Book of Heroes

Mercing blacklist- Guilds

Hello there fellow mercenaries!

You might be aware that, as of now, mercs in BoH are one of the most unprotected social classes :D
Every mercenary (both pre 1.6 and now) has been in a situation where you hop into a raid with the other guild dumping all E (a few times), even using E pots, just to find this guild unable to finish the raid. So you basically sell your energy, potions and time for some damn silver.

It got worse with 1.6, because now the guild gets something even if the raid was a failure: they get loyalty points. I've recently joined a raid with some guild just to find a message in their chat an hour later: "So, guys, we don't have to actually finish this one - doing it only for loyalty points. So don't bother". And that was said in a raid with 10 merc slots already occupied by mercenaries!!!
I've proposed some changes to amend this system here: Mercing - some suggestions on 1.6
But the devs are busy, and chances are nobody will notice my suggestions at all, so here's the deal:

Let's start our own "Mercing Blacklist" here and now, so that mercs that do read forums won't get their energy wasted for nothing.

Report template:
1. Guild name (hosting the raid)
2. Raid name
3. Who started raid (guild member nickname - as seen in report) and when did it start.
4. Your RPP
5. Results

i.e.:
1. Juv raids
2. CoC
3. Tybeerus, 3:35:11AM GMT
4. 9775, placed 3rd
5. Failure: 12 participants - 10 mercs, 2 members. Wasn't even close: most mercs abandoned the raid due to lack of input from guild members.
good luck on that.

a better solution would probably be to let mercs start their own raid somehow. with the changes in 1.6, i don't see why raids need to be only started by guilds.
Fizz_Boozard wrote:good luck on that.

a better solution would probably be to let mercs start their own raid somehow. with the changes in 1.6, i don't see why raids need to be only started by guilds.
Raiding is a guild feauture - I'm ok with that: lets you earn +8 max E while you farm silver/valor. Sometimes your guild doesn't run the raid you want/can join for some time (or different schedule/time zone, or for some other reason) - and that's the time to join as a mercenary. Problem is some retarded guilds think that starting a raid with 2 guild members on and with 10 merc slots open is something funny. It's not and there should be a restriction/punishment system for that, but untill then we can only share our bad experience with each other so that others won't jump into a raid of a guild with irresponsible GM/officers.
How about look before you join a raid with only 2 guild participants and 10 merc slots with 45 min left in the bronze time? I have only had one or two times where a guild I merc'd with failed to complete the raid, and that was because there werent very many mercs and everyone was out of energy, not because members didnt show up. Granted, there have been a few guild raids of mine that failed because people said they would be on and didnt show till the last phase, but that happens with real life. Besides, you can't black list a guild or merc from hosting or joining raids, there just isnt a feature for that. Some people need to learn to read the stats on a raid before joining, and others need to learn that when you make a commitment to a raid and take a slot, you should contribute as much as you can, after all that could cause a raid to fail. Yes, I know sometimes raids have a high percent of the raid completed, a fair number of participants, and can still fail because everyone logs off to do other things and no one finishes the raid, it happens and it sucks. But you get a much higher completion chance if you look at the stats on a raid: Completion %, number of guildies / mercs, time left (gold, silver, bronze). Don't join a raid with a low completion % that has bronze time left on it or only 3 guildies and 4 mercs. Guidlines like that would help more than a blacklist of guilds or mercs. Maybe someone could come up with a guide for picking a raid to join, I kinda shoot from the hip on % vs time left vs participants (guildies weighing more value than mercs) and see if it would be worth my energy / time to chance a failure vs a completion.
I understanf and agree with what people have written here but recenetly have come across a guild who x2 now has shown to start a raid 18 members on and 7 of 10 mercs, jump in only to see 15 min later the guild post in chat opening up a second raid. Noe before you go saying its to send notifications to other user its not within the next 10 or 15 minutes you will see the drop off and no one comes back, chat is dead so yeah. Got bronze both times and swore i woukd never join their raids again
Without some way to post a note on raid startup about the guild's intentions, this is indeed a challenge. Our own guild runs almost constant GG and PR raids just for Guild Loyalty, and not all those may finish. We never open slots on the GG raid, but do open them on the PR raid. We always make those slots password protected though so if, into the raid, we see we can finish it, but will need that little extra help, we can advertise it in global with the disclaimer and the password. It's the best approach I can think of given the current scenario.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jun 6, 2013 2:45 pm
How about look before you join a raid with only 2 guild participants and 10 merc slots with 45 min left in the bronze time? I have only had one or two times where a guild I merc'd with failed to complete the raid, and that was because there werent very many mercs and everyone was out of energy, not because members didnt show up. Granted, there have been a few guild raids of mine that failed because people said they would be on and didnt show till the last phase, but that happens with real life. Besides, you can't black list a guild or merc from hosting or joining raids, there just isnt a feature for that. Some people need to learn to read the stats on a raid before joining, and others need to learn that when you make a commitment to a raid and take a slot, you should contribute as much as you can, after all that could cause a raid to fail. Yes, I know sometimes raids have a high percent of the raid completed, a fair number of participants, and can still fail because everyone logs off to do other things and no one finishes the raid, it happens and it sucks. But you get a much higher completion chance if you look at the stats on a raid: Completion %, number of guildies / mercs, time left (gold, silver, bronze). Don't join a raid with a low completion % that has bronze time left on it or only 3 guildies and 4 mercs. Guidlines like that would help more than a blacklist of guilds or mercs. Maybe someone could come up with a guide for picking a raid to join, I kinda shoot from the hip on % vs time left vs participants (guildies weighing more value than mercs) and see if it would be worth my energy / time to chance a failure vs a completion.

Agree with Spartanmerc completely, good advice. Personally I find the attempt to create merc/guild blacklists counter-productive and not in the spirit of the game.
Denrael wrote:Without some way to post a note on raid startup about the guild's intentions, this is indeed a challenge. Our own guild runs almost constant GG and PR raids just for Guild Loyalty, and not all those may finish. We never open slots on the GG raid, but do open them on the PR raid. We always make those slots password protected though so if, into the raid, we see we can finish it, but will need that little extra help, we can advertise it in global with the disclaimer and the password. It's the best approach I can think of given the current scenario.
You can keep all slots closed from the start and then open them at any time during the raid to allow mercs to join, the advertisment in general chat is good though, that way people might know what it is.
Hope_Ilyana wrote:Agree with Spartanmerc completely, good advice. Personally I find the attempt to create merc/guild blacklists counter-productive and not in the spirit of the game.
Thank you, I too find it disheartening when I see threads about Blacklists, sometimes people have an off night and don't want to or can't get back to the raid, that's no reason to ban them from ever having a chance. Same with guilds. Personaly I think the PW protected raids are the best option, but luckily I don't think people will have an issue raiding again anytime soon with that last patch. :D