Book of Heroes

Official PvP Beta Feedback Thread- ARCHIVED · page 10

I completed my PvP feats with my top toon, a nearly 24k might shadow walker. I plan to use the second spec for Karnak now, retiring my main from PvP. (My top Justi and WM just reached 125 wins, and fortunately their PvP builds work well vs Karnak, so I will occasionally fight with them, but they are both slow 2-handers, barely keeping above .500)

My SW finished 250-130.
80-51 vs Justi
87-59 vs SW
83-20 vs WM (a testament to the lack of WMs at my might level in PvP)

In recent times 2-h mages and 2-h justis are extremely rare in PvP, and if the stats above could be broken down further, I rarely lost to a 2-h wielder. If the knockbacks on a 1-h justi's brutal and seismic were halved, this might make the 2-h justi a little more desirable, but to balance, the SW smoke bomb should also be reduced.

What the WM lacks that the other classes have is a relatively fast knockback attack. Ice Lance has too long a casting time to be useful in PvP. If the knockback were moved to Frozen Shard, the mage might improve.

The other problem PvP faces is a dwindling population. When it first came out, vast quantities of players tried it out. Those that performed in the bottom 10% probably left quickly, making the next 10% now the bottom 10%, causing them to leave, and so on.

One solution to the dwindling population might be having players fight NPCs at a similar might and ability if no suitable match can be found in 60 seconds (I'd love to beat up on Majerio for making me get all those ingredients for the Undrian Plateau). This would allow PvP to narrow the might gap in fights (not Matues again! I'm only 24k might), but might also keep the less able PvP fighters interested as they hone their craft against Ember, Daedalus, and the gang.

My main now only needs to enchant/empower 58 items and kill 870490 monsters (at least 360 of which must be Sarkisian) to finish all the feats.

If you see one of my slow 2-handers in PvP, go easy on them. :)
FT_NikoNarf wrote:
The other problem PvP faces is a dwindling population. When it first came out, vast quantities of players tried it out. Those that performed in the bottom 10% probably left quickly, making the next 10% now the bottom 10%, causing them to leave, and so on.

This is one reason... But it's not just people quitting "because they're losing".

When PvP started, everyone jumped in with PvE builds. It quickly became apparent that these didn't work in PvP unless you went up against someone else using a PvE build - who were becoming rarer. More and more people quit as they faced the choice of 100GS for a 2nd spec or a long string of cruahing losses to PvP spec'd players. So they quit.

The other main one was facing cookie-cutter opponents who, on open, would immediately reduce your toon to <50%HP before you got a swing. Demoralising to new PvPers especially. So they quit.

PvP very quickly lost appeal to casual players, free / low $ players, and those who didn't want to focus on it. Personally, I was top 10 performance and still quit very early when every opponent was a gear and combo clone of the previous - I had 5 opponents in a row, all SWs, who opened with the same succession of moves, and to whom I lost. I accept that it's the most effective strategy for them, and that it works well - but the sheer lack of variety was what killed my interest, as I actually got more variety in tactics fighting PvE.
Anyone who's seen me in VG knows I'm not scared of spending shields, but I won't put them into PvP as it stands, and stopped playing PVP in less than 24hrs after it started.
I'll admit... honestly... it was fun for a while, but it wasn't lasting. Took me ~2 weeks to get more or less bored of pvp. And it wasn't the lack of rewards, it was the lack of variety. Whether I won every match or lost a match, every match turned into basically the same thing, and as hp became desirable, matches took longer and longer. It's finally gotten to the point where honestly, PvP is fun in small doses, but feels more like a mini-game than anything else.
What Eric said is basically what I addressed in my post in feature requests forum. So I 100% agree
I personally do not like this PVP system.

1. If 2 skilful players are matched against each other and executed each moves correctly, the winner will be the one that keep dodging, blocking and resist during the match. It is purely dependable on luck.

2. 18k might player is match against a 28k might player..... Ridiculous!

3. If PVP for BOH is so call 'optional', why are there even feats for PVP??? It doesn't make sense.... Forcing players to go PVP in order to complete the PVP feats?

4. It will takes weak PVP players forever to complete 250 win for PVP feat.

5. How about those PVE players? The PVP feats will forever be incomplete....
BOH core gameplay is on PVE. It is unfair for those PVE players unable to complete the PVP feats...

