Book of Heroes

Official PvP Beta Feedback Thread- ARCHIVED · page 3

I am a 30th level Justicar. (I have played the PvP with all 3 classes, but for this post I am focusing on my Justicar.)

The Shadow Walker seems to have a huge advantage in PvP. They seem to be able to get off several attacks before I can use my fastest attack. Then I get stunned and pushed back before I have even gone once, giving the Shadow Walker more attacks. Their riposte and urgency seem to be kicking in a lot as well.

I haven't noticed my backswing kicking in much, nor do my enhancements seem to be affecting the combat. I have enchanted my gear with knockback resist, accuracy, and status resist. I've been watching for them to take effect, and I haven't resisted any statuses or knockbacks. I also can't seem to penetrate their dodge with accuracy. I realize these percentages are not that high, but I've noticed them taking effect fairly often in the regular game.

I have won a few combats against Shadow Walkers, but those shadow walkers had less HP's than me and seemed to be lower might.

I am built for 2-handed weapon fighting, and 100 gs seems way too much to spend in order to make a second spec. I did purchase a 1-handed weapon and shield, which helped my speed a little, but lowered my damage a lot since my abilities are based around 2-handed fighting.

Otherwise, I have enjoyed the PvP.
Bbbb wrote:Let's see:

Very buggy - not going to bother to list all the bugs I've seen. The worst was after PVP I couldn't enter raids until I restarted the app.

Classes are completely unbalanced (I posted more in another thread).

It's no fun when the battle starts and the opponent gets 4 attacks in a row before you can do anything. I've been on both ends of this.

It's extremely boring when you have an opponent who takes most of the 20 seconds every time. I faced a person like this three times in a row too.

The 100gs price is insane.

I couldn't agree more!!! The lag is ridiculous...Some battles end for no reason and clearly I have lost connection
100gs was a bit much...but other then that I guess if you don't have lag PvP is fun :)
I won't however keep going with PvP until this lag is resolved...might just wait a few weeks b4 I get back to playing BoH, hopefully by then the bugs and issues are addressed
the idea behind the update is good...just needs fixing of certain issues
So, ultimately positive thus far for me. Definitely changes gameplay mechanics around wen facing another player. Have only run on my SW. I have really bad luck against ice mages. My very first match, I was stunned to much I actually got very few hits off. Matches against Justi and SW vary greatly based on the player's preferred play styles. I like being able to see what the opponents are casting to prepare accordingly. As well I like the dangerous side of that as well. You might cast a move that they could screw you over by using something with a shorter cast time. I like juking people out with reflexive strikes. Can be a good time buyer to use in conjunction with cooldowns etc.

I did have my first issue last match where the player was AFK the entire time. His timer kept running out, thus casting Attack each time. Once I finally defeated him, my game then sat with the loading wheel in the corner and never come up with match stats. I finally decided to reset my game and I received nothing from the match. My record even remained as it was before the match occurred.

All I really have to say for now besides great job implementing the new PvP system and I look forward to the changes made to it in the future!

EDIT: I suppose I forgot to mention. The 100GS to unlock the second spec was a bit disappointing. I figured that since that was one of the including new features for Beta, there wouldn't have been such a large gating into the feature. After reading the patch notes, I was very excited to be able to make a second build for PvP with different talents and different gem arrangements (maybe different gems in the future). I was sad to see it was made out of reach for so many.
Not much to complain about but i strongly suggest that the PVP timer be reduce from 20s to 10s
i have encountered it in other game pvp.
some players usually (sore loser) will just let the timer run down if they know they are losing.
that will total piss the other players off. causing the pvp to be very dragy

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Jul 22, 2013 11:50 pm
K_G_Raiden wrote:Not much to complain about but i strongly suggest that the PVP timer be reduce from 20s to 10s
i have encountered it in other game pvp.
some players usually (sore loser) will just let the timer run down if they know they are losing.
that will total piss the other players off. causing the pvp to be very dragy

I recommend against that...several times today I was distracted during a battle, luckily in a few instances I was able to get back to my phone to choose before the timer ran out...had it been any shorter I would have been fubard.

...and on a few occasions I didnt get back in time and I was fubared. :x
Raiden: there needs to be a concede button.

Like MIth, I thought I was clear to play and then the other player was extremely slow and dog or kiddo needed attention.

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Jul 22, 2013 11:59 pm
On the whole Venan, I would say the Beta is a success as far as betas go. I think you got a lot right, despite some glaring issues. Its a good thing and both Fero and I have agreed that your ability to bring new aspect, and difficult aspects, of game play to this game have been impressive....

That being said....a few comments:

I think with tweaking I have gotten a better matchup against justies, but the SW is hopeless.

