Book of Heroes

Official PvP Beta Feedback Thread- ARCHIVED · page 6

I know we're supposed to be matched with someone of similar level and might, I wondering what similar means. It seems like a broad range.

I have a 30th level Justicar, 10,400 might, with mostly tier 9 and 10 gear and my PvP HP is around 22,000. I've gone up against several opponents with around 25,000 PvP HP and I can tell they have mostly tier 14 gear. I don't stand a chance. That seems like a big difference in might.

I wouldn't mind waiting a little longer to get matched with a more equal opponent.
I want might range to be
Like 1000 maximum

5000might hero fight between 4000-6000 might range

And I want u guys to make us able to choose who we can fight
And that we get rewards such as valor and gold shield
I also like to see some comp for current might
And I wanna see that more quests for pvp from guys other than lady Gwynn

Like deadlus etc and we wanna see (most wanted) fixes in the bugs that take us out of battle

And I want to see some guild that fight other guild in pvp
(Or u guys can make Pve guild war like we fight a boss (lets say goblin king ) ( and we need to defeat him 100 times before the other guild does ---

(I havent read whats before this reply so im just creating what i have while im doing this one lol )
After some more trials in PvP, here are some more long term thoughts.

First, I assume there will be weekly PvP leaderboards with attached rewards, once classes are balanced. I think it’s a great thing to keep people playing PvP. You may however want to clarify how much might difference is allowed - if I get a good record because I was lucky enough to face very weak opponents, it's not very interesting.
You could also have tiers or make sure your score computation doesn’t favour people with the highest might too much (you still need to reward them for being the best obviously).

Second, portals give you essences and fluxes, raids give you valor and tokens, PvP gives you nothing. That means PvP does not help you progress in the game and there isn’t much incentive to keep playing it in the long run (except bragging rights), let alone shield for it.
- It’d be great to add random, low probability drops after one wins. Valor, shards, gold, ht, materials, something new that you can only get in PvP…
- I like the idea of a betting system if it only applies to an opponent you manually pick (I look at people open for bets, I challenge one with a value, they can accept or not) and once you find a way to avoid voluntary desynchronisation.

Right now, the typical fight I’ve seen is: stun, defend, caltrops (if SW), attack, knockback (3 times if justicar!!!), attack again. Then look at the damage, prepare to defend while let the other finally starts playing and see where we both stand once they’ve done the same. I'm starting to see less fights opening with stun so there'll surely be more variety when people learn to play.
Nevertheless, If I resist your stun, I’m almost sure to win. If we fight again and you’re the one resisting me, you’ll win. Resist percentage is quite low (27% with full enchants?) so it’s really a matter of luck, and the probability for both sides to resist the stun in the same game is very low. If the chance to resist was higher, that’d make it less likely for one resist to decide of the winner, since you’d probably have one or more occurrences on both sides during the fight. The fights could be longer and more frustrating, but less subject to pure luck. This is just my two cents, but I've had several wins or losses decided by a resist.

Then… the cost. The dual spec feature is great and I find it normal to pay for it. I also find normal that you have to work on your build and redo it a few times. But 100 gs is quite steep considering that not all classes are equal against it. My SW can live with one build that does great in raids and OK in PvP. My mage has to pay 100gs or give up on either PvP or PvE. A more reasonable price (with a refund to those who paid 100) would be nice. Also, why not make re-spec on the second skill set much cheaper during the beta?

Finally, group PvP has been discussed but I have mixed feelings towards it. Take into account the lag and lack of voice communication between team-mates and I'm not convinced you can pull an interesting implementation.
Romain wrote:stun, defend, caltrops (if SW), attack, knockback

...what's the pointing of defending inbetween?
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Romain wrote:stun, defend, caltrops (if SW), attack, knockback

...what's the pointing of defending inbetween?

lol

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Wed Jul 24, 2013 3:26 am
My suggestion has to do with the dual spec option, and setting a default spec for PvP. First of all, if I set a default spec for PvP, stop asking me every time I enter PvP if I want to actually use my chosen PvP spec. Obviously I do, or I would not have set it as my default. And if I want to change the default, I will do so.

