Noogler wrote:
statistics speak. sure, i could spend months regearing/respecing for pvp, but why? why should i waste that time to just be able to compete?
Because many of those shadow warriors you complain about did exactly that. I've literally spent weeks halting my might growth to grab pvp gems. They were utterly useless in raids, dungeons, portals, everything. But because of that, I'm dominating pvp. Sure, there are some balance issues, and venan has shown they fix those quickly. But every update, there's complainers and quitters. The game fluctuates. If you don't like pvp, don't do it. WMs will be balanced if there is an issue soon enough, and swers or justis will as well. Either way, no reason to ragequit as a result.
Well, currently sitting 22-12 with my level 30 Justicar, and I just have a couple thoughts.
Payout for Victory isn't... rewarding? Like, yes you do get the credit for the win and such, however, the only real payout is 500ish silver. Perhaps putting a treasure chest where randomized loot drops and can give you anything from Gem Shards, Gems, Valor, Gold Shields, Recipes, flux, or really anything there is in the game. Right now, 500 silver is about enough to get you a minor purge rune, which isn't usable in PVP anyways. PVP should be an alternate to PVE when it comes to outfitting your gear.
On that thought, seeing as I'm batting at a 0.54 W/L ratio, I think that how you are performing in PVP might need to be curved towards you moving up. Sure, it's nice to win, but I'd rather win in a narrow amount of HP with my opponent and I at the ropes. And when I lose, I'd like to get a hit in edgewise.
So, might I suggest that your might places you in a tier of what caliber opponents you face, but your W/L ratio then sorts who you're up against, so I'm not the next guy in line to smash the dude who's 0-25, and he's facing the other guy who's 0-13. Everyone needs a win sometimes.
Anyways, that's my $0.02, enjoying the beta so far, looking forward to how the next update goes!
-radarforest
PS. Oh, and feel free to finish the Vile Gate Questline, I was on the edge of my seat for that cliffhanger!
In keeping with previous guideline:
I don't like PvP so far because matchups seem to be tilted towards higher lvl players or players with more might.
Lag time during PvP battles is very disruptive. (There is a blur between when they hit or I hit)
I consider myself a noob at just over 1 month on BoH. Lvl 26 SW heading for max Posion. So far, every PvP I've encountered is a couple of lvls above me and, of course, I have lost every time (0-6). {lag time during PvP encounters doesn't help!]. Several of my Guild-mates have had similar encounters. Granted, I'm not up to lvl on several items, but am over lvl on several as well. Are the pointers for matching set on the wrong parameters? Or maybe there need to be additional criteria to enable more equitable matchups?
Have to surmise that the matching needs some tweaking. Or, is it that too many players have bought higher lvl items with purchased GS? I admit I have bought some, but feel it is not an even battle if it is tilted towards those with the resources to purchase their might as opposed to those who earn it.
Several of us in our guild, Psychosis, are ex Dark Summoner Players who have played that game over the last year. The same problem has almost killed that game. Those who want to play the game on it's own merit end up losing to those with the ability to aquire their strength through purchasing items ahead of earning them.
Hope my fear is unjustified and that these elements can be worked out. I really like BoH. It's like a breath of fresh air after Dark Summoner choked their players abilities to trade/gift and directly interact with each other. Have to admit that one of the pluses about BoH is the Chat function and SUPER support from Mods and Admin. MAJOR KUDOS!
I do know that the recent changes are only in the Beta stage and I really appreciate the way that Venan is up front and communicative with their upgrades. A-Team could learn a lot from you guys!!
Thanks for all you do!!
First, the good stuff: the system works really well. There are plenty of bugs in BoH and here you deliver a beta feature and I don't see any, pretty cool! It's obviously been well tested. I'm also happily surprised at how fast it is to find an opponent.
