Book of Heroes

Update 1.6.1 - May 23, 2013 · page 7

My major gripes with the 1.6.1:

1)Removal of FS and SC:
Raid content, however unpopular, should be maintained. Perhaps some adjustments could be made to length or payoffs to make them a tad more attractive. But taking away 2 raids outright just seems a waste of time and effort on the devs part and new raiders would miss out on potential content. So please keep SC and FS. You can tweak them later on if still not satisfied but for now let new raiders experience them as they were before please.

2)Cooldown reduction/removal:
The old system of cooldowns worked pretty well with different raids having different cooldowns. It added an extra dimension to planning raid schedules and which raid to attempt. No idea why the cooldowns need to be reduced to 30 mins.


Other changes which I feel could be tweaked but are not major issues for me:
3)Capped mercs
Agreed that mercs should be capped but I would suggest that it be a function of expected raiders instead of a fixed number. Tight cap: max of 20% mercs of targeted balance number, Loose cap: max of 50% mercs of targeted balance number. Doesn't give guilds running VG/GK much of an incentive to merc if just 10 raiders. Just a matter of preference though. I am not strongly against having a fixed cap of 10.

4)Raid cap raised to 100 members
I'm a bit on the fence as to whether we need such a big increase. If Venan still feels the need for a raid cap, would suggest putting the cap to about 1.5x targeted balance number for each raid.

5)Targeted balance numbers for each raid and wave rebalancing
The old system of small increases in required raiders for higher tier raids was perfect. It made raids feel different and everyone had their favorite raid. I'm not sure if putting 30 for all Soldier raids is a good idea. Here is my take on what I feel the numbers should be: (haven't done CV raids so not suggesting anything)

10 Raiders: Gobblin' Goblins
15 Raiders: The Plaguerider
17 Raiders: Lockbolt's Reign
22 Raiders: Wrath of the Overseer

22 Raiders: Risen from the Depths
20 Raiders: Crypt of Corruption
25 Raiders: Attack at Dawn
30 Raiders: Dark Lord Helion

30 Raiders: Cursed Keep
35 Raiders: Vale of the Ice Dragon
35 Raiders: War of Fellmarsh
Darkhorse wrote:Before someone asks, because I know it will come up. Yes we are aware there are some players who preferred the new capped raids for a challenge. We will most likely revisit this idea in the future, but in a much more limited capacity and not in a "broad game sweeping changes" way ;). Think "challenge raids". Again no promises, just being a bit more transparent about our thought process.

One reason the removed Raid caps looked good to me, is that they removed the coercive "you MUST raid"-element from guild membetship. It looked like it'd make it socially feasible for a casual player to be permanently in a guild.
A few thoughts.. Pls dont rush the 1.6.1

1. Removal of FS and SC
If it happens, with all due respect, I am truly happy I did have a chance to have a less focused KV raiding experience... Enough ppl said about FS (which is a solid raid) so I have to speak for SC I guess.. Why ditching one of only two existing full onslaught raids is a mystery to me.. Granted, SC is not very popular, but so are, for example, physical resistance gems, and so what? Less variety & choices are not exactly "focused experience".. Hundreds of players were and still moaning about lack of content.. and what do we get, less content?
These two raids can stay auxiliary / standalone, not being prerequisite for other raids or guilds progress in general.
Finally, I suspect 1.7 might add more raids, but then why remove these two now in a rush, and not in 1.7?

2. Cooldown timers.
Always believed them to be a direct analogy of energy regeneration concept, just the other way around. 30 min cooldown seems disastrous and paired with 100 cap/ 10 mercs cap is likely lead to non stop zerg raiding by major guilds and death of minor 20-30 ppl guilds..
Actually, why raids have individual cooldowns? Perhaps it makes sense that a guild has a sort of slowly regenerating guild energy bar, and the energy could be spent on any raid..

3. Caps.
Mercs caps in particular.. They just shouldnt be there and the number of mercs allowed is better left to the guild's discretion since there is already a general cap. 100 general cap seems too generous - see above. OK, perhaps its worth trying another extreme (from very tight cap to effectively no cap) but Im sure there is going to be 1.6.2 soon...
thanks for 1.6.1! it seems great fix.
I love karnak payouts increased. this way it might become energy per cv worthy (compared to vg for example) also for players under 30k might and guilds will have more motivation to run this raid (eg not just for power increase)

targeted raiders numbers to my opinion should increase more smoothly and not by jumps between valor tier raids. say kraken should require less raiders than zuur.

I love cooldown reduce time and 100 raiders cap! it gives us more freedom to raid based only by participation and free time. ok so hj will hit 10m power in a week, but who cares, anyway they probably stay first in nearest future and I have absolutely no problems with it (lol I hope my gm doesn't read it ;) )

while I don't really care about fs as just another regular kv raid, I would like to see sc around. its more unique. and it fills onslaught hole for kv tier (lol u can convert fs to sqv onslaught to cover all tiers ;))

I think as was said before theres no need in mercs tight cap. mercs didn't finished raids in 1.5 without guild main participation it's not gonna happen in 1.6.1. mercs r just too random and not organized to do it. but some merc cap should exist to encourage guilds to run raids and not jump mercing

just a idea about content. we have a few essence drop in some cv raids along with valor and ht, but even more in portal because portals r only about essence.
can we have something specialized for hero token only? with more ht than in raid but without cv silver etc. just as another farming option (currently end game player can farm shards for karnak ring (to max one piece of gear) or gems , cv + ht in raids (to max gear gems hero training loyalty), flux/essence in portal (to max enchants)). last remaining thing is hero training which doesn't have dedicated source of farming (coc doesn't count at least I don't believe venan designed it for this purpose for end game players)

Lovin_Spoon_Full

Fri May 17, 2013 6:12 am
Ferocee wrote:Save the bogqueen!

