Book of Heroes

SW build for KFS. Help needed

My build
Stats-(hero training stats)

Melee-400(224)
Magic-999(568)
Crit-40.51%(832)
Crit power-188.63%(520)
Defence-41.92%
Physical resist-1.67%(176)
Magic resist-1.67%(176)
Dodge-29.22%(328)
Haste-42.04%(968)

Abilities

Toxic blade 3
Caltrops 1
Ensnare 1
Poison cloud 3
Maneuver 3
Assassinate 3
Reflexive strike 3
Acid spray 3
Riposte 3
Neurotoxin 3
Urgency 1
Corrosive blades 3

Enchantments

Nature-level 5x2, level 4x1
One hand-level 5x1, level 4x2
Defence-level 4x3

I have 24k might and decent stats but still have a hard time with p2 and p3 KFS. I don't want a completely new build but willing to make changes if it helps with KFS. Any tips on strategy or build would be most helpful.

Thank you in advance.
I'm still working on my KFS build for my poison SW so keep that in mind. I am avoiding going a complete overhaul to melee for both me and the OP here.

The obvious problem - you have too much haste and would get better performance with other gems. Drop it to 39.xx% and invest more into melee or magic. From looking at your build, is your 4th slots all yellow?

When I was talking to people today about my build, they said I was too magic and needed to scale back towards hybrid more, but your ability build is even more so than mine. I am going to a few melee gems instead of magic and see how much I improve. I think you have to have Piercing Strike 3.

Get Urgency to 3. Drop Caltrops.

The abilities that I think need discussion are:

[*]Ensnare - Tiffy dropped it I know. I think I want to keep it.
[*]Poison Cloud - one person told me to drop it. However, it is a DOT, would be costly for CoC, and is needed for my 2 hit kills on mobs so I am not doing that.
[*]Acid Spray - I think you gotta have at least one point here. I have 3 but is it needed? Lowering it may hurt CoC or mob kills for me in VG.
[*]Reflexive Strike - how many points? I think 1 is enough for a poison build.
[*]Corrosive Blades - I have 3 but I could be talked into dropping it or going 1-2. Thinking this over
[*]Maneuver - there is a debate about this. Some people (who I side with) are against because it lowers your urgency chance.
[*]Smoke Bomb - I have it at 1. If I was to drop it, it would cost me a wave in CoC but otherwise I could live without it. Been running a lot of CoC for guild challenge, but after that, I'm not sure.
[*]Riposte - it is fine by itself. A matter of priorities.
[*]Crit Eye - if you put Piercing Strike back, then this becomes attractive.
[*]Assassinate - if you are going all out for KFS, it is a dropper. For a balanced toon, it is a keeper.

In my build, I have 18 points to spread across the above. I know I want PC 3, AcS 3, Ass 3, RS 1, Man 0, CritEye 3, and then the last 5 pts I get hung up on where I got CB, SB, Ensnare and Riposte left. Thoughts?
I have talked to a few people about KFS and they all agree that haste is an important factor so is 39.xx% a bit slow considering I use an axe?

My 4th gem slots are indeed all yellow and I think I will reconsider this, maybe a bit more melee.

I don't know if its just me but it seems that I have to have at least 5 points on the first level of abilities, please confirm if this is correct?

I have maneuver and riposte at 3 which is why I only have 1 on urgency. Personally I prefer the maneuver + riposte combo to urgency as I feed its more useful.

I use ensnare to interrupt so I would keep 1 on there and I can two hit mobs with spay then cloud so I would keep both at 3.

I have reflexive strike at 3 but I think I might move that down to 1. I would keep corrosive blades at 3 because I feels it's really useful for poison SW.

I'm not a fan of smoke bomb and I would keep assassinate at 3 because KFS is only one raid and I would prefer to keep a more balanced toon.

If I want PC + crit eye then it's 6 points so what do I take away? RS to 1 will give me 2 points, if I can remove caltrops then that gives me 1 point and maybe urgency so it 4 points still need 2 more.
Maybe I have to change man + riposte for PC + crit eye.

As for your build I would leave out riposte as you don't want maneuver and go CB 3, SB 1 and ensnare 1.
BaneFirerises wrote:I have talked to a few people about KFS and they all agree that haste is an important factor so is 39.xx% a bit slow considering I use an axe?

Haste is important, but once you get above 40%, it takes a lot of gems/training to get that last 2%. You'd be better invested in damage.

I don't know if its just me but it seems that I have to have at least 5 points on the first level of abilities, please confirm if this is correct?

Correct and when I respeced, I wasted a point. :roll:

After trying a more hybrid build and talking to a lot of people, I have yet to have anyone tell me a good poison/hybrid build. Unfortunately, everybody I know who is kicking butt is using melee. Oh well, I will focus more on Just/Mage for KFS.
Bbbb wrote:
BaneFirerises wrote:I have talked to a few people about KFS and they all agree that haste is an important factor so is 39.xx% a bit slow considering I use an axe?

