Book of Heroes

Official PvP Beta Feedback Thread- ARCHIVED · page 13

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Aug 13, 2013 12:03 pm
You are not paying attention to the game much then. First off, it is arguable to what extent "vastly" underpowered could mean..it is a subjective term after all..., but yes we are arguing that there exists a very noticeable imbalance.

For instance, in the top25 score: there are only 4 WM including Jynxcakes at 9k might who is probably burning resolve pots. I'm curious what his W-L record is, but if you look at Tow who has the highest score, his W-L record is about ~2.5:1 (Tow may need to correct me here) ratio. Compare that to all the Justis and SW in the top brackets who generally have a W:L ratio of >5:1; Some much higher than that.

Do you always open responses with an insult?

If there were none in the top 25, it would support the point a little more. Does it not suggest that these folks are not finding it difficult to play mages? Are you just beating other mages?

What this indicates is that for comparably matched Justicars and SW, skill can definitely take a hand in determining records...but for Mages...not so much. There is not a single Mage out there besides myself in the >20K range with a better than 5:1 W-L ratio (someone correct me if I am wrong), yet there are many many SW and Justi...why do you suppose that is? (I actually would like to hear your answer to that)

It's a beta. Are you really expecting it to be perfect? I've said several times elsewhere that the devs will make any changes to how mages perform if necessary.
Then consider the top25 performance board: There are only 2..TWO WM there, Japster and Myself...tell me Ilyana, where are all these Monster WM when essentially 33% of the Toons in BoH are represented by an 8% showing on the leaderboard? (If you respond, I'd like to hear your thoughts on this as well)

I was referring to in-match performance rather than boards, but point made in that respect. However many of us will have run into very, very good war mage players, which you are perhaps overlooking. I've run into many that were very good.
This is the proof I am offering...the stats on the boards, and my experience as arguably the best PvP WM in the game (no offense intended to any of my fellow WM's and you are all more then welcome to disagree, I realize its a bit pretentious on my part to state it here)...

Are you a good war mage player because of luck, then, if the system is as broken as you say?
Hope_Ilyana wrote:Leaving aside matchup issues, many people are encountering monster mages that are just as good if not better than Justicars at the same might level. They are not vastly underpowered, there are too many good mages for that to be accurate.

As far as I can tell, its pretty anecdotal, and only one persons opinion, with little to no WM playing experience...or at least who isn't even present as a WM on the leaderboard (at least not as far as Ive searched).

Of course it's anecdotal. I've both fought and heard about plenty of good mage players though. Don't drag them down. I have a little mage but not one that I've prepped for PvP at all yet.

However, all of this trash talk will just make WM players not play PvP, which skews the stats even further. You're even advising players to not even play WMs elsewhere on this forum, solely because PvP stats for WMs are poorer. You make some good points but end it by implying 'I'm the best, so my opinion counts more'. Don't try to drown anyone else out because they happen to disagree on certain areas. It may be that the WM continues to have worse performance overall until fixed, or Venan might decide they disagree with you and only make small patches.
there are many complaints that mages are underpowered in pvp. I think unnerfing some wm abilities that were nerfed recently could help. for example returning ice lance knockback to 0.75, restoring all conditions for snap cast, restoring ice shield strength and trigger probability.

personally I would love increasing probability and adding conditions of snap cast. it probably more balanced change than say upping ice shield
to 99% probability and dmg absorb ratio.

John might be onto something here, actually suggesting fixes if Venan decide there are problems with mages, which they might well do.
I could just sit and argue that its fine the way it is but WMs will stop competing in pvp if it remains this way, especially as more and more players begin learning better strategies.

Even though you were disagreeing Sok, you manage to put it across in a friendly way. What will also put WM players off is players flocking to the forums complaining about 'broken' PvP. Personally I think the matchup system is a big issue, but since PvP is a beta they will have mounds of data to sift through by the time they decide which changes to make.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Aug 13, 2013 12:54 pm
Postby Darkhorse » Tue Aug 13, 2013 2:18 pm



Hamilton wrote:Well looks like I fold.
With no news of War Mages and PvP considered to be working as intended. The game seems to no longer be for a casual gamer, or at least for me.
But I did enjoy the time and the money invested, so this is not in spite.
It was real and fun.


These kinds of posts are of the most frustrating kind to read as a game developer. How did you come to this conclusion?

Just because there are no War Mage changes this patch doesn't mean that we aren't working on something or that we think balance is perfect. Where did we say that PVP is working exactly as we intend or where we want it to end up? If it was, why would we leave it in beta? We know there is a LOT we need to do to improve PVP, that's why it's in beta. Just for starters, we aren't overly happy with the matchmaking currently or the game balance at extremely high mights. These are things we are working on, but we don't have any announcements for THIS particular patch.

