Book of Heroes

merc reward for failed raid

Too many times I have dumped a lot of energy into a raid as a merc only to have the hosting guild give up.

Could the mercs still get a small reward for failed raids ?

Darkhorse

Site AdminFri Jul 12, 2013 11:26 am
Not sure this is something we'd consider implementing since it has other negative implications.
slaneyrw wrote:Too many times I have dumped a lot of energy into a raid as a merc only to have the hosting guild give up.

Could the mercs still get a small reward for failed raids ?

It's usually a good idea to pick and choose the raids you join wisely. Too often, I see a guild in a gk or vallus with 1.5 hours left til failure with like 4 people in with only 8% complete. I'm sure it occurs even more with the lower raids. If you accidentally join one of those, you're kinda setting yourself up for failure. Unless I can personally burn the raid to completion or a raid is nearly finished, I don't join bronze raids at all. Generally stick to the gold/silver ones that are on pace as a merc, and you'll be fine.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Jul 12, 2013 12:19 pm
slaneyrw wrote:
Could the mercs still get a small reward for failed raids ?

This post
Bj_DWR wrote:
Mercs will often join a Guild to help a failing Raid. Consolation Prizes would help repay this altruistic effort.
Failed Raid or Consolation Prizes(P1-2)

got an interesting response
FT_NikoNarf wrote:
would encourage players to delay finishing a raid, seems counter to the spirit of a raid... which is to vanquish your foe as quickly and decisively as possible. I like that guild power rewards quicker raids.

Cont.

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri Jul 12, 2013 5:04 pm
Fizz_Eric wrote:
...
It's usually a good idea to pick and choose the raids you join wisely.
...

This right here is key...as a merc you have a lot of discretion in choosing which raids to join, just pay attention closely to how well they are doing, time remaining, and how committed the guild is before you join it. Problem solved.

Overtime to you will discover which guilds finish their raids and which ones don't..also if you follow various raid times, you will find guilds who succeed and run raids when you are able to play...at which points you make their raid part of your gaming schedule. As a merc, the only downside is when a guild has a raid you want to join but will not open slots, apart form that, this is not a real problem for mercs. A bigger problem is for guilds when lazy one hit mercs fill up their merc slots and then do not contribute.
Fizz_Eric wrote:
slaneyrw wrote:Too many times I have dumped a lot of energy into a raid as a merc only to have the hosting guild give up.


Could the mercs still get a small reward for failed raids ?

It's usually a good idea to pick and choose the raids you join wisely. Too often, I see a guild in a gk or vallus with 1.5 hours left til failure with like 4 people in with only 8% complete. I'm sure it occurs even more with the lower raids. If you accidentally join one of those, you're kinda setting yourself up for failure. Unless I can personally burn the raid to completion or a raid is nearly finished, I don't join bronze raids at all. Generally stick to the gold/silver ones that are on pace as a merc, and you'll be fine.

I understand not being rewarded for joining a raid that is destined to fail. But how about rewarding the mercs that join raids that are then cancelled. I have been mercing in a couple of raids that were doing good and then out of the blue they mention they are cancelling the raid for one reason or another. So I have spent energy and or gold shields/pots helping and now get nothing in return.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sat Jul 13, 2013 7:07 pm
CR_Corybear wrote:
....
But how about rewarding the mercs that join raids that are then cancelled. I have been mercing in a couple of raids that were doing good and then out of the blue they mention they are cancelling the raid for one reason or another. So I have spent energy and or gold shields/pots helping and now get nothing in return.

I think this is a valid point, but to avoid abuse, it would have to be a reward to the merc that costs the guild something and not Venan. (Otherwise people would start raids, have all their toons join from other guilds, cancel the raid and earn free rewards from Venan).

Meaning if Guilds ever were to create a guild bank or system where GM could hand out rewards, gear, as has been discussed in other forum threads, then if a guild cancels a raid with mercs, the guild would be forced to pay the mercs something from their own reward pot. Then I could see this being a viable reward system without abuse.
Mithrid wrote:
CR_Corybear wrote:
....
But how about rewarding the mercs that join raids that are then cancelled. I have been mercing in a couple of raids that were doing good and then out of the blue they mention they are cancelling the raid for one reason or another. So I have spent energy and or gold shields/pots helping and now get nothing in return.

I think this is a valid point, but to avoid abuse, it would have to be a reward to the merc that costs the guild something and not Venan. (Otherwise people would start raids, have all their toons join from other guilds, cancel the raid and earn free rewards from Venan).

Meaning if Guilds ever were to create a guild bank or system where GM could hand out rewards, gear, as has been discussed in other forum threads, then if a guild cancels a raid with mercs, the guild would be forced to pay the mercs something from their own reward pot. Then I could see this being a viable reward system without abuse.

That sounds like a fair trade. The mercs arent being punished for a guild decision. And if the guild elects to cancel, then the guild is penalized for it, and the mercs still receive some sort of compensation.

I like it! Thanks

CR_CoryBear (Carolus Rex)
Darkhorse wrote:Not sure this is something we'd consider implementing since it has other negative implications.

I think a lot of these problems could be solved if the person initiating the raid could put a small message up on the purpose of the raid.

Another option might be to remove the ability to cancel a raid once Merc's join. That one it trickier, but it would make people stop and think if they wanted Mercs or now.

Thinking is a good thing. :)
Fizz_Eric wrote:
...
It's usually a good idea to pick and choose the raids you join wisely.
...

Something that would make this much nicer would be a guild state of completed vs. failed or abandoned raids. This could show up in the Merc listing. It would also make guilds much more interested in actually finishing raids they start.