Book of Heroes

Clean up guild chat · page 2

My opinion is get rid of the children..make a version that is iap-free for kids..and for adults with credit card get to not only spend money but say what they want..
I, too, was a little concerned about the language in some of the guild chat rooms, as my son (age 10) & nephew (age 11) have now started to play.

My solution was to create a G-rated guild as an offshoot for Natchys, called Friends_of_Natchys. As GM, I will boot anyone that gets out-of-line. Also, I try to always raid with them, so that I can monitor the mercs.

FYI - If any of you have kids & want a G-rated guild. Friends_of_Natchys welcomes all.

Darkhorse

Site AdminMon Dec 16, 2013 8:21 pm
All good points here.

The approach we take to this is that guilds can decide what kind of language and content they would like in their guilds, and it is up to their officers and GM to allow or not allow users into that guild who break their rules or standards.

That being said, harassment or hate speech is not tolerated under any chat circumstances.
Darkhorse wrote:
The approach we take to this is that guilds can decide what kind of language and content they would like in their guilds, and it is up to their officers and GM to allow or not allow users into that guild who break their rules or standards.

One thing tho, GMs and officers or any guild member have no real idea of the age of our guildies unless they choose to share. Minors may not be willing to tell the truth about it for whatever reason; they're so cool, they don't want to get booted, whatever. So the probability of children being witness to adult chat is actually very high, and it's pretty much definite that it's happened without the GM or officers of a guild knowing. Even knowing this, adult chat guilds are not gonna restrict their chat to discussions about My Little Pony, or debates about which smurf is the cutest.

If there is some way to have users mandatorily input their age into the account, again, obviously something very easy to circumvent, it would help those adults who do want to play the game the way we want, yet protect young eyes from our, sometimes very intense chat. I have to assume Venan has thought about this before, and I have no clue the difficulty of adding it to the system. But, we should try to protect young minds as long as we can.
Darkhorse wrote:All good points here.

The approach we take to this is that guilds can decide what kind of language and content they would like in their guilds, and it is up to their officers and GM to allow or not allow users into that guild who break their rules or standards.

That being said, harassment or hate speech is not tolerated under any chat circumstances.

Then what happened to the cases I reported people to Venan on when they were make horrible remarks either thinking they were funny or attacking me personally in a whisper chat? Specific names Heach of Crusaders and Johnny something of Virtue.
Puff wrote:
Darkhorse wrote:All good points here.

The approach we take to this is that guilds can decide what kind of language and content they would like in their guilds, and it is up to their officers and GM to allow or not allow users into that guild who break their rules or standards.

That being said, harassment or hate speech is not tolerated under any chat circumstances.

Then what happened to the cases I reported people to Venan on when they were make horrible remarks either thinking they were funny or attacking me personally in a whisper chat? Specific names Heach of Crusaders and Johnny something of Virtue.

The GM in both cases knows and knew what was said yet did nothing. I actually left Crusaders because of it.
I believe you about the Crusaders after what I saw today - racism, comparisons to hitler, insults to Christopher Columbus' brain power, etc. OTOH I have spent a lot of time in Virtue and it has always been pleasant. Must have been one bad seed.
Darkhorse wrote:All good points here.

The approach we take to this is that guilds can decide what kind of language and content they would like in their guilds, and it is up to their officers and GM to allow or not allow users into that guild who break their rules or standards.

That being said, harassment or hate speech is not tolerated under any chat circumstances.

I think it is one thing for guilds to specify that they are not G-rated.
In such cases, parents can check in from time to time to see which guild the child is in.

However, it is harder when children raid with over-18 guilds.
There is no way for child or guild to know that the other is not age-appropriate.
When the child raids with them, they have immediate access to chat logs of the guild, even from before the raid started.

One solution could be: don't merc. But that can make it rather difficult for kids to find a age-appropriate guild whose raid times match their play times.

Venan may wish to consider truncating the Guild chat log for mercs such that they are only able to see what is said after they have joined the raid.
Guilds can then take on the responsibility to ensure that guildies do not make age-inappropriate comments once the raid is open to mercs.

A better solution would be if we could flag either or both over-18 guilds as well as minors in the game.

But failing that, truncating the chat log would at least ensure that kids don't merc a raid and suddenly find out that they walked into a sexting contest.
CarlosDanger wrote:I believe you about the Crusaders after what I saw today - racism, comparisons to hitler, insults to Christopher Columbus' brain power, etc. OTOH I have spent a lot of time in Virtue and it has always been pleasant. Must have been one bad seed.


To be fair, Crusaders does advertise (both recruiting and mercs) as 'explicit chat'. They don't pretend to be anything other than what they are.

Comparing people/organisations to Hitler is a time-honoured internet tradition - Godwin's Law* was applied in internet forums 20+ years ago... And many historians are less than complimentary about Columbus. Neither of these strike me as anything to get particularly hot and bothered about.
Racist stuff is another matter, but I didn't see what was said so obv can't comment there.


*In case you're not familiar with Godwin's Law, the essence of it is that the longer a discussion continues, the higher the chance of Hitler/Nazi comparisons becomes, and that the first person in an argument to reference Hitler/Nazis etc automatically loses (assuming that it's not an appropriate discussion for such comparisons):
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law