No need for a double Trask phases on WoF replace the last with the Bogqueen!

^^ !!

Removing her is simply unthinkable!!!!!

*calls out* "Boggy, my love! Fear not, I shall fight for you 'til the bitter end!! Keep your chins up!"

And speaking of unthinkable -- you are removing useful, unbroken raids in an enjoyable but content-anemic game for a "more seemless experience?" Huh?? Tell me this is a belated April fool's joke. If content is to be sacrificed for a more seemless experience (cover your ears, Boggy), why not trim the fat more and reduce it to one raid per valor type. Yah, that'd be tight, indeed.

KuroYukiHime

ModeratorFri May 17, 2013 7:00 am
Darkhorse wrote:

Guilds
  • Added a guild objective for defeating Karnak 100 times
  • Added a guild objective for unlocking Karnak's Final Stand (You must defeat War of Fellmarsh 10 times)
  • Some guild objectives have been deprecated (see raids)
  • Players will now lose 50% of their guild loyalty when joining a new guild (lowered from 100%)
Raids
  • The raid cap for all raids has been raised to 100 members!
  • With the change to all raid caps, some raids have had their number of waves adjusted. Here is the approximate number of raiders we have balanced each raid around (regardless of the targeted balance number, the raid cap will still be 100 guild members for each raid):
    • 10 Raiders: Gobblin' Goblins
    • 20 Raiders: The Plaguerider, Lockbolt's Reign
    • 25 Raiders: Wrath of the Overseer
    • 30 Raiders: Risen from the Depths, Crypt of Corruption, Attack at Dawn, Dark Lord Helion
    • 35 Raiders: Cursed Keep, Vale of the Ice Dragon, War of Fellmarsh
    • 40 Raiders: Horde of the Goblin King, Karnak's Final Stand, Battle of the Vile Gate
  • All raids have had the number of mercenaries capped at 10 (with the exception of Gobblin' Goblins which is set to 5)
  • The Shadow Comes and Forgotten Sentinels have been removed from the game!
  • The might requirement for War of Fellmarsh has been lowered to 9150 might to accomodate the might gap left by the removal of Forgotten Sentinels
  • The cooldown on all raids has been reduced to 30 minutes (after completion of the raid)
  • Raid finder will now display all raids, not just those with open mercenary slots. However, only raids with mercenary slots open will be joinable
  • The valor and hero token reward pool for Karnak's Final Stand has been raised

First of all, excellent work and efforts there developers! :) hope u can release the update quicker. We all love a surprise after all :)

As for the content of the update, I have some thoughts/suggestions:
1. Don't take my BOG QUEEN! :( She is one of the best graphic momon aside from Behemoth!! We'll really miss her!
2. The increase of cap is greatly appreciated though I hope it's not 100 :( too many.. The challenge is somehow disappear! No need to take it into that extent. 50-60 should be more than enough. Those who can't manage that are simply have managerial issues to fix!
3. The decrease in merc slot is really great btw. Keep it up devs! ;)

One final suggestion, as u guys already aware, there won't be a perfect system for all to enjoy. However, u should reward those who work, think, and manage harder and smarter than others! No need to spoil those who don't want to put more efforts and can only complain. People must be taught to adapt to changes, don't they?! It's how the world work in the real life. Cheers
You can test the theory of how popular FS is by keeping the raid, but skipping it in the guild "chain". In other words 10 Valluses (Valli?) unlock FS and WoF.

Merc caps could be a problem for growing guilds that have dedicated and casual raiders mixed together. Not only will a guild now not be able to run raids for their highest might players, merc slots will be even harder to find.

One option: Available merc slots start at a maximum of 10, and increase with each hour (20 mercs available after 1hr, 30 after 2hr). This allows the thrill of swooping in to save a guild's raid from failing without making gold trivial for small guilds.

I still think the best way to distinguish gold is by how much you can kill, not how fast you can kill.

Hashtag_QueenPippin

Fri May 17, 2013 9:29 am
I haven't been able to run shadow comes yet successfully! Merced it once before the update and loved it but it was just too long. FS wasn't so bad either! My guildies would have loved it! There needs to be another kv raid between ck and vallus might. My guildies love onslaught! CoC is one of our favorites!

If u wanna know which raid everyone would be happy to see y'all get rid of is WoF! That raid is torture! 5 LONG phases of hell!! Keep FS and kill WoF! It's ridiculous! We got gold once but the top 5 had at least 30k rpp and went thru at least $20 worth of shields. That's with between 25-30 participants too. It's painful! Would love to see that raid die lol

An onslaught dungeon would be a nice addition since I view most dungeons as practice for raids in that zone but there's no dungeon to practice onslaught. Maybe a lower one to practice for CoC and a higher one for Karnak practice.

Please kill WoF or make it less painful! That raid will be the death of me!

Darkhorse

Site AdminFri May 17, 2013 10:18 am
By popular demand, phase 3 of WoF has been changed to include everyone's favorite queen...

Little_Mike

Site AdminFri May 17, 2013 10:30 am
Frankly, the reason why the merc caps are set to 10 for this iteration is because we want to see how everything plays out with the new 100 man cap. Having a large merc cap makes it easy for an organized group of players to overman a raid. We will look at the numbers and make adjustments as necessary after this goes live.