Next, I bought the energy regen enchantment for a ridiculous 375 GS so I could speed up my regen in between raids, or after taking a full dump in a raid. But when I go to PvP and put on my damage gear, my regen gear comes off and I lose the benefits of the 375 GS I spent. As more people realize that health gems are a must for PvP, battles are taking longer and longer. I could be in a battle for 5-10 minutes, and could string together 5 or 6 battles before even using a resovle pot. This is a long time to not have my energy regen gear on and working for me. Then, when I leave PvP, my gear is not automatically swapped back to my pre-PvP gear and I forget to put it back on, and I lose even more time with my regen gear.

You guys have made it clear that PvP is not related to PvE play by giving us a different energy bar with resolve. So why can't my energy regen gear stay "in play" while I do PvP as a completely different part of the game? That way, I don't have to remember to always put it back on when I leave PvP, and I can still benefit from that crazy expensive regen recipe I bought and spent tons of time enchanting. When I leave PvP, I don't need my PvP gear on anymore, so just default me back to my pre-PvP spec.

Also, I haven't confirmed this for sure, but it appears that my health also does not regen while I am in PvP battle. Again, this is separate from PvE so my health should continue to regen while I play a "different game". (If I am mistaken here, let me know and I'll edit this post).
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Romain wrote:stun, defend, caltrops (if SW), attack, knockback
...what's the pointing of defending inbetween?
Reduce the cooldown of the stun by 0.5 sec. I think this is especially useful if you go to level 3 as you re more likely to land a second stun during the fight.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Wed Jul 24, 2013 4:33 am
Romain wrote:
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Romain wrote:stun, defend, caltrops (if SW), attack, knockback
...what's the pointing of defending inbetween?
Reduce the cooldown of the stun by 0.5 sec. I think this is especially useful if you go to level 3 as you re more likely to land a second stun during the fight.

Well hot damn, that's actually pretty genius!
Doctor_Love wrote:
Well hot damn, that's actually pretty genius!
And I guess the reason why there's now a cooldown on defend. Before you could defend 3 times in a row to reduce timers even more and hit only when the stun is about to finish.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Jul 24, 2013 10:34 pm
Excerpt from here: PvP Praise...really a Great Job Venan!!!!!!!!
Now there are a few items I would like to suggest and Ill copy them to the official thread:

1. The Dual Spec- 100GS...look, PvP has a learning curve, not so much for SW, a tad more for Justi but an extremely hard one for WM. There are still too few WM who have figured it out (Droen, Sim0n and Anechi are 3 that come to mind...I hear Japsters doing well but I haven't fought him yet ;) ) You should have realized that PvP Beta needed players to really experiment and play with it...but you put an automatic limit on Beta testing to big spenders...that was a complete SLAP to the face of a lot of players I know who modestly put in $5-$10 every few weeks/months. you alienated a good majority of players who are now justifiably pissed ( I know 3 who have deleted the game from their phones and have mentioned maybe coming back after the bitter taste wears off).

My suggestion: The Beta should have given everyone a new and EXPLICIT PvP Spec, that cost maybe 1 or 2 GS to respec at a time. This Spec would not have been usable in PvE, likewise PvE would not be usable in PvP..they would be isolated...then after everyone has had a chance to spend a few GS and test the beta out, climb the learning curve, THEN you take it away when you move on from beta and add the "Dual Spec"....make it 100GS if you want then, I don't care, but at least by that time everyone would have had a taste of the PvP beta without getting shafted on price. You still could have made your money after releasing the official version because everyone would be more confident in buying a respec for PvP at that point. Full Rant here: viewtopic.php?f=24&t=4080

2. Add a might stat in the PvP arena screen. Just so everyone can be aware that they weren't matched to a 33K brawler when they only had 20k Might. I mention it here in greater detail:
viewtopic.php?f=24&t=4088

Actually a better spot to post your opponents might is on the "versus" screen, when you also flash their win-Loss record.

3. Add a "Training Arena"
It would cost resolve points to enter, but in the training arena you could arbitrarily fight your guild-mates for fun. Matches be damned. The fights wouldn't affect global stats or leader-boards at all, but guildmates could mess around with each other, try new builds, test strategies, help each other out. In this Training arena I would also remove the Decision timer so that they could chat and discuss next moves or evaluate prior moves, also offer an exit button so they could end a match when they were done. Again, its not free, they still spend resolve, and it can't be abused because it has no reward toward feats or stats.

Additional items:

4. I still want a visitor chat channel in guilds. :) I miss the casual visiting days of 1.5 and I still think the community has suffered from the limited social interaction of 1.6.