Now the bad stuff: balance is a catastrophe.
lvl 30 magic sw: win/loss ratio > 2:1 (would be more without disconnections). Considering I have 3 luck enchants and a build optimized to kill mobs, this is way too high. It seems the one I have the most difficulties against are SW, followed closely by Justi. I can kill a mage without getting a single hit, and once again I haven't changed my build from 1.5. Basically with the SW, if I can get to level 3 poison quickly enough, the damage is massive.
lvl 30 1h mage: well, unsurprisingly, I'm getting destroyed. Of course I could respec (I still have my raid build) but that wouldn't be enough. It seems I can only win against a mage. Damage is very low (can't compete with SW) and the lack of knockback makes it impossible to compensate (ice lance doesn't even count). Against a justicar, by the time they finished stun, smite, seismic slash, brutal strike and another attack and I can finally have a change to get a hit, I'm almost lying on the ground.
So I'll be keeping my mage out of PvP until there's a balance change and I'll play a bit with my SW.
In terms of feature, I second the idea of being able to pause for chat. An easy way to whisper the opponent in any case would be nice. 20 seconds is a fine timer, sometimes the network is quite slow (I don't think much can be done about the lag).
I also agree with the idea of adding win/loss ratio in the equation for match making. This will allow everyone to get a better chance and hence reduce a bit the complaints about balance (as I said, it seems my mage can only win against a mage, so I'd be happy to encounter more of them).
Finally, it'd be cool to be allowed to challenge someone directly. I guess you should have in your profile an option saying whether you accept challenges from anyone, from people at similar might, or from no-one.
Once again, I think the mage nerf is a failure but the implementation is really well done for a beta. Kudos for that.
I think there are some balance issues that will become apparent over time. However my 18k melee SW is now 20-13 and more of my losses have been to Mages than anything else. Maybe instead of claiming it's flatly not balanced or 'broken', you could try adapting your play styles, builds and gems? The beta is hours old. It will take weeks to gather any meaningful data. At the minute one bad match and people think the mechanics are broken rather than it just being an outlier (i.e. bad luck). Today I fought a fellow SW and won quite comfortably, but got them again not long afterward and never hit him.
My one request is for a Concede button.
Im sorry, but for an SW to defend the current system is SO NATURAL, why? Because they are dominating the pvp right now with their obvious invincibility.
I had to read the whole thread so I'll know which recurring complaints are being forwarded in this particular forum (as well as on other existing fora regarding pvp). There are some particular issues that The dev is not answering to:
1. The nerfing of spells for WM and,
2. The casting time and consecutive damages that a Justi and most importantly a SW can inflict on a WM.
The reply from the dev was "Oh but I am winning lots and I have a great stats to prove it" ...and stops there...OMG, seriously?
Another thing, they seem to be VERY MUM about people complaining with regards to the 100 gs you need to use for re-spec. Unbelievable. Specially for a BETA update.
Like with other previous players posting on this thread-there is an issue with balancing, do not deny it and a smug reasoning is very infuriating. I'd much rather read a reply that will say, "we take seriously the issue being pointed out and we will continously monitor the beta phase so we can tweak the balancing issues", rather than "oh c'mon, my war mage is so freaking unbelievable my stats are like this". Goodness.
I also just realized that you cannot equip the offhand box as a mage with 2h weapon, Justis and SW have a great advantage here specially if they equip with 4 T5 gemstones, that's a BIG gap. There ought to be an equalizer of sorts. If a mage opts for one hand and a shield, they lose more than half of their affective damage, and even a defense boost with a shield is no match for ensnare, caltrops, poison attacks and smoke bombs. It'll just take longer for them to kill a 1h equipped mage with a shield.
Let's keep in mind it hasn't even been 24 hours yet

Give the poor devs time to gather data and balance accordingly. Mith is doing well as a wm, so it's somewhat doable with the right build. It definitely needs some tweaking, but allow them a chance to work. I'd rather they fix things than spend all day talking. And that's probably what they're doing.
Every WM I've faced with my SW I've dominated. Truly something needs to change for WM's as they have potential to be a strong opponent. However, don't nerf the other classes just buff the ones that need it.