Lots of people aren't seeing this glaring hierarchy though. There are lots of good WM, using 1H weapons and shields, playing at different levels. Others are also saying Justicars are the OP class...it just isn't as cut and dry as it's being claimed. There are a couple of things I'd like to see fixed - Riposte shouldn't allow a defend (unless backswing is changed to allow it too), ice shield procs more than stated and you should be able to dodge stuns (you can dodge other attacks). And yes, unless there's a valid reason it does (i.e. it was deliberate), Caltrops removing ice shield shouldn't be happening either.
Official PvP Beta Feedback Thread- ARCHIVED · page 11
Should fix the level differnce issue ie a level 16 vs level 22 etc
I totally agree if pvp is optional there should not be a feat tied to it.
SianZzz wrote:I personally do not like this PVP system.
3. If PVP for BOH is so call 'optional', why are there even feats for PVP??? It doesn't make sense.... Forcing players to go PVP in order to complete the PVP feats?
4. It will takes weak PVP players forever to complete 250 win for PVP feat.
5. How about those PVE players? The PVP feats will forever be incomplete....
BOH core gameplay is on PVE. It is unfair for those PVE players unable to complete the PVP feats...
Just to share my thoughts.
Cheers!
SianZzz
The 20 seconds is a kick in the pants and makes matches way way way too long and boring (well, it is boring anyway). This is a battle not a chess match. 5 seconds is what it should be.
Mithrid wrote:I think Niko summarized well the state of PvP.
But I'll make my point here, I'm kind of over PvP. Mostly because the WM is vastly underpowered by comparison. Sure I've beaten all the top players multiple times over, but in order to do so I either needed luck or for my opponent to make a mistake. But as they have added HP and gotten smarter, they make fewer mistakes, or when they do make a mistake, it doesn't cost them.
And the only way a WM can win is if his SW or Justi opponent makes a mistake. The contrary is not true, unfortunatelty.
Even if I play a perfect hand as the WM, I'll lose to a SW or Justi UNLESS I can trick them or keep their rotations off balance. As HP have pretty much become the dominant stat in PvP, one of the problems for the WM is recovering from the standard knockbacks of the SW or Justi. I can possibly recover, Once, from a Justi rotation of seismic-brutal-heroic-brutal-wound routine, where they easily can do 10k + damage while I watch, or the SW smoke bomb-pierce-reflexive-ensnare-caltrops-pierce-reflexive rotation as well, but only once. But as HP have become a dominant stat the PvP rounds are long enough for Justis or SW to get 2-3 of these rotations off. The WM cannot recover from it. The WM needs several rounds to make up the damage deficit inflicted during either of these rotations.
See the WM has no massive damage rotation, no real knockbacks (Ice lance at 0.5 sec is useless, takes too long to cast).
Incinerate is no Brutal Strike or Piercing strike either.
We get no magic damage bonus for the required 1H PvP weapon.
The game is fairly well balanced for a first pass beta, but WM need a fix, otherwise it's just demoralizing.
I'm over PvP. It's just kind of hard to keep motivated when you realize the odds are against you as a WM.
Whatever Mithrid has said. I concur fully. The War Mage is a horribly WEAK class compared to Justicar and SW at endgame. When the two mages at the top end of the leader boards are agreeing on this point, it has to hold some truth.
I'm done with PvP. 250 wins and I'll stop for good unless real changes occur.
I'm sorry if someone already said this. I don't feel like reading 11 pages... The 2nd spec thing is awesome. It was needed. It's not quite right though. If we've set up a 2nd spec for PVP and it is not the one we're using at the time we enter PVP, then there are two issues. 1) We already set PVP to the spec that we want to use in it. Don't bug us by asking. Just switch to it. 2) we weren't using that spec when we entered because it's useless for everything but PVP. Automatically switch us back to the previously selected spec when we leave PVP. It's such a bother to start a dungeon and suddenly realize you don't have any group attacks because you're on the wrong spec. Inevitably one wastes the 20 e and leaves.
11 pages and no ingame updates at all nor any communication.
It's nice to see Beekeo ingame participating but I rather a real update: adjusting where/what needed.
The longer it takes the worse it will get in terms of willing to pvp..
It's nice to see Beekeo ingame participating but I rather a real update: adjusting where/what needed.
