Book of Heroes

SW build for KFS. Help needed · page 3

My magic and melee are the same. 1052 with mod 1183. 7111/7111 magic/melee. Not sure which numbers you were looking for.
Tiffy wrote:
BaneFirerises wrote:My build
Stats-(hero training stats)

Melee-400(224)
Magic-999(568)
Crit-40.51%(832)
Crit power-188.63%(520)
Defence-41.92%
Physical resist-1.67%(176)
Magic resist-1.67%(176)
Dodge-29.22%(328)
Haste-42.04%(968)

Abilities

Toxic blade 3
Caltrops 1
Ensnare 1
Poison cloud 3
Maneuver 3
Assassinate 3
Reflexive strike 3
Acid spray 3
Riposte 3
Neurotoxin 3
Urgency 1
Corrosive blades 3

Enchantments

Nature-level 5x2, level 4x1
One hand-level 5x1, level 4x2
Defence-level 4x3

I have 24k might and decent stats but still have a hard time with p2 and p3 KFS. I don't want a completely new build but willing to make changes if it helps with KFS. Any tips on strategy or build would be most helpful.

Thank you in advance.

Ur crit and crit power looks good, you need to focus on your magic stat and haste. I think you haven't max out your dodge hero training and look no where near maxing it. My dodge is 27% without maneuver and any gems (pure hero training).

As for your abilities, I think you can take 1 point off from reflexive strike and put it in Smoke bomb. SB is useful for reducing your ability Cooldown and delay enemies attack. So buy you time to kill enemies before getting too many hits.


Thanks for sharing your build Tiffy.
I think my main problem is my stats are too low. Should I leave my build as it is for now as I work on maxing some of my hero training stats?

I want to add PS + crit eye which is gonna be 6 points and I want 1 point on SB. Removing RS will give me 3 points but where do you think I should get the other 4 points from?

Between one hand enchantment and nature enchantment, which is more important for SW?
BaneFirerises wrote:

Melee-400(224)
Magic-999(568)
Crit-40.51%(832)
Crit power-188.63%(520)
Defence-41.92%
Physical resist-1.67%(176)
Magic resist-1.67%(176)
Dodge-29.22%(328)
Haste-42.04%(968)

Abilities

Toxic blade 3
Caltrops 1
Ensnare 1
Poison cloud 3
Maneuver 3
Assassinate 3
Reflexive strike 3
Acid spray 3
Riposte 3
Neurotoxin 3
Urgency 1
Corrosive blades 3

1H and Nature enchant are both important to a Poison SW

I think you can take your 1 point from Urgency.
Take 3 points off from RS
May be take 1 point off from CB

Little trick to trigger CB, using basic attack as first attack can easily trigger CB but only on one target ( I think it's becoz basic attack is doing 2 attacks - main hand and off hand attack, so better chance to poison than using other attack), or use caltrops to poison your enemies , with chance of poisoning more than 1 target.
Hybridized my build with Tiffy's to try out today... worked decently well (averaged 2100-2250 with haste n might elixir):

3110 (Caltrops as a throw away point)
3330 (Getting used to life without assassinate... VG is going to be a tad tougher for a short while until my ht compensates)
0333 (Riposte is nice I'll admit.... but I don't like using 6 pts on it + urgency. Need to do a speed analysis for karnak and see which is theoretically better and how many points)
1330 (Smoke Bomb doesn't need more than a point since CDs are all under 0.50 seconds w/haste elix, Corrosive... I agree with Tiffy-- i can live without)

But the Urgency/Riposte thing I don't like. Feels a bit of a waste.





Don't read the rest unless bored and feel like proofchecking.
--------
****Rough number calcs
At 16% dodge (where I was before gems), Urgency had a ~25.2% of proc'ing upon enemy attack. With 44% dodge now, Urgency is down to a 16.8% chance, and Riposte is up to 26.4% chance... So effectively a 43.2% chance of one or the other proc'ing. I assume we can say the expected value of a riposte is ~50% cast speed for any particular attack. Therefore, since I have 50% haste (with elixir), it's effectively +25% haste for duration of [average spell time/2]. Empirically (with a low sample size) my average spell time is 0.48 seconds, so I get the following:

Option A (16% dodge):
Urgency - 3 points - 25.2% chance of +15% haste for 2 seconds.

vs.

Option B (44% dodge):
Urgency - 3 points - 16.8% chance of +15% haste for 2 seconds.
Riposte - 3 points - 26.4% chance of double haste (25%) for 0.24 seconds.
Riposte while Urgency Proc'd - 1.95% chance of 1-[(1-[haste%+15%])/2] haste for 0.12 seconds


Option A: For 100 seconds of cast time, 50.4 seconds of 65% haste, 49.6 seconds of 50% haste
Option B: For 100 seconds of cast time, 33.6 seconds of 65% haste, 6.34 seconds of 75% haste, 0.23 seconds of 82.5% haste, 59.83 seconds of 50% haste

or simplified - Option A is ~121.6 seconds of casting per 100 seconds. Option B is ~121.2 seconds of casting per 100 seconds.