Might also shed some light on things, given you're at high-end might Mithrid.

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue Aug 13, 2013 1:36 pm
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
Do you always open responses with an insult?

With all due respect, I didn't insult you, I merely pointed out that you were not paying attention to the details. There is a difference between telling someone "You're an idiot" versus "You are missing the point"...one is clearly ad hominem and the other is a statement of fact (the accuracy of the fact can be debated).
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
If there were none in the top 25, it would support the point a little more. Does it not suggest that these folks are not finding it difficult to play mages? Are you just beating other mages?

In statistics, all or "none" doesn't cut it when determining factors and circumstances for an outcome. The world is not black and white...but a massive game of probability. So the fact that only 4 WM are in the top 25% is bad enough, but look at their records..Tow is ~2:1 W-L, and he has one of the better records, the vast majority of WM on the leaderboard for score are 1-1 or or worse; compare that to many of other Justis/SW who are anywhere from 5:1 to 10:1.
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
It's a beta. Are you really expecting it to be perfect? I've said several times elsewhere that the devs will make any changes to how mages perform if necessary.

Again you are not paying attention (not an insult, just a point of fact) as I have made it very clear in several prior post that for a beta Venan has done a great job.
just one of several examples:
PvP Praise...really a Great Job Venan!!!!!!!!

However the beta doesn't seem to be getting any updates to help bring things into balance, and Venan, nor other players have been able to provide any suggested improved approaches for WM's in PvP.
Worse, even the latest patch will do nothing for WM based on the patch notes. They will however be providing for a PvP rewards system but now that means WM are further going to be a kickboard for other toons if they want to make a grab for those PvP rewards.
There-in lies the annoyance. The beta is getting really old (i.e. demotivating) as a WM, and so far there is no real hope for relief on the horizon, as of yet, the the PvP system is being expanded nevertheless.
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
I was referring to in-match performance rather than boards, but point made in that respect. However many of us will have run into very, very good war mage players, which you are perhaps overlooking. I've run into many that were very good.

Again very anecdotal as in-match performance is also highly plagued with mis-match issues...sure a 20k might Justi may very well have a challenge beating a 28k WM.
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
Are you a good war mage player because of luck, then, if the system is as broken as you say?

If you read one of my earlier posts on this same thread, you will have your answer. A very explicit example that answers your question, I posted on Wed Aug 07, 2013 12:22 am and Japster quoted it in whole on Fri Aug 09, 2013 3:24 am (this same thread as well). Attention to details. ;)
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
Of course it's anecdotal. I've both fought and heard about plenty of good mage players though. Don't drag them down. I have a little mage but not one that I've prepped for PvP at all yet.

I haven't dragged any of them down and have pointed out that they are perfectly welcome to disagree with me as well. The only real responses have been full agreement such as Japster or unrelated posts where other WM players have commented on their challenges, and implicitly agreed with my point. I have yet to see a WM who is doing very well (Let us say better than 2-1 W-L, in the >20K bracket) disagree with me and argue that WM are balanced.
Again you are implying insult where none exist (your reference to drag them down), and you have cemented/confirmed my position that you are debating me on a point (WM imbalance in PvP) when you as a fact do not have real WM PvP experience.
Hope_Ilyana wrote:
However, all of this trash talk will just make WM players not play PvP, which skews the stats even further. You're even advising players to not even play WMs elsewhere on this forum, solely because PvP stats for WMs are poorer. You make some good points but end it by implying 'I'm the best, so my opinion counts more'. Don't try to drown anyone else out because they happen to disagree on certain areas. It may be that the WM continues to have worse performance overall until fixed, or Venan might decide they disagree with you and only make small patches.

Now here you have made an amusing comment. First off no one is trash talking anybody. What is being conveyed is is concerns about the game engine as its stands, as well as my personal frustration with the WM situation. Your other point about stats being skewed because other WMs will be deterred by my opinion...the reality is if I am way off base, no one will pay attention to me because it will be obvious due to in-game play and other WM doing well. However it should be noted that most WM either stopped playing or dramatically reduced their PvP play long before I started my concerns on this particular thread.

I would also love love love to have you point out on the message boards where I have attempted to drown out another WM who is countering my points. I don't think it exist, so your concern about me "drowning" out other WM's on the message board is invalid.

That being said, people play these games for enjoyment and to do well (there are a few, but very few people who join a game with every intention of sucking and get enjoyment out of it)...my advice to them still stands, If you want to do well, a WM is not your best option as the game currently stands. A competitive player by nature will get demotivated if it is obvious that they are given an intrinsic handicap, so I am warning those players if they are still early in their toon development. That is completely acceptable.