The longer it takes the worse it will get in terms of willing to pvp..
Whatever Mithrid has said. I concur fully. The War Mage is a horribly WEAK class compared to Justicar and SW at endgame. When the two mages at the top end of the leader boards are agreeing on this point, it has to hold some truth.
Lots of people are not seeing this, however. Two players agreeing does not equal proof. It's not that there aren't any issues, perhaps it's that these are more glaring at very high might. So far it's anecdotal and only the devs will be able to answer whether it's actually true. Leaving aside matchup issues, many people are encountering monster mages that are just as good if not better than Justicars at the same might level. They are not vastly underpowered, there are too many good mages for that to be accurate.
Hope_Ilyana wrote:Whatever Mithrid has said. I concur fully. The War Mage is a horribly WEAK class compared to Justicar and SW at endgame. When the two mages at the top end of the leader boards are agreeing on this point, it has to hold some truth.
Lots of people are not seeing this, however. Two players agreeing does not equal proof. It's not that there aren't any issues, perhaps it's that these are more glaring at very high might. So far it's anecdotal and only the devs will be able to answer whether it's actually true. Leaving aside matchup issues, many people are encountering monster mages that are just as good if not better than Justicars at the same might level. They are not vastly underpowered, there are too many good mages for that to be accurate.
This changes with every update.. Here's my view for the current version: justicars and SWs are somewhat matched. SWs coming out behind a little. They excel at CoC and PVP but not as good at raids which I'd give greater priority. Either way there's some balance there. In the past WMs rocked too much and as a result were knocked back too much. They're currently at the short end of the stick for both raids and PVP. Not too far off for raids. My oppinion for what adjustments are needed: significant boost for WM in PVP(I don't know how). Slight decrease for justicars in raids (they never get hurt.. Too much knock back) my Justis will hate me for saying that though. Emphasize "slight"
They should all have differences I think. So I stress slight in the places I used it.
Obviously my builds might not be perfect, so my opinions might be off, but with 19 toons you get a feel for things. I think that's mostly right. It feels wrong when my whimpy toons fight better than my uber toons
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
Lots of people are not seeing this, however. Two players agreeing does not equal proof. It's not that there aren't any issues, perhaps it's that these are more glaring at very high might. So far it's anecdotal and only the devs will be able to answer whether it's actually true. Leaving aside matchup issues, many people are encountering monster mages that are just as good if not better than Justicars at the same might level. They are not vastly underpowered, there are too many good mages for that to be accurate.
Ilyana,
You are not paying attention to the game much then. First off, it is arguable to what extent "vastly" underpowered could mean..it is a subjective term after all..., but yes we are arguing that there exists a very noticeable imbalance.
For instance, in the top25 score: there are only 4 WM including Jynxcakes at 9k might who is probably burning resolve pots. I'm curious what his W-L record is, but if you look at Tow who has the highest score, his W-L record is about ~2.5:1 (Tow may need to correct me here) ratio. Compare that to all the Justis and SW in the top brackets who generally have a W:L ratio of >5:1; Some much higher than that.
What this indicates is that for comparably matched Justicars and SW, skill can definitely take a hand in determining records...but for Mages...not so much. There is not a single Mage out there besides myself in the >20K range with a better than 5:1 W-L ratio (someone correct me if I am wrong), yet there are many many SW and Justi...why do you suppose that is? (I actually would like to hear your answer to that)
Then consider the top25 performance board: There are only 2..TWO WM there, Japster and Myself...tell me Ilyana, where are all these Monster WM when essentially 33% of the Toons in BoH are represented by an 8% showing on the leaderboard? (If you respond, I'd like to hear your thoughts on this as well)
This is the proof I am offering...the stats on the boards, and my experience as arguably the best PvP WM in the game (no offense intended to any of my fellow WM's and you are all more then welcome to disagree, I realize its a bit pretentious on my part to state it here)...
Now I am curious what your proof is for your statement:
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
Leaving aside matchup issues, many people are encountering monster mages that are just as good if not better than Justicars at the same might level. They are not vastly underpowered, there are too many good mages for that to be accurate.
As far as I can tell, its pretty anecdotal, and only one persons opinion, with little to no WM playing experience...or at least who isn't even present as a WM on the leaderboard (at least not as far as Ive searched).