Drathnar wrote:
Most graphs appear to be more or less a random scatter.
MY PERSONAL OPINION
The two biggest factors in your data set are a) Elite Player Fatigue and b) Venan adjusting the Raid Ladder.
Celestrial Beings is the first Guild I think of when the topic of Elite Player Fatigue comes up in Global Chat or the Forums, followed by Black Lotus both where hard raiding Guilds when v1.3 came out. Some players just play BoH as hard as they can, do everything, then leave. Maybe coming back with the next update. This can negatively affect older Guilds, though not always. This is also why Venan has a Power (decays) and Prestige (no decay) leaderboard for Guilds. So older Guilds still can show off their high Prestige, while newer Guilds can show off their high Power.
Research Note: Prestige does not decay. But since it includes a percentage of each member's Might Rating, sudden shifts in membership can cause a sharp rise or fall in total Guild Prestige.
Venan has adjusted the Raid Ladder serveral times. Originally, Raids were 2- 6 hour, cool downs were longer, you had to complete much larger multiples of each Raid to unlock the next Raid, you had to complete Forgotten Sentinels to unlock War of Fellmarsh, 1% of Raid Power was not added to Presitige, there was no Gold or Silver finish, you could not buy Tier 11 Gear and Tier 4 Gems at Majerio's Shop, there were no Captain Valor Raids (with their very high XP, Power and Prestige), there was no +10% Bonus for 0% Mercs in a Raid, there was no +10% Valor for Raids hosted by your Guild.
Each time Venan has adjusted the Raid Ladder, Raid Rewards and Majerio's Shop, it is easier and faster (less Real World Time per Raid, less days before unlocking a Raid) for a Guild to get to into a better paying Raid (higher XP, Power, and Prestige). Allowing them to catch up, and even pass, older guilds.