 50% mercs of targeted balance number. Doesn't give guilds running VG/GK much of an incentive to merc if just 10 raiders. Just a matter of preference though. I am not strongly against having a fixed cap of 10.
4)Raid cap raised to 100 members
I'm a bit on the fence as to whether we need such a big increase. If Venan still feels the need for a raid cap, would suggest putting the cap to about 1.5x targeted balance number for each raid.
5)Targeted balance numbers for each raid and wave rebalancing
The old system of small increases in required raiders for higher tier raids was perfect. It made raids feel different and everyone had their favorite raid. I'm not sure if putting 30 for all Soldier raids is a good idea. Here is my take on what I feel the numbers should be: (haven't done CV raids so not suggesting anything)
10 Raiders: Gobblin' Goblins
15 Raiders: The Plaguerider
17 Raiders: Lockbolt's Reign
22 Raiders: Wrath of the Overseer
22 Raiders: Risen from the Depths
20 Raiders: Crypt of Corruption
25 Raiders: Attack at Dawn
30 Raiders: Dark Lord Helion
30 Raiders: Cursed Keep
35 Raiders: Vale of the Ice Dragon
35 Raiders: War of Fellmarsh
1)Removal of FS and SC:
Raid content, however unpopular, should be maintained. Perhaps some adjustments could be made to length or payoffs to make them a tad more attractive. But taking away 2 raids outright just seems a waste of time and effort on the devs part and new raiders would miss out on potential content. So please keep SC and FS. You can tweak them later on if still not satisfied but for now let new raiders experience them as they were before please.
2)Cooldown reduction/removal:
The old system of cooldowns worked pretty well with different raids having different cooldowns. It added an extra dimension to planning raid schedules and which raid to attempt. No idea why the cooldowns need to be reduced to 30 mins.
Other changes which I feel could be tweaked but are not major issues for me:
3)Capped mercs
Agreed that mercs should be capped but I would suggest that it be a function of expected raiders instead of a fixed number. Tight cap: max of 20% mercs of targeted balance number, Loose cap: max of 50% mercs of targeted balance number. Doesn't give guilds running VG/GK much of an incentive to merc if just 10 raiders. Just a matter of preference though. I am not strongly against having a fixed cap of 10.
4)Raid cap raised to 100 members
I'm a bit on the fence as to whether we need such a big increase. If Venan still feels the need for a raid cap, would suggest putting the cap to about 1.5x targeted balance number for each raid.
5)Targeted balance numbers for each raid and wave rebalancing
The old system of small increases in required raiders for higher tier raids was perfect. It made raids feel different and everyone had their favorite raid. I'm not sure if putting 30 for all Soldier raids is a good idea. Here is my take on what I feel the numbers should be: (haven't done CV raids so not suggesting anything)
10 Raiders: Gobblin' Goblins
15 Raiders: The Plaguerider
17 Raiders: Lockbolt's Reign
22 Raiders: Wrath of the Overseer
22 Raiders: Risen from the Depths
20 Raiders: Crypt of Corruption
25 Raiders: Attack at Dawn
30 Raiders: Dark Lord Helion
30 Raiders: Cursed Keep
35 Raiders: Vale of the Ice Dragon
35 Raiders: War of Fellmarsh