--------
AKA... after all that.... there's no virtual difference between the two (provided low dodge doesn't kill you). Looking at it like that... I'd rather just switch back and invest the three points back in Assassinate once I beef up my def/resists a bit.


Though what's interesting is... if we're not using an elixir of haste, and sitting at 35% haste...

Option A: For 100 seconds of cast time, 50.4 seconds of 50% haste, 49.6 seconds of 35% haste
Option B: For 100 seconds of cast time, 33.6 seconds of 50% haste, 8.24 seconds of 67.5% haste, 0.3 seconds of 75% haste, 57.84 seconds of 35% haste

or simplified - Option A is ~115.1 seconds of casting per 100 seconds. Option B is ~118.05 seconds of casting per 100 seconds.

--------


For everyone who chose to ignore all that... 3 points in Riposte + Urgency ends up saving approximately 2.56% more in game timer @ 35% haste. But by 50% haste, it ends up losing you 0.3% more in game timer.

That being said... This is completely ignoring damage. So once you lose the risk of dying in KFS, you're better off shifting out those three points elsewhere.


My calcs might be off- they're rough... but yeah.




After all this...
Tomorrow's new kfs build attempt will be:

3110
3303 (Dodge has no benefit as seen above unless karnak killing you)
1330 (No riposte for same reason as above)
1332 (Don't need corrosive... but meh... what else to invest in? RS? maybe)

Dodge- back down to 16% (wish i didn't have any ht in it)
Haste- 50% up to 54%
Crit- Remaining at 35%
Eric, I think you are doing a comparison where you are changing multiple variables at once (dodge percentage and abilities) and then reaching a conclusion about a single variable (riposte) from it which is invalid.

My assumption is that I never will use dodge gems so that isn't something I care about. Manuever is the question.

What I am interested in calculating is the advantage of riposte with a fixed dodge percentage. Too early in the morning for me to figure it out. And then a head to head of riposte versus urgency and figure out the dodge % tipping point where one is better than the other.

However, Tiffy makes a good point about dodge helping against steal weapon and also I would add ice blast.

I am just trying to figure out a way to get Assassinate and/or RS back. I have been paying attention and assassinate makes a huge difference in my real time performance on GK/VG mobs.
Bbbb wrote:Eric, I think you are doing a comparison where you are changing multiple variables at once (dodge percentage and abilities) and then reaching a conclusion about a single variable (riposte) from it which is invalid.

My assumption is that I never will use dodge gems so that isn't something I care about. Manuever is the question.

What I am interested in calculating is the advantage of riposte with a fixed dodge percentage. Too early in the morning for me to figure it out. And then a head to head of riposte versus urgency and figure out the dodge % tipping point where one is better than the other.

However, Tiffy makes a good point about dodge helping against steal weapon and also I would add ice blast.

I am just trying to figure out a way to get Assassinate and/or RS back. I have been paying attention and assassinate makes a huge difference in my real time performance on GK/VG mobs.

Yeah lol it was 2am, I was tired. Woke up, reread my post and was like oops. I'll redo it at some point.

Well when I was at 58% haste, it was quick enough with SB, runes, ensnare, or just outright kill construct that he couldn't steal weapon. Or worst case just cleanse. 50% is too slow for that. Gonna slowly inch up til I find my sweet spot.

I noticed that about assassinate too. I still am pretty reliant on it. Cuts down my VG speed by a good 15-20% at the moment.

Meh, either way this is a good thread. Gives me something to keep working at.
Tiffy,

I notice you have 3 in PS but rarely mention it in your attack patterns:

TB SB TB

TB AS

I've been rotating TB PS against bosses (after doing the initial poison and runes work). Any reason why you don't have PS in your attack pattern?

I'd love to pick up the Ripost and Urgency. I can see giving up CB, especially now that I'm becoming more comfortable with rune work, but I don't see where the other 3 would come from.

3 1 1 3
3 3 0 3
1 3 3 0
3 3 0 3

is my build. I'm still just building my trainings stats.

Melee: 672
Magic: 833
Crit: 21.78%
Crit Power: 177.1%
Defense 17.25%
Physical Resist: 5.37%
Magic Resist: 2.71%
Dodge: 21.5%
Haste 34.1%

Obviously it takes longer for me to kill which is why I'm reluctant to give up the assassinate or the ensnare as an extra interupt.
Denrael wrote:

I'd love to pick up the Ripost and Urgency. I can see giving up CB, especially now that I'm becoming more comfortable with rune work, but I don't see where the other 3 would come from.

DW unless you are pure melee it's not that useful.

Obviously it takes longer for me to kill which is why I'm reluctant to give up the assassinate or the ensnare as an extra interupt.

Unless you are high might and paying for the haste elixir, keep ensnare.
I use PS a lot,sorry i forgot to mention my attack rotation

For GK boss, AS+PS (after AS, enemy is poisined and my crit for PS will be 100%)
For VG boss, TB+PS (if still alive, finish it off with Nature Rune)

for karnsk i just rotate TB PS if SB in cooldown.
And i normally use PS to finish boss off coz i know PS is 100%CRIT. TB sucks without crit.