Book of Heroes

Dodge- 20% Hard Cap Needed · page 2

Whether or not I can use defend on a riposte doesnt really help me all that much. It completely ruins the timing of everything you strategically planned. It crushes WMs and Justicars since they rely on power more than speed. Power takes time. Starting the timers over is hugely in favor of SWs. And I have yet to fight a good SW that has taken riposte off. In fact every day it seems more and more SWs are going heavy dodge and using riposte.
Sokpuppet wrote:Whether or not I can use defend on a riposte doesnt really help me all that much. It completely ruins the timing of everything you strategically planned. It crushes WMs and Justicars since they rely on power more than speed. Power takes time. Starting the timers over is hugely in favor of SWs. And I have yet to fight a good SW that has taken riposte off. In fact every day it seems more and more SWs are going heavy dodge and using riposte.

Justicars rely on power more then speed? Lol that is one of the funniest things I've ever heard. The top justicars are just as fast as SW if not faster but the difference is that they also hit harder and have better defence due to heavy shield.

As for dodge, most of the top players I know agree that it's better to face an attack head on then run the risk of getting hit by backswing.

Justicar attack-SW dodge-backswing(upward of 3k damage)-riposte-defend-SW attack(under 1k damage)

If you're a Mage then dodge can be troublesome but if you're a justicar then it doesn't matter if all your attacks are dodged coz you'll just hit them harder with backswing.
Instead of coming on here with condescending crap like "lol, thats one of the funniest things I've ever heard" maybe you could focus more on the facts and what people can do to improve the game. And to say that Justicars are just as fast if not faster is completely wrong. A full haste justicar is slower than a full haste SW. So what makes up the difference between justicars and SWs? More power for the justicar... So yes, when its justicar vs SW its power vs speed. And maybe if you read my post you wouldnt have bothered with the "Justicar attack-SW dodge-backswing(upward of 3k damage)-riposte-defend-SW attack(under 1k damage)" line since I said its not the current SW attack Im worried about, its the fact that timers are reset which gives an advantage to the faster SW. I'm perfectly fine with backswing being nerfed some, but thats a completely different point. Backswing also doesnt give you the knockbacks you need as a justicar to win the fight. Feel free to continue to be condescending, but if you'd like to discuss it as an adult, I'll be happy to reply. If not, more power to you, enjoy the game.
Sokpuppet wrote:Instead of coming on here with condescending crap like "lol, thats one of the funniest things I've ever heard" maybe you could focus more on the facts and what people can do to improve the game. And to say that Justicars are just as fast if not faster is completely wrong. A full haste justicar is slower than a full haste SW. So what makes up the difference between justicars and SWs? More power for the justicar... So yes, when its justicar vs SW its power vs speed. And maybe if you read my post you wouldnt have bothered with the "Justicar attack-SW dodge-backswing(upward of 3k damage)-riposte-defend-SW attack(under 1k damage)" line since I said its not the current SW attack Im worried about, its the fact that timers are reset which gives an advantage to the faster SW. I'm perfectly fine with backswing being nerfed some, but thats a completely different point. Backswing also doesnt give you the knockbacks you need as a justicar to win the fight. Feel free to continue to be condescending, but if you'd like to discuss it as an adult, I'll be happy to reply. If not, more power to you, enjoy the game.

We are discussing this like adults and that comment wasn't condescending but if you found that to be the case then it's your problem not mine.

If the timers are reset it doesn't favour SW it depends on what skills each player has available. If SW have skills that are faster to cast then they have the advantage if not then the other player will have the advantage.

Justicars already have two knock backs that does damage on hit as well as having the longest pushback times and you are complaining that backswing doesn't give the needed knock back to win.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Aug 7, 2013 11:56 am
Agree with Bane. The timer gets reset, but Riposte is not actually proceeding as it's described if you can block it. If you go too high on dodge, you just get backswing (which you can't dodge, block, or defend either, but nobody seems to want that nerfed). I've fought a mage that dodged a lot of my attacks too, but I didn't think that warranted a dodge nerf. Just made me think 'hm, he's got high dodge'.

SWs need to be fast and have better dodges because their attacks do less damage. One problem is that Justicars have backswing (see above), can be just as fast given the propensity for 1H weapons now, and can equip heavy shields. They don't even need to bother much with dodge.

Dodge should be left alone and focus shifted to areas that are actually unbalanced.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Aug 8, 2013 11:09 am
HearMeRoar wrote:
Gemmed SWs are dodging 70-80% of attacks, which makes them almost unbeatable and heavily luck dependent.

Maximum Dodge from Gems and Tomes is 50% (Dodge Rating Cap, Note 1). This is true of all classes.

Your Dodge Rating is versus a same level opponent. According to PvP chat, the current limit on the matching algorithm is -4 Levels. All classes get +0% to +5% (due to Rating Cap and diminishing returns the higher your Rating) against opponents 4 Levels lower than the character (Note 2).

With Maneuver rank 3 (Dodge +15%), maximum Shadow Walker Dodge is PvP Dodge is 65% or 650 of every 1000 attacks. Maximum Justicar and War Mage Dodge in PvP is 50% or 500 of very 1000 attacks.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
All my characters have decent Dodge from Tomes and Gems. This is especially useful since Venan added Spell Dodge (50% Spell Damage) and improved Defend (Dodge +10%).

Note 1)
Little_Mike wrote:
  • Most percentages computed from stat ratings now follow a curve with diminishing returns on excessively high ratings. This means that adding a specific amount of rating will have lower effect if your rating is already very high. It also means that adding rating will always have some kind of positive effect.
    • Crit Chance: From stat rating: 5%-50%, Hard cap: 100%
    • Crit Power: From stat rating: 150%-200%, Hard cap: 300%
    • Physical Resist: From stat rating: 0%-50%, Hard cap: 90%
    • Magic Resist: From stat rating: 0%-50%, Hard cap: 90%
    • Dodge Chance: From stat rating: 5%-50%, Hard cap: 100%
    • Haste: From stat rating: 0%-50%, Hard cap: 90%
  • Physical/Magic Resist and Armor Defense are no longer additive. They are now multiplied to determine the final amount of damage received. For example, if you have 20% mitigation (80% damage taken) due to Defense and 30% mitigation (70% damage taken) due to Physical Resist, you will take 70% x 80% = 56% damage taken.
Update 1.5 - December 20, 2012

Note 2)
This increases the larger the difference between you an a Monster.