Haste is important, but once you get above 40%, it takes a lot of gems/training to get that last 2%. You'd be better invested in damage.

I don't know if its just me but it seems that I have to have at least 5 points on the first level of abilities, please confirm if this is correct?

Correct and when I respeced, I wasted a point. :roll:

After trying a more hybrid build and talking to a lot of people, I have yet to have anyone tell me a good poison/hybrid build. Unfortunately, everybody I know who is kicking butt is using melee. Oh well, I will focus more on Just/Mage for KFS.

Bbbbs, let me know if you do discover a decent poison/hybrid SW build. Mine is doing awful as you know lol.



Edit: I think I may be on to something that semi-works for both vg speed and kfs?

Here's what I just switched to:

3011 (Dual Wield just as a toss-away point)
3330 (As much as I like assassinate, I can take out VG mobs w/ PC+AS [+rune worst case], so its unnecessary)
0333 (Crit Eye for auto-PS crits, w/Riposte, I can sacrifice a bit of haste)
0313 (0322 might work better, but i'm loathe to drop corrosive)

Gems:
20 Magic
10 Crit Power
2 Haste, 4 Crit, 4 Dodge

Stats (usually on might + haste elix, but this is base):
Melee - 900 (Goal: 1650)
Magic - 10,048
Crit - 34.68% (Goal: 35%)
Crit Power - 188.14% (Goal: 189%)
Defense - 41.92% (Goal: 50%)
Resists - 3.34% (Goal: 5%)
Dodge - 42.73% w/manuever (Goal: 44%)
Haste - 35.29%

Enchants:
2 Lv. 5 1H, 1 Lv. 4 IH
1 Lv. 5 Nature, 2 Lv. 4 Nature
3 Lv. 4 Defense

Damage: Piercing Strike Crits for 8k-10k, Toxic Blade Crits for 18k-22k.

I'll try it out tomorrow and report back.
I'm loathe to give up the RS point. I do make kills with it even on KFS. Urgency at 1 is a tough pill to swallow especially given your lower haste.

Your assassinate argument is an interesting one. I don't need it but it does speed up my killing on VG Mobs quite a bit. Also, that will murder my CoC performance. That's why I hope they give us multiple builds for PvE. I can have my KFS build and my regular build.

You are dodge heavy whereas I am dodge light.

My enchants are:
2 Lv 5 1H, 1 Lv 6 AP
3 Lv 3 Nature (working on this currently)
3 Lv 5 Defense

Also I sacrificed 4% of Crit Power to get my Resists up. However, with your high dodge, it might be less needed.
Bbbb wrote:I'm loathe to give up the RS point. I do make kills with it even on KFS. Urgency at 1 is a tough pill to swallow especially given your lower haste.

Your assassinate argument is an interesting one. I don't need it but it does speed up my killing on VG Mobs quite a bit. Also, that will murder my CoC performance. That's why I hope they give us multiple builds for PvE. I can have my KFS build and my regular build.

You are dodge heavy whereas I am dodge light.

My enchants are:
2 Lv 5 1H, 1 Lv 6 AP
3 Lv 3 Nature (working on this currently)
3 Lv 5 Defense

Also I sacrificed 4% of Crit Power to get my Resists up. However, with your high dodge, it might be less needed.

Yeah I was loathe to give up my point in reflexive too, I might bring it back if I find myself running into trouble.

I had to swallow the fact that poison sw couldnt perform optimally in CoC long ago. I can consistently hit 1950 in p3 though by alternating PS/TB with 10 haste gems. I'm going to have to live with that. But since I mainly merc CoC when I need it, works out nicely since they rarely ever open at p1. Good enough for me.

Multiple builds would be nice. I am dodge heavy only because it was at 15% until now, and I kinda over did it. That may drop down a bit as necessary and add in a bit to haste or crit.
I have what I think is a decent hybrid KFS build. I admit though it sucks for p1 so if I don't use another toon in p1 then I respec after p1 and use my everyday build for p1.

3003
3030
3033
0333

^That's the one I prefer. However, some have a thing for smoke bomb so i included the build i used to use with smoke bomb below. With this build^ I average 360-396 HS and have hit 414 HS multiple times but not as consistent. This is with haste elixir and pot. Without the haste pot I average 288-306 HS. This is for both Deus and Karnak. However the highest HS I got on Karnak is 396 not 414. 414 is against Deus.

3003
3030
3033
3231

^With smoke bomb.
I don't usually need smoke bomb so I don't use this build anymore but a lot of shadow walkers use it so i included it. The other build it seems I crit more.

Enchants make a huge difference. So play around with the enchants as well not just gems and build. Hope this helps some of you.
That looks like a melee build to me. What are your magic and melee numbers? Unfortunately, as you point out, it is a special purpose buildl.

I may give up on my SW as far as KFS p2 and p3 go. Focus on the Justie and Mage instead where I got decent builds that also work for general purpose. It will be a long time before I have enough melee gems to get me in that direction. I don't have the phys dmg enchant either.