Book of Heroes

Dodge- 20% Hard Cap Needed

Dear Venan,

The current dodge situation is ridiculous. Gemmed SWs are dodging 70-80% of attacks, which makes them almost unbeatable and heavily luck dependent. If you need to buff their damage, so be it, but a dodge cap is needed. 10-20% max. Please make PVP about skill of players and not RNG.

Yours sincerely,

Concerned Player
HearMeRoar wrote:Dear Venan,

The current dodge situation is ridiculous. Gemmed SWs are dodging 70-80% of attacks, which makes them almost unbeatable and heavily luck dependent. If you need to buff their damage, so be it, but a dodge cap is needed. 10-20% max. Please make PVP about skill of players and not RNG.

Yours sincerely,

Concerned Player

I don't dodge anywhere near to 70-80% of attacks.

Anyway it's no different to backswing or ice shield which seem to trigger all the time.
HearMeRoar wrote:Dear Venan,

The current dodge situation is ridiculous. Gemmed SWs are dodging 70-80% of attacks, which makes them almost unbeatable and heavily luck dependent. If you need to buff their damage, so be it, but a dodge cap is needed. 10-20% max. Please make PVP about skill of players and not RNG.

Yours sincerely,

Concerned Player

My dodge is at 51% and I'm dodging close to 30% of the time. Idk if it is base on luck or not, but I'm not getting the full benefits of it. I also changed from armor penetration to accuracy skill. I have accuracy at 13.5% at this moment(this skill reduces the dodging chance of your opponents). I was hitting about 60% of the time and had a record of 201-65. Since I change to accuracy my hitting % has drop drastically. In my last 10 fights I have lost 8 fight vs really sucky players who at this point are dodging 60-70% of my attacks. The reason I got the accuracy skill was to be able to hit more frequently, but I think I'm getting the opposite effect. Just wondering if anyone was having this problem as well.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sat Aug 3, 2013 9:32 pm
I had upped Dodge to 38% and noticed a reasonable increase in my dodging...only to discover I was taking more damage from Justi Backswings, every time I dodge, then I would have in some of the regular attacks...so dodge got the boot.
BaneFirerises wrote:
HearMeRoar wrote:Dear Venan,

The current dodge situation is ridiculous. Gemmed SWs are dodging 70-80% of attacks, which makes them almost unbeatable and heavily luck dependent. If you need to buff their damage, so be it, but a dodge cap is needed. 10-20% max. Please make PVP about skill of players and not RNG.

Yours sincerely,

Concerned Player

I don't dodge anywhere near to 70-80% of attacks.

Anyway it's no different to backswing or ice shield which seem to trigger all the time.

I am talking about SWs that gemmed dodge and have a lot of hero tokens spent on dodge. Virtually unbeatable, and they do dodge 70% of the time at least.

It's very different to backswing and shield because these abilities have a cap, and you can't stack gems or spent hero tokens to go over that cap. SW's dodge ability plus the gems / hero points spent is what makes it so OP.

Please cap dodge, it should be something that happens rarely, just like ice shield.
HearMeRoar wrote:
BaneFirerises wrote:
HearMeRoar wrote:Dear Venan,

The current dodge situation is ridiculous. Gemmed SWs are dodging 70-80% of attacks, which makes them almost unbeatable and heavily luck dependent. If you need to buff their damage, so be it, but a dodge cap is needed. 10-20% max. Please make PVP about skill of players and not RNG.

Yours sincerely,

Concerned Player

I don't dodge anywhere near to 70-80% of attacks.

Anyway it's no different to backswing or ice shield which seem to trigger all the time.

I am talking about SWs that gemmed dodge and have a lot of hero tokens spent on dodge. Virtually unbeatable, and they do dodge 70% of the time at least.

It's very different to backswing and shield because these abilities have a cap, and you can't stack gems or spent hero tokens to go over that cap. SW's dodge ability plus the gems / hero points spent is what makes it so OP.

Please cap dodge, it should be something that happens rarely, just like ice shield.
Are you saying that ice shield happens rarely? No way!! 80% of the time a mage activate those ice shields. It drives me crazy. You hit them with ice shield on and the it reactivate. So what is the point of trying to break the shield? I have encounter mages with over 25k hp and they are unbeatable. It is almost impossible to hit a mage with my strong attack. And there are also mages out there dodging over 40%. I think evey class has its ups and downs. And this pvp matches are also base on how lucky you are. I have encounter justicars that always resist my ensnare. I'm talking about fighting the same guy twice in a row and resisting ensnare over 6 times. Ohh and also catacolps.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Aug 5, 2013 11:16 am
Gemmed SWs are dodging 70-80% of attacks

You mean they're dodging 70-80% of your attacks. Dodge can be high on any character, both from HT and gems. If your opponents have high dodge, they sacrificed gems elsewhere.
Of course all classes are able to gem up in dodge, but the riposte ability for the SW makes them completely OP for someone who has taken the time to load up on dodge gems. I know I have criticized SWs for being overpowered in the past and I agree that the gap seems to be lessening as most players are finally able to switch to 1H weapons. But now that SWs are learning that the dodge/riposte combo is so powerful the gap is increasing again. I really would like to see this issue addressed and would love opinions from SWs as well as Justis and WMs. (as long as you can attempt to be unbiased) There are SWs that I've fought many times who must have dodges well over 50% (im making an assumption on a small amount of data I know) who are unstoppable for me. In back to back fights I was dodged 12 and then 13 times. (I started counting SW dodges when i started noticing the dodge/riposte trend) It takes all the strategy out of the fight. Based on current timers I can try to come up with a series of hits to counter what I know my opponent has available to him at the time and what I know he will have available to him over the next couple of turns. a dodge/riposte wipes all that out and then you're left with 0.00 timers which will always favor the quicker SW. I'd love to hear any ideas any of you may have to help counteract this. I would really love to hear from a dev on this issue if its possible but I know they're busy.
Sokpuppet wrote:Of course all classes are able to gem up in dodge, but the riposte ability for the SW makes them completely OP for someone who has taken the time to load up on dodge gems. I know I have criticized SWs for being overpowered in the past and I agree that the gap seems to be lessening as most players are finally able to switch to 1H weapons. But now that SWs are learning that the dodge/riposte combo is so powerful the gap is increasing again. I really would like to see this issue addressed and would love opinions from SWs as well as Justis and WMs. (as long as you can attempt to be unbiased) There are SWs that I've fought many times who must have dodges well over 50% (im making an assumption on a small amount of data I know) who are unstoppable for me. In back to back fights I was dodged 12 and then 13 times. (I started counting SW dodges when i started noticing the dodge/riposte trend) It takes all the strategy out of the fight. Based on current timers I can try to come up with a series of hits to counter what I know my opponent has available to him at the time and what I know he will have available to him over the next couple of turns. a dodge/riposte wipes all that out and then you're left with 0.00 timers which will always favor the quicker SW. I'd love to hear any ideas any of you may have to help counteract this. I would really love to hear from a dev on this issue if its possible but I know they're busy.

The thing about riposte is that it gives you a chance to chose an action before it hits because it only reduces the timer to 0.00 instead of completing the action immediately. Most players block before the action that is being riposted hits and I know players who are dropping maneuver and riposte from their skill set solely because of this so it's not overpowered like you are saying.

If anything is overpowered it's backswing can't be blocked and will always hit when it triggers and it hits hard(I've been hit by an 9k backswing after dodging wound WTF?)