Book of Heroes

PvP Praise...really a Great Job Venan!!!!!!!!

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Jul 24, 2013 10:32 pm
Dear Venan,
I know at the beginning of PvP I griped at you, and I eventually came around and posted that I was initially wrong. (I'm eating my words Venan.....)

I have been playing all types of PvP games since before half the squats ( I would say idiots but I'm trying to be polite, I did mention this thought for Bims and Garlands benefit) on global were born...That being said, I think your beta PvP is very very good.

The more I play it the more I gain an appreciation of the level of strategy, tactics and balance (did I say balance, yes I did) you put into it. Especially as players become more competent, the challenge to win become increasingly rewarding.

The level of balance between the 3 classes, with very different builds, attacks, features; is extremely, even exceptionally impressive.
Yes there are a few hiccups, but really you have done an incredible job. Did I mention how much fun I find the strategy of the fights...I was asked by a player what my rotation is, and I answered "none...every fight is very different"...yes there are a few players who always start off with the standard rotations, and as Eric and I were joking, after its done, they have no strategy and get their @$$'s handed to them. Then there are the players who pay close attention to the strategy and sometimes they hand me my @$$.

But on the whole, you have clearly and competently added a wonderful dimension to this game and I have to admit at this point that it is impressive...probably one of the best Mobile App PvP roleouts I have ever seen, and THE best for a game that was not originally engineered for it.

Now there are a few items I would like to suggest and Ill copy them to the official thread:

1. The Dual Spec- 100GS...look, PvP has a learning curve, not so much for SW, a tad more for Justi but an extremely hard one for WM. There are still too few WM who have figured it out (Droen, Sim0n and Anechi are 3 that come to mind...I hear Japsters doing well but I haven't fought him yet ;) ) You should have realized that PvP Beta needed players to really experiment and play with it...but you put an automatic limit on Beta testing to big spenders...that was a complete SLAP to the face of a lot of players I know who modestly put in $5-$10 every few weeks/months. you alienated a good majority of players who are now justifiably pissed ( I know 3 who have deleted the game from their phones and have mentioned maybe coming back after the bitter taste wears off).

My suggestion: The Beta should have given everyone a new and EXPLICIT PvP Spec, that cost maybe 1 or 2 GS to respec at a time. This Spec would not have been usable in PvE, likewise PvE would not be usable in PvP..they would be isolated...then after everyone has had a chance to spend a few GS and test the beta out, climb the learning curve, THEN you take it away when you move on from beta and add the "Dual Spec"....make it 100GS if you want then, I don't care, but at least by that time everyone would have had a taste of the PvP beta without getting shafted on price. You still could have made your money after releasing the official version because everyone would be more confident in buying a respec for PvP at that point. Full Rant here: EASY (short term) HELP for the WarMages--the real problem

2. Add a might stat in the PvP arena screen. Just so everyone can be aware that they weren't matched to a 33K brawler when they only had 20k Might. I mention it here in greater detail:
Mis-matched Mights

3. Add a "Training Arena"
It would cost resolve points to enter, but in the training arena you could arbitrarily fight your guild-mates for fun. Matches be damned. The fights wouldn't affect global stats or leader-boards at all, but guildmates could mess around with each other, try new builds, test strategies, help each other out. In this Training arena I would also remove the Decision timer so that they could chat and discuss next moves or evaluate prior moves, also offer an exit button so they could end a match when they were done with it and didn't want to finish the fight. Again, its not free, they still spend resolve, and it can't be abused because it has no reward toward feats or stats. Make so that you cant train during a raid even without reseting the RPP.

Those are my primary suggestions at the moment.

Again Venan, on the whole this has added so much more to the game...very very much enjoying the new challenge, and the depth of strategy is phenomenal. The balance is actually extremely well crafted and engineered, especially for the players who have crossed the learning curve.

I praise the Beta!! congratulations Venan, you did a great Job!! (100GS dual spec excepted :roll: )
I whole heartlessly agree with Mith. If you step back and look at the product Venan has delivered, with it's immersive social environment, raids, guilds, quest, tiered valor, gems, etc...and now PvP. I can think of no other app I've seen as complete as this one, that can offer so many avenues to take with a character that you can keep building for well over a year (and counting for me). I truly appreciate the job they've done (and do) and while I have my gripes, (let's not nerf things that people spend time and money on, and let's not make raids do insanely long that it takes the joy out of it) I certainly am appreciative of BoH as a place to come and enjoy the challenges of building my toons and relaxing with the people I meet.
+1 You take the time to mention the problems but also an actual solution that is well thought out and considered.

