I miss Kronaz.... He was awesome
Mega Topic: Low RPP Mercs/ Mercs Trapped in Raids · page 16
We shall call this "The Barooen Initiative"
We shall call this "The Barooen Initiative"
+1
Getting real sick of the obvious, intentional deadweights I keep seeing in raids. And I agree with Garic's suggestion as well .
Getting real sick of the obvious, intentional deadweights I keep seeing in raids. And I agree with Garic's suggestion as well .
gem_dragondreamer wrote:Reporting option seems a good idea to me. Ejection would probably be too open to abuse.
But SOME resolution is needed as it causes massive ill will. Only excuse is rl, so people should make the effort to apologize, even afterwards, if it's an internet problem.
If ejected unfairly, one could always chose to blacklist the guild in future. Guilds will reap what they sow in that regard.
If you rely on mercs to not fail, you are not truly ready for the raid, but difference in valor is often decided by mercs at lower levels where numbers are low.
I would add a request to add an ability to withdraw, for those times when RL does suddenly intervene.
Lord_Garic wrote:Believe or not, I have a couple of thoughts...#1-Ilyana is absolutely correct in saying you should not depend on mercs to complete your raids. If you open, it still remains the sole responsibility of guildies to finish. Honestly, there is nothing wrong with a silver or even a bronze finish once in a while, just finish! #2- Probably the only way to make sure skunks cease this practice is to not allow rewards to start until a certain RPP is achieved and then retro back to first hit, say 3475...full bar. Once you hit that, all rewards take place.
Really good idea. Level should be set by raid, rising with raid level. I would not apply it in final phases though, and only to non-guild Raiders.
I say -1 (just because Ily said +1) jk
This has been discussed at length elsewhere, so I'll leave it at that. I do think it's a good idea (especially the blacklist). Problem with PW raids is you want mercs and there are good mercs that you don't know. How do you get new mercs if mercs can't just drop in?
This has been discussed at length elsewhere, so I'll leave it at that. I do think it's a good idea (especially the blacklist). Problem with PW raids is you want mercs and there are good mercs that you don't know. How do you get new mercs if mercs can't just drop in?
Can't everyone get a merc rating? Like it's based on your average rpp for non guild raids? Bronze, silver and gold maybe. Like if u average 1080 rpp that's bronze. Then maybe u could set ur raid to only accept like silver and above.
Ñütèllå_Wølf_ôf_Dréâms wrote:Can't everyone get a merc rating? Like it's based on your average rpp for non guild raids? Bronze, silver and gold maybe. Like if u average 1080 rpp that's bronze. Then maybe u could set ur raid to only accept like silver and above.
Although it'd have to be more complex than avg RPP = rating band, the idea of a rating per toon has a lot of merit.
It'd need a lot of thought to account for new players, various raids having various 'acceptable' RPP averages, MVP GG raids etc - but as a concept, yeah. You could open your raid and specify number of mercs as normal, with default rating of Silver, with the option to only accept Gold / Platinum if you prefer, or to allow Bronze (open to all).
I thought some sort of rating based on an average would be more fair since we all get pulled away sometimes in the middle of a raid. Maybe it can be like PVP where u needed a certain number of matches before u get a rank. Maybe you need at least ten raids to get your first rating. I will have to discuss this with my friend Bob Venan. He owns book of heros.