Venan is welcome to do what they want, it is their game after all, and as it stands they have not seen fit to adjust the WM apart from the 1.7.1 fix.

I do expect they are considering something, but for now it is merely frustrating to play a WM in PvP...and personally I do not have a great way of coping with that frustration....apart from trying to walk away until a fix does come.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Aug 14, 2013 6:00 am
With all due respect, I didn't insult you, I merely pointed out that you were not paying attention to the details. There is a difference between telling someone "You're an idiot" versus "You are missing the point"...one is clearly ad hominem and the other is a statement of fact (the accuracy of the fact can be debated).

You may think you're stating a fact, but many people use similar arguments in debate. They claim that their detractor 'just doesn't get it' or 'isn't paying attention'. In the end it's still just an opinion, not a statement of fact.
In statistics, all or "none" doesn't cut it when determining factors and circumstances for an outcome. The world is not black and white...but a massive game of probability. So the fact that only 4 WM are in the top 25% is bad enough, but look at their records..Tow is ~2:1 W-L, and he has one of the better records, the vast majority of WM on the leaderboard for score are 1-1 or or worse; compare that to many of other Justis/SW who are anywhere from 5:1 to 10:1.

Fair enough, and I think I agree here. Darkhorse has already mentioned they think there is a problem at very high mights, which is backed up there.
Again you are not paying attention (not an insult, just a point of fact) as I have made it very clear in several prior post that for a beta Venan has done a great job.

Maybe you didn't realise that I didn't say you hadn't praised Venan elsewhere? Spurious to suggest that I did, but there's that 'not paying attention' dig again.

Hope_Ilyana wrote:I was referring to in-match performance rather than boards, but point made in that respect. However many of us will have run into very, very good war mage players, which you are perhaps overlooking. I've run into many that were very good.

Again very anecdotal as in-match performance is also highly plagued with mis-match issues...sure a 20k might Justi may very well have a challenge beating a 28k WM.

Of course it's anecdotal, but then a lot of people's experiences in this game are. But yes, mis-matches are a problem, and if the patch tightens things up we might see WM problems across PvP rather than at the very high mights, which if I may reiterate is the only level Venan have said they have noticed a problem.

If you read one of my earlier posts on this same thread, you will have your answer. A very explicit example that answers your question, I posted on Wed Aug 07, 2013 12:22 am and Japster quoted it in whole on Fri Aug 09, 2013 3:24 am (this same thread as well). Attention to details. ;)

Again a dig, this time at not having recently read a post from a week ago. You said:
Sure I've beaten all the top players multiple times over, but in order to do so I either needed luck or for my opponent to make a mistake.

Unfortunately this is also anecdotal, and you're in the top 25. Was it really luck/mistakes that kept you competitive? Fair enough if you feel it was. I actually agree about the mage knockback and 1H magic, their kb isn't impressive and they probably need a 1H equivalent of a staff. Wand perhaps?
I haven't dragged any of them down and have pointed out that they are perfectly welcome to disagree with me as well. The only real responses have been full agreement such as Japster or unrelated posts where other WM players have commented on their challenges, and implicitly agreed with my point. I have yet to see a WM who is doing very well (Let us say better than 2-1 W-L, in the >20K bracket) disagree with me and argue that WM are balanced.

Firstly, the forum is a small sample. Lack of disagreement on a forum isn't anything to shout about. But since I seem to be playing devil's advocate right now and garnering hostility just for speaking up, maybe it's not surprising WM agree? Everyone wants their favourite class to get a buff. SWs were heavily nerfed in 1.5 and only had Onslaught to comfort them, the same thing is happening today with Mages in PvP.
Again you are implying insult where none exist (your reference to drag them down), and you have cemented/confirmed my position that you are debating me on a point (WM imbalance in PvP) when you as a fact do not have real WM PvP experience.

Let's see...I have a WM (that needs better gems), with the 2nd spec, that has played in PvP. I've fought innumerable WMs in PvP with my other toons, both of which are appropriately specced. A fair number had obviously got their spec, gems and tactics spot on. If that isn't experience to you, then you're obviously only referring to fighting at high mights with WMs but not making it clear that you are.
Now here you have made an amusing comment. First off no one is trash talking anybody. What is being conveyed is is concerns about the game engine as its stands, as well as my personal frustration with the WM situation. Your other point about stats being skewed because other WMs will be deterred by my opinion...the reality is if I am way off base, no one will pay attention to me because it will be obvious due to in-game play and other WM doing well. However it should be noted that most WM either stopped playing or dramatically reduced their PvP play long before I started my concerns on this particular thread.