I'm sure most fellow WM's could find the right build and spec to be more successful (with time) but the cost is prohibitive and not something most would invest for a BETA when the rewards are unknown.
At minimum, throw in 5 respec tokens on the 100 GS spent for the additional spec. Bundling makes the value seem better.
I agree with Mithrid on all points. Having played PvP focused characters in MMOs for years, I am very impressed with the tactical and strategic depth of the PvP fights here.
One feature that really amazes me is the defense skill, which seems to separate good players from bad ones.
I see a lot of complaints about spec cost and while I understand Mith's post about giving people a chance to use it during beta test..they'd cry bloody murder when venan took it away. Two things to this point..I honestly don't have a problem with the cost...most people aren't ready for the PvP switch of their toons (massive CV investment) it's an investment to get the extra spec well beyond GS..so save the GS along the way...and secondly, no one is crying bloody murder about energy sigil cost anymore...that's because it's something they understand the value for and save for it..same too with the second spec.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jul 25, 2013 9:00 am
People aren't complaining about sigil cost anymore because sigils have not just been added to the game. I know some players who saved long-term for their Sigil of Endless zeal and it takes months. I have every expectation that the cost will never change and it will become another accepted method of dividing the spenders (I don't mean 'top players', there's a big difference) from the non-spenders.

I don't think it's a huge CV invest...my SW/Justicar will need 1-2 extra pieces of kit and maybe some different gems, if that. The biggest problem is not being able to access the 2nd spec without paying. Like Mith says, its a Day 1 auto limit on properly testing to the spenders only. That's just a fact. Comparing this to sigils works in one way, as not having the sigils also puts a limit on raid performance with a knock-on to character growth.

Make no mistake, without these IAPs Venan couldn't make as much money and therefore not make much new content. However some of these higher GS costs are just too expensive. Other than reliance on random drops, there is no in-game way to mitigate the higher costs. £ features should be limited to things like extra energy or buying gear/gems in advance rather than earning them through gameplay.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Jul 25, 2013 10:16 am
Arror wrote:
...
One feature that really amazes me is the defense skill, which seems to separate good players from bad ones.

No kidding...timing Defense usage is critical!
I should clarify...I am not a big spender...I haven't purchased GS in months..I'm a free apps downloader...in over a year of playing I've spent around $50.

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu Jul 25, 2013 11:59 pm
I'm glad you are enjoying PvP! After Wednesday's update, match results are looking much more even between the classes. It's still a little skewed for Justicars at the extreme low mights and skewed for Shadow Walkers at the extreme high mights. Overall it's pretty good, but there is still room for improvement. We will still evaluate the data and continue to make changes in the future if necessary. It has taken us many months to finally reach this point, we actually started working on PvP with the ability revamp that introduced procs.

Now, to address some high priority issues:

1) EDIT: We're still working out the details around secondary spec pricing. There are definitely some problems related to how we present the feature. We'll continue to evaluate the necessity of this feature for PVP along with our data and make changes as necessary.

2) We will continue to improve our PvP UI and include things like showing level, class, might, etc. when you get matched up so you all can get a better idea of who you are fighting.

3) Our matchmaking algorithm and performance metric is very BETA right now. We will continue to improve these features in the future like adding a real performance score and make the matchmaking smarter so you get appropriate level fights.

4) We know it's all about the rewards. We pushed out this beta version of PvP so that we could get you all an update as soon as we could. Adding full PvP rewards and features would have added weeks to the development cycle. When the full version of PvP comes out, expect things like gear to improve your PvP capabilities, consumables to make things more interesting (paid with PvP currency most likely), and being able to duel with your friends. (Don't worry PvEers, we are already in production of the continuation of the Vile Gate storyline).

Anyway that's all for now! I can't really get into more details since we still need to flesh out a lot of this stuff. We hope you all will enjoy the Were-Chef seasonal event that's coming up! Thanks for your support and continuing to play our game! :)