Book of Heroes

Armor Pen- Enchant, increase % per Rank

Any chance of hoping armor penetration will be buffed a bit? It'd be nice to have some purpose for the enchant other than being a poor version of the 1h/2h... Even at like 1.2% per level, it'd start being a very viable pvp option.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sat May 18, 2013 5:08 pm
Tennis (Or do I call you Eric now? Old habits die hard! :D )
Currently we have no idea how PvP will work. And in my opinion when it does come out it may look very different from what you and I are familiar with regarding game mechanics.
That being said, to speculate on how AP will work in PvP at this point is mere conjecture and most likely inaccurate.

My point is there is no reason to ask for AP tuning at this point, with regard to PvP, because PvP will most likely not work the way your mind thinks it will.

I have posted more of my thoughts on the limitations of trying to imagine PvP under current conditions here:

The Player versus Player (PvP) Pipe Dream!
Mithrid wrote:Tennis (Or do I call you Eric now? Old habits die hard! :D )
Currently we have no idea how PvP will work. And in my opinion when it does come out it may look very different from what you and I are familiar with regarding game mechanics.
That being said, to speculate on how AP will work in PvP at this point is mere conjecture and most likely inaccurate.

My point is there is no reason to ask for AP tuning at this point, with regard to PvP, because PvP will most likely not work the way your mind thinks it will.

I have posted more of my thoughts on the limitations of trying to imagine PvP under current conditions here:

The Player versus Player (PvP) Pipe Dream!

Tennis, tc, Eric, they all work. Your post was an excellent read mith.

However let me amend my post to just buffing armor pen in general.

Typically if the defense range of enemies in BoH range from 0-60, lets say, I would have hoped with the way armor pen works, the breakeven point vs. 1h/2h would have been closer to the mean defense of a creature, providing us with a choice between more damage vs, less armored creatures or more damage vs. heavily armored creatures (based off 1h/2h). The current system makes armor pen virtually useless except maybe vs. Lob, and even then the diff is so slight, it isn't worth using. I guess I fail to see the purpose of the enchant in that case.

As useless as some may seem, I can think up scenarios hypothetically where I'd want to use nearly every other enchant.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sat May 18, 2013 6:53 pm
Fizz_Eric wrote:
The current system makes armor pen virtually useless except maybe vs. Lob, and even then the diff is so slight, it isn't worth using. I guess I fail to see the purpose of the enchant in that case.

Sadly, I couldn't agree more. I've tested L6 AP against L6 2H on LoB and the 2H actually averaged better damage (granted over only around 20 waves of data collection, and not counting hits when Vile Ward was in place...that may make a difference but I wanted consistent factors using base LoB).

I would be curious how well AP would work against the Scarabs with "Hardened Shell", that may actually have possibility (haven't tested yet); but outside of that, I consider AP a useless enchant at the moment.
Fizz_Eric wrote: I guess I fail to see the purpose of the enchant in that case.

It is given to you for free. Venan wants you to either spend the GS or do an enormous amount of farming (Mith remembers my adventure) to get the 1H/2H recipe.
Mithrid wrote:
I would be curious how well AP would work against the Scarabs with "Hardened Shell", that may actually have possibility (haven't tested yet); but outside of that, I consider AP a useless enchant at the moment.

Even if it works, I don't think you can do a decent amount of damage against "Hardened Shell" period.
2H will work better because 2H weapons have higher base damage.

AP can only be competitive with 1H even if it's buffed and only against higher armor targets.

That said, there's no reason to think 1H/2H damage is going to be significant enough of a damage increase to be useful in PVP compared to other enchants like Accuracy and Initiative.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun May 19, 2013 12:08 pm
AoW_McLovin wrote:
That said, there's no reason to think 1H/2H damage is going to be significant enough of a damage increase to be useful in PVP compared to other enchants like Accuracy and Initiative.

I am neither going to argue or agree, at the end of the day I am still very curious as to what the exact mechanics will be for PvP, before I begin to speculate on the respective usefulness of enchants.

The reason i say this is that Venan to their credit has created a very broad game with all kinds of toon customization possibilities, (look at all the choices for optimizing your toon, resists, AP, Initiative, various damage enchants, dodge versus crit versus haste, etc)... however, the games goals and actual playing have created a situation where everyone can name on 3 fingers the most important metrics to beat others in a raid (Haste, Dmg, Crit).

To Create a PvP were every option for tuning/customizing a toon can have a great impact on performance, without unbalancing the system, is very difficult. I expect that in PvP, if true to history, players will discern relatively quickly which enchants and stats work the best and which are useless. (just like what we have no in raids and high-end questing).