A few suggestions for balance:

Caltrops: Have too much influence and their cooldown is too short. First off, if I am in a stun, they throw caltrops, its a given effect and I stay in stun. Caltrop cooldown and cast is fast enough that it is a give mitigation for ice shield...every time my ice shield goes up, they throw caltrops...even better if it went up when they stunned me, then they throw caltrops, remove my ice shield while leaving me in stun, and then get a free attack with no protection for myself. I do not know the exact slow down but they also seem to have an inordinate slow down to my timers than when Im chilled by war mages...but that is how it feels...could be wrong there haven't actually measured it.

Ripost: occurs far too often, in effect it is a snapcast, know I dont know the % ripost is supposed to be at but it is a lot more often then a L3 snapcast...very unbalanced.

Smokebomb: too long a knockback. Im ok with Justi Knockback because tey have slower attacks...but SW get 5 attacks (ok a little exaggerated) in the 1 sec they kicked me back.

Urgency: I havent had a battle yet where the SW didnt have a constant Urgency symbol...no wonder the bastages can hit 31 kills on Karnak...everything is urgent to them.

I think in just tweaking some of those items you could bring a lot more balance to the game.

I also suspect that the initial apparent WM slaughter is due to the fact that while the other classes play PvP with very similar gear and rotations to their normal raiding styles, the WM requires a complete re-think on how to use your abilities...it will take most of the BoH WM community aloooong time to figure most of it out...not to mention they need to all buy 1H weapons and reinvest in 1H enchants.


and finally:
PhoenixÆterna wrote:One thing that really bugs me is when I found out HASTE is the most important thing in PvP.
The dev has always neglected to correct one thing, to make MAGIC contribute to DAMAGE POWER of sword.
Mages are downright screwed! If we use sword/shield we get our haste alright, at the expense of having a VERY LOW DAMAGE because we don't invest in melee. WHY? For ALL OUR SKILLS DERIVE THEIR DAMAGE POWER FROM MAGIC!!!! :( :cry:

Mich is right...if you are going to force WM to go 1H, please fix the $%@# weapon!!!!!!
I am still feeling out PvP.

Here my results
Lv 30 Justicar
all opponents were lv 30 and i have only one win. I seem to be two slow against other justy and SW.

Lv 25 Warmage
lost every battle (4) average opponent was 3.75 levels higher than me. I am a two handed WM and i was so slow none of the fights were close. a respec is likely needed to compete.

LV 24 SW
Average opponent was 4 levels above me in 4 fights. my faster abilities gave me a fighting chance here. i did win one fight, two losses were close, and one was a complete mis match. Only win was VS a WM and he was way to slow.

My main gripe. You expect us players to PAY to beta test your game? 100 GS to respect during beta is a slap in the face to the loyal fan base. even if we don't do that we still have to pay to retrain to put a serious effort to test PVP. I understand the 100 GS AFTER the beta test. if you want More meaningful data drop the 100 GS for now and allow people to really try PvP.
Level 30 2H WM here, getting absolutely destroyed by SW and Justis. Even with close to 50% Haste, I'm still not fast enough, and the changes to Ice Lance and Icy Grasp are beyond disappointing. I am 2-9 in PvP, with my 2 wins coming against other 2H WMs. In one battle against a SW with 25k Health (I have just shy of 20k), I literally did not even get one hit in before he completely pantsed me. I am DONE with PvP until something changes - and I'm certainly not paying 100GS for something that's in Beta.

Even more disappointing is the fact that for some ridiculous reason the specs for Ice Lance and Icy Grasp have been changed for non-PvP action - why in God's name was this needed? I've busted by hump getting my little guy to a level that I truly felt was a great balance and something I was excited to raid and quest with, but after these obtrusive changes I feel out-of-sorts with the action and it seems like I'm just pushing the buttons now and dealing with whatever random actions happen as a result.

PvP and PvE are two VERY separate aspects of this game - please restore the original attack settings so that this can continue to be so. I'm trying to be as positive as possible here, but for me right now, the game experience has been completely ruined, and I just can't help but shake the feeling that this was a money-grubbing move on Venan's behalf. I'm not spending another dime in this game until the joy is back.
worked for months on my war mage to progress gear and get max level. was enjoying the game until these nerfs and realizing i am garbage in pvp.

justi hitting me for huge crits, doing 4 or more moves before i even land one?

sw doing the same? my spells soo slow they kill me before i cast anything?

statistics speak. sure, i could spend months regearing/respecing for pvp, but why? why should i waste that time to just be able to compete?

100gs for beta? yea, ok, this app is nearing deletion like my old phone game kingdoms of camelot. lol. deleted and never looked back. they got enough of you hooked on this crap to pay them the profits they need anyways, they dont need me.

30 war mage here, definitely not spending money on this game. almost had me, hah