Just to share my thoughts.
Cheers!
SianZzz
U are damn right!!
SianZzz wrote:I personally do not like this PVP system.

1. If 2 skilful players are matched against each other and executed each moves correctly, the winner will be the one that keep dodging, blocking and resist during the match. It is purely dependable on luck.

2. 18k might player is match against a 28k might player..... Ridiculous!

3. If PVP for BOH is so call 'optional', why are there even feats for PVP??? It doesn't make sense.... Forcing players to go PVP in order to complete the PVP feats?

4. It will takes weak PVP players forever to complete 250 win for PVP feat.

5. How about those PVE players? The PVP feats will forever be incomplete....
BOH core gameplay is on PVE. It is unfair for those PVE players unable to complete the PVP feats...

Just to share my thoughts.
Cheers!
SianZzz
SianZzz wrote:I personally do not like this PVP system.

1. If 2 skilful players are matched against each other and executed each moves correctly, the winner will be the one that keep dodging, blocking and resist during the match. It is purely dependable on luck.

2. 18k might player is match against a 28k might player..... Ridiculous!

3. If PVP for BOH is so call 'optional', why are there even feats for PVP??? It doesn't make sense.... Forcing players to go PVP in order to complete the PVP feats?

4. It will takes weak PVP players forever to complete 250 win for PVP feat.

5. How about those PVE players? The PVP feats will forever be incomplete....
BOH core gameplay is on PVE. It is unfair for those PVE players unable to complete the PVP feats...

Just to share my thoughts.
Cheers!
SianZzz

Have to agree with SianZzz.

Implementing Feat by no means make this beta optional. & Will cause rage in serious Pve players not willing to respec for pvp.
On the other end, serious pvp players will want more feat.

IMHO, this is still a Pve dominant game, unless there's a different set of gameplay/items for pvp.

Cheers,
Gav

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Aug 7, 2013 12:22 am
I think Niko summarized well the state of PvP.

But I'll make my point here, I'm kind of over PvP. Mostly because the WM is vastly underpowered by comparison. Sure I've beaten all the top players multiple times over, but in order to do so I either needed luck or for my opponent to make a mistake. But as they have added HP and gotten smarter, they make fewer mistakes, or when they do make a mistake, it doesn't cost them.
And the only way a WM can win is if his SW or Justi opponent makes a mistake. The contrary is not true, unfortunatelty.

Even if I play a perfect hand as the WM, I'll lose to a SW or Justi UNLESS I can trick them or keep their rotations off balance. As HP have pretty much become the dominant stat in PvP, one of the problems for the WM is recovering from the standard knockbacks of the SW or Justi. I can possibly recover, Once, from a Justi rotation of seismic-brutal-heroic-brutal-wound routine, where they easily can do 10k + damage while I watch, or the SW smoke bomb-pierce-reflexive-ensnare-caltrops-pierce-reflexive rotation as well, but only once. But as HP have become a dominant stat the PvP rounds are long enough for Justis or SW to get 2-3 of these rotations off. The WM cannot recover from it. The WM needs several rounds to make up the damage deficit inflicted during either of these rotations.

See the WM has no massive damage rotation, no real knockbacks (Ice lance at 0.5 sec is useless, takes too long to cast).
Incinerate is no Brutal Strike or Piercing strike either.

We get no magic damage bonus for the required 1H PvP weapon.

The game is fairly well balanced for a first pass beta, but WM need a fix, otherwise it's just demoralizing.

I'm over PvP. It's just kind of hard to keep motivated when you realize the odds are against you as a WM.
I would just like to state that when fighting a shadow walker as a war Mage with ice shield. And the mage becomes stunned with ice shield activating. If sw next move is caltrops it removes the ice shield. If its removing the ice shield its acting as damage which in turn should remove the stun also! I would like to see this looked at before the next update. Either it should leave ice shield active or it should remove both shield and stun as a damage hit would. Thank you
Prophet is 100% correct. It doesnt make any sense... And other than amazing record SWs who want everything to stay exactly the same, the consensus seems to be SW > Justi > WM... Its near impossible to beat a good SW as a Justi or WM, and its near impossible for a WM to beat a good Justi.

I do agree that for a beta, its not too bad, as mentioned earlier. But I still feel like this pvp system lacks "substance." Soon most people will have it figured out, exactly how they should play, and then it just comes down to which person has the better class or which person gets the luckiest dodges/blocks.