It's trash talk if you simply default to 'you're not paying attention', which is an opinion and nothing more. It has no basis in fact, but you clearly think you are stating a fact as you said above.
I would also love love love to have you point out on the message boards where I have attempted to drown out another WM who is countering my points. I don't think it exist, so your concern about me "drowning" out other WM's on the message board is invalid.

I'd also love to see where I said you were trying to drown other WM players out. You were reading too much into that. It's me you're trying to drown out for having an opinion I'm quite entitled to have.
That being said, people play these games for enjoyment and to do well (there are a few, but very few people who join a game with every intention of sucking and get enjoyment out of it)...my advice to them still stands, If you want to do well, a WM is not your best option as the game currently stands. A competitive player by nature will get demotivated if it is obvious that they are given an intrinsic handicap, so I am warning those players if they are still early in their toon development. That is completely acceptable.

I suppose it really depends on whether they want to be very active in PvP. Mages are very good in PvE, better than SWs in fact.
I do expect they are considering something, but for now it is merely frustrating to play a WM in PvP...and personally I do not have a great way of coping with that frustration....apart from trying to walk away until a fix does come.

I understand you're frustrated, and I may very well have a different PoV once my Mage grows up. What Venan need to do is gather all the data they can, validate the claims made anecdotally vs the player/board stats, and work out where they want to make changes. For now, I can agree to disagree (though you've convinced me in some places) until my little Mage gets her act together ;)
I've just one comment/question I can accept everything except one thing.. How do you justify seismic doing double the time push that the other two classes time push abilities.
Droen wrote:I've just one comment/question I can accept everything except one thing.. How do you justify seismic doing double the time push that the other two classes time push abilities.
and how u justify all classes except justicar have slowing effects? mage has 2 ice slowing abilities and sw has caltrops while both giving u additional bonuses besides slowing. give up caltrops and 2 ice slowing abilities and I give up seismic.

japster

ModeratorWed Aug 14, 2013 3:09 pm
john12345 wrote:
Droen wrote:I've just one comment/question I can accept everything except one thing.. How do you justify seismic doing double the time push that the other two classes time push abilities.
and how u justify all classes except justicar have slowing effects? mage has 2 ice slowing abilities and sw has caltrops while both giving u additional bonuses besides slowing. give up caltrops and 2 ice slowing abilities and I give up seismic.

Meh...but justicars have the highest natural defense due to their plate mail armor and heavy shield + highest natural block due to access to a heavy shield...so that does make up for it. Honestly, the knockbacks do get a bit crazy at times :P

Truth is, the list goes on if we continue with simplistic comparisons, but Mithrid's analysis throughout this thread pretty much hits the spot on the challenges a WM face.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Aug 15, 2013 5:53 am
Good point John..pretty much all fight against SWs and Mages you are slowed. Against SWs and Justicars especially you get knocked back a lot. Against all 3 you're probably taking DoT. I think the Mage ice lance is probably their biggest problem, with its obscenely long cast length (compared to SB and Seismic) and poor knockback effects.

I'm happy to wait and see whether the developers agree with WM concerns. So far they only think there's a problem at high mights, which looks like that's what you're seeing. I quickly took my Mage back into PvP while waiting for regen and won 6 matches out of 7...she still has more losses, but she played a while without the 2nd spec.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Aug 15, 2013 9:40 pm
Mithrid wrote:

2. Add a might stat in the PvP arena screen. Just so everyone can be aware that they weren't matched to a 33K brawler when they only had 20k Might. I mention it here in greater detail:
viewtopic.php?f=24&t=4088

Actually a better spot to post your opponents might is on the "versus" screen, when you also flash their win-Loss record.

Thanks Guys...I actually really like how you implemented this suggestion.
Mithrid wrote:

3. Add a "Training Arena"
It would cost resolve points to enter, but in the training arena you could arbitrarily fight your guild-mates for fun. Matches be damned. The fights wouldn't affect global stats or leader-boards at all, but guildmates could mess around with each other, try new builds, test strategies, help each other out. In this Training arena I would also remove the Decision timer so that they could chat and discuss next moves or evaluate prior moves, also offer an exit button so they could end a match when they were done. Again, its not free, they still spend resolve, and it can't be abused because it has no reward toward feats or stats.

Additional items:

4. I still want a visitor chat channel in guilds. :) I miss the casual visiting days of 1.5 and I still think the community has suffered from the limited social interaction of 1.6.

I would still really like to see items 3 and 4....I think Guilds would really enjoy #3.
PvP is fun when I win lol just kidding. Its good. So I guess the match making though is still screwy. Im 20.6k and I match up with Matues who is 30k. What a joke