Book of Heroes

Mega Topic: Low RPP Mercs/ Mercs Trapped in Raids · page 15

Reporting option seems a good idea to me. Ejection would probably be too open to abuse.
But SOME resolution is needed as it causes massive ill will. Only excuse is rl, so people should make the effort to apologize, even afterwards, if it's an internet problem.

Knights_Snowflake

Thu Mar 19, 2015 8:27 am
+1 I totally agree! GM and officers should be able to boot non hitters from any raid. Thank you Izy for taking the time to start this up!
Venan has always felt that this option being available to GM could potentially be misused. As for giving that power to CHAT mods...no. They are in place to keep CHAT rules, not make decisions about gameplay. I dont know what a good solution is, but i can pretty much guarantee this is thinking of the devs at this point. I really like the idea of booting the skunks but as for implimentation ...not sure how.

Im sure the devs dont want to be on-call 24/7 to deal with this sort of reporting/kicking process either.
The need for this has been talked about for a long time and would be fairly easy to set up. +1
Fluffy_Dragøñ wrote:
Though I must say, raids don't fail because of a couple of skunks. Don't expect mercs to be the difference between finishing and failing.

That's not entirely true, the higher raids say... Kraken, AaD, CoC... if you have a couple 'Bottom Feeders' that could very well make your raid fail.
I completely agree with everything else though. 1) kick out option 2) blacklist 3) restrictions

Although I blinked when seeing AAD and Kraken described as "higher raids", the SolVal thru to CapVal (GK and VG anyway, people jump on KFS for HS) seem to suffer completion issues sometimes - esp after an event with the raid slowdown.
Mercs can very well make or break those raids for guilds who are hitting one of these at their top-end. 15 mercs dropping 25 hits + regen each is almost a full phase in itself. 5 of those mercs dropping <5 hits and leaving is a massive blow at this range. These raids don't have the burners they did when they were top-end, and the longer a raid takes, the more people drop out, and it goes even slower, until there's a handful of people left trying to save Bronze.
It's easy to say "you shouldn't run raids you can't do in-guild" but if you run it, get decent mercs, and Gold or Silver it, of course you're gonna run it again! Then you get skunked and wonder what the hell happened...
Believe or not, I have a couple of thoughts...#1-Ilyana is absolutely correct in saying you should not depend on mercs to complete your raids. If you open, it still remains the sole responsibility of guildies to finish. Honestly, there is nothing wrong with a silver or even a bronze finish once in a while, just finish! #2- Probably the only way to make sure skunks cease this practice is to not allow rewards to start until a certain RPP is achieved and then retro back to first hit, say 3475...full bar. Once you hit that, all rewards take place.
The best way to insure you have quality mercs is to password and give only to those, true friends/mercs, that always give there all...not only in RPP, but also in good chat. There are many out there. Start that list! :)
Lord_Garic wrote:#2- Probably the only way to make sure skunks cease this practice is to not allow rewards to start until a certain RPP is achieved and then retro back to first hit, say 3475...full bar. Once you hit that, all rewards take place.

Just on this point, the "target" would have to vary with raid. 3475 is fine for CapVal upwards when most people have 50e, but below that it could be a bit high?
Also, the feat for "Take Part in X Raids" could be tweaked to require a min number of hits, perhaps mapped to the above. A bunch of 1-hitters at low level are chasing these feats.

Drèádñåûght_Jîñglë___Jûñk

Thu Mar 19, 2015 9:50 am
Agreed!be nice to have some kind of penalty for parkers/campers
Nice catch DD...although 3475 could be hit over the course of any raid...I do believe you caught the real reason for skunks, outside of phase two of PM being too difficult for some, the feat of "Take part in X raids" should be based on a minimum RPP for it to count. By the way